Headlines, Human Rights, North America

SOCIETY-U.S.: Muslims Take Lead in Educating Citizens

Ushani Agalawatta

NEW YORK, Jun 27 2003 (IPS) - In response to the crackdown on members of their communities after Sep. 11, 2001, Arab and Muslim-American groups are striving to demonstrate to people here that there is a difference between a terrorist and a person of Arab, Muslim, Middle Eastern or South Asian descent.

A year long ‘Islam in America’ advertising campaign, a weekly talk show, as well as numerous resources prepared for schools, law enforcement agencies, employers and parents are just a few of the initiatives undertaken by these organisations.

The non-profit Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) recently launched a year-long advertising campaign to raise awareness about the face of Islam in America.

The first ad, run by the ‘New York Times’ in February, featured three individuals of different ethnic backgrounds with the caption, ”We’re all Americans, but which one of us is Muslim?”

Answering, ”We all are”, the ad explains, ”It’s impossible to make general assumptions about Muslims because we represent more than one billion people from a range of races, nationalities, and cultures – from the South Pacific to the Horn of Africa.”

CAIR spokesperson Ibrahim Hooper told IPS, ”the campaign was prompted by the misinformation about Islam and Muslims that we hear on a daily basis from a number of sources, particularly right-wing, evangelical and pro-Israel circles, bashing Islam, bashing Muslims and creating a distorted picture of the reality of, particularly, the American Muslim experience”.


”The reality of the American Muslim experience is that they are millions of people going about their daily lives as mothers fathers, students, bus drivers, doctors, soccer moms, you name it, and will never come within a hundred miles of any act of violence or political instability within their entire lives,” added Hooper, whose group has headquarters in Washington DC and chapters country-wide.

Since 9/11, Arab, Muslim and South Asian communities have been under duress, marginalized and victimised in President George W Bush’s ”war against terrorism”. Hate crimes, discrimination and public hostility are making individuals from these groups secondary victims of the terrorist attacks, according to spokespeople.

”The climate in the U.S. towards Arabs and Muslims, including persons perceived to be Arab and/or Muslim, can best be described as intimidating,” said Laila Al-Qatami, spokeswoman for the American-Arab Anti Discrimination Committee (ADC), which calls itself the largest grassroots Arab-American civil rights group.

”While official statements coming from the administration and other officials are generally of a tolerant and inclusive nature, many of the policies instituted by the U.S. Department of Justice reflect an entirely different reality, a reality that is not as welcoming and tolerant.”

Earlier this month the inspector general of the Justice Department released a report that evaluated treatment of INS detainees after 9/11. The IG criticised the length and ”unduly harsh conditions” of confinement of the more than 750 people held in Brooklyn and New Jersey after the terrorist attacks.

Earlier this week, the Justice Department issued guidelines that ban federal employees from racial profiling in day-to-day situations, such as random traffic checks. But it said ”race and ethnicity may be used in terrorist identification, but only to the extent permitted by the nation’s laws and the Constitution”.

Al-Qatami told IPS that the civil society groups’ latest activities are imperative to promoting and protecting the rights of Arab, Arab-American, Muslim and Muslim-American communities in the United States.

Added Hooper: ”Any law is fine as long as it does not single out people based on their race, religion, ethnicity or national origin. Unfortunately we are seeing all too many policies that are based on those factors and that is what is disturbing.”

CAIR says its ad campaign and TV show are a success. ”Both projects have been received very well by the Muslim and non-Muslim community. CNN featured our ad campaign on one of their shows and invited Ibrahim Hooper to talk about it. We have hundreds of testimonies from a variety of people who appreciate and welcome the campaign,” says Rabiah Ahmed, CAIR communications coordinator.

”The show is also doing well. Many Muslims write in from around the world saying that it’s about time that Muslim Americans have a show discussing issues affecting them and other minorities,” adds Ahmed.

That echoes the comment of an observer who has studied U.S. Muslim and Arab communities since 9/11.

”The experience of Muslim and Arab communities post-Sep. 11 is, in many ways, an impressive story of a community that first felt intimidated, but has since started to assert its place in the American body politic,” said Muzaffar Chishti, a senior fellow at the Migration Policy Institute and co-author of a report, released Thursday, on authorities’ treatment of members of those groups and its effects to date.

But some people question if the groups’ public relations efforts can work. For instance, Professor Khalid Abu Alfadhl of the UCLA School of Law says the ad campaign is well-intended, but he doubts it will make a ”significant difference in how Islam is viewed by non-Muslims".

”Muslims are not the only minority group in America to have faced hostility,” adds Abu Alfadhl, a Muslim American, in an interview with Voice of America.

”During the major Jewish migration to the United States, which was in the 1800s, there was widespread hostility towards Jews. Also, Chinese Americans had a very negative image in the late 1800s and early 1900s.”

But, he adds, "Muslim Americans have an added difficulty – their historical legacy. Muslims and Christians have fought in years past; some people believe they might always be enemies."

But the organisations say it is their responsibility to educate and solidify their communities’ places in U.S. society, and that the administration should also play a role.

‘We welcome government initiatives that are well thought out,” said Hooper.. ”After all, the ad campaign launched by CAIR in the United States is similar to the advertising promoted by the U.S. government in the Middle East.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags