Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

MIDDLE EAST: Put peace above the roadmap, says UAE daily

Att.Editors: The following item is by the United Arab Emirates news agency (WAM)

ABU DHABI, Apr 21 2003 (IPS) - A major United Arab Emirates (UAE) English daily today urged all the parties concerned in the – roadmap" to peace in the Middle East to show good faith in implementing existing plans instead of drawing more.

It said only good faith can resolve the Arab-Israeli conflict and bring peace and stability to the Middle East.

Commenting editorially in its issue of today under the topic – Put peace above the roadmap", the Dubai-based ‘Gulf News’ said in part: ôArabs and Israelis pinned great hope on the long-awaited ‘roadmap’, authored by the so-called ‘Quartet’. Both sides were hopeful it would bring a just and comprehensive settlement to the 55-year-old Arab-Israeli conflict. But, unfortunately, the draft text of the plan, published in ‘Gulf News’ on Thursday, shows that it takes the conflict nowhere but to more injustice and uncertainty.

ôIt adds more to the rhetoric already surrounding this conflict instead of finding an effective mechanism to implement the related Security Council resolutions 242, 338, and 1397, which guarantee the full rights of the conflicting parties. Although it has been described by its authors as a ‘performance-based and goal-driven roadmap, with clear phases, time-lines, target dates and benchmarks’, the roadmap provides no guarantee whatsoever that the parties concerned would implement it.

ôIt has been so far delayed three times by Israel, which failed to even announce its initial approval of the publication of the plan. Hence, by failing to stop aggression and violence against Palestinians and deliberately destroying their homes and institutions, Israel has succeeded in eliminating the first phase of the roadmap before it was even born. The roadmap calls for ‘Ending terror and violence, normalizing life and building institutions by May, 2003′.

ôEven by declaring its destination as ‘a final and comprehensive settlement of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict by 2005", the roadmap seems to be illogical and impractical since it isolates the conflict between Palestinians and Israelis from its general context of the Arab-Israeli conflict. One wonders how Palestinians can establish their independent state with its ‘provisional borders’, while Israel continues to occupy lands in Syria and Lebanon where hundreds of thousands of Palestinian refugees live!

ôMore importantly, the roadmap leaves all the central issues unresolved for Phase III: borders, occupied Jerusalem, refugees, colonies, and other aspects of the Arab-Israeli conflict. If ending violence, achieving normalization between Palestinians and Israelis needs two years to achieve, then how can one understand that all other major issues mentioned above could be settled in one year!

ôIf the Quartet can provide assistance and facilities to implement the plan, can it guarantee that Israel will comply with the obligations outlined in the plan? Israel’s failure to accept the plan without any modifications, and the inability of the Quartet to force it to implement the plan will remain the biggest challenge the roadmap will face.

ôThe roadmap uses the same phrases used for years to describe the Arab-Israeli conflict. However, it offers very little on how this conflict can be solved. It stresses the importance of having ‘an agreed and realistic solution to the refugee issue, and a negotiated resolution on the status of occupied Jerusalem,’ but it ignores the fact that Arabs and Israelis have been negotiating even simpler issues for years without reaching any tangible results, thanks to Israeli intransigence and the lack of an effective mechanism to settle this conflict.

ôThe roadmap is a combination of great efforts made by many individuals, organizations, groups and countries over the years to find a peaceful settlement to the Arab-Israeli conflict. However, achieving peace in the region needs the good faith of the parties concerned and a clear mechanism to implement existing plans instead of drawing more plans.

ôIt is the destination that counts, not the roadmap, it is peace rather than the road to peace that Arabs and Israelis really need," concluded the daily.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags