Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

PHILIPPINES: Unresolved Gulf War Claims Recalled as New War Looms

Marites Sison

MANILA, Feb 6 2003 (IPS) - As the U.S.-led war against Iraq looms and plans are drawn up for the evacuation of Filipinos working in the Middle East, those who suffered from the effects of the 1990 Gulf War and have not been compensated to this day fear the worst: that they will be forgotten.

"The payment of claims will be further delayed when the new war breaks out. And then, of course, there will be a new set of victims," said Roy Anunciacion, campaign officer of Migrante International, a non-government group that has been helping Gulf War claimants.

The United Nations established a compensation commission in 1995 to handle the compensation claims from 100 different countries, including the Philippines, whose workers had to abandon jobs and livelihoods after Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait and the subsequent liberation of Kuwait by the United States.

Around 50,000 Filipino workers, mostly domestic workers and hospital staff, were displaced by that conflict. Filipinos are among the biggest number of foreign workers in the Middle East, which is home to 1.5 million of them spread across the Middle East.

Up to now, however, more than 2,000 workers who have filed war reparation claims before the Philippine Claims and Compensation Committee, a body set up by the country’s foreign affairs department to process the disbursement of the U.N. funds, have yet to receive their checks, according to Anunciacion.

This figure does not include those who are not aware that they are entitled to such individual claims, which range from 2,500 to 100,000 U.S. dollars, or who were late in filing their claims because of lack of information.

An estimated 15,000 Filipino workers displaced by the war are believed to fall under this category. Thus far, the United Nations has agreed to review the cases of those who filed past the Jan.1, 1995 deadline, but officials conceded that the funds are already running low.

But the attention to unfinished war claims also brings out a larger issue here, especially as some expect an upcoming war to be longer and possibly triggering a conflagration in the entire Middle East.

Analysts have questioned the wisdom of President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s decision to throw her support behind U.S. President George W Bush – and expose Filipino workers to high risk, when the dislocation and danger caused by a war can already be seen from the 1990 conflict.

"We continue to treat the issue primarily in terms of our commitment to the American-led war on terrorism, forgetting that a million Filipino workers face danger once the war explodes in the Middle East," wrote Randolf David, political analyst and columnist with the English-language daily ‘Philippine Daily Inquirer’.

”Whatever motives the United States may have for wanting to invade Iraq – and we have heard all kinds of conflicting explanations – our own are simple and straightforward. We have people working in the region, and it is our duty to look after them,” he argued. ”We are not at war with Iraq."

”This is going to have a more serious and wider impact on our overseas Filipino workers. We are not just talking about (the war spreading) along the borders of Iraq. Many Arabs are upset,” added Anunciacion.

Arroyo flew to Kuwait earlier this week to assure Filipino workers that her government was prepared to evacuate them if and when the need arises. While Arroyo’s concern for the workers was lauded by some quarters, still many believed the better option would have been for her to declare a neutral position on the planned attack against Iraq.

"You cannot fax an assurance, you cannot e-mail a helping hand in an hour of grief, or anxiety. There is a difference between sending a message of hope to the overseas Filipino workers to be read by envoys, and being there to deliver it yourself. Ms Macapagal did well to choose the latter," said ‘Inquirer’ columnist Conrado de Quiros.

"But that’s about all the good you can say about it. Ms Macapagal’s message itself gives out a false hope, and should prove exceptionally cruel if war should break out in Iraq. How can she guarantee that no Filipino will not get hurt in that war or lose his job by it?” he asked.

Meantime, the distribution of the compensation from the 1990 Gulf War continues to be marred by allegations of corruption, misuse and mismanagement.

In 1999, migrant workers groups accused some officials at the foreign affairs department of "profiteering" at the expense of Filipino migrant workers, whose receipt of checks were unduly delayed. The foreign affairs department denied the allegations, saying the verification of documents was causing the slow processing of claims.

When the Arroyo government was installed in 2001, migrant workers petitioned her to address the unresolved issue. In a meeting at the presidential palace, representatives from the Filipinos’ Gulf War Claimants Club presented Arroyo with documents backing their allegations.

"We have been victims of corrupt practices of certain officials manning the Philippine Claims and Compensation Committee," the group had said in a letter addressed to Arroyo.

The group claimed that some officials had deposited the funds into their own dollar time deposit accounts, hence the delay in the release of checks to claimants.

Some claimants have also been given "non-compensated status" because others supposedly claimed their checks. "A lot of the cases even go as far back as 1993 to 1995, when claimants’ papers were unattended by foreign affairs officials,” the group said.

Arroyo had promised to act on the complaints about compensation claims. But up to now said Anunciacion, there has been little progress, with preparations are focused now on the war against Iraq.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags