Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

POLITICS-CANADA: Native Audit Law Unlikely to Pass Muster

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Jul 9 2003 (IPS) - The leader of Canada’s largest aboriginal association says he expects a new law that would tightly regulate financial actions of Native communities will fail to pass this country’s Parliament.

The law was a keystone of the legislative program of retiring Prime Minister Jean Chretien, but is opposed by the front-runner for Chretien’s job.

Paul Martin, who is expected to become prime minister late this year or early in 2004, says he does not support the First Nations Governance Act, a law that would give the government greatly increased power to audit the spending by Native groups.

The law would impose government-appointed auditors and a new financial management system on all reservations that receive government funding. The government says some Native communities have no control over spending.

Each native reserve elects its own band council, which, under the present regime, is financially autonomous. Supporters of the proposed law say it will end corruption and nepotism on native reserves.

Native leaders say they want an accountability system run by aboriginals, not by the government.


Matthew Coon Come, grand chief of The Assembly of First Nations, which represents most of the country’s native reserve band councils, says the proposed law "has fallen off the table, and it won’t be an issue for the future Prime Minister, because of the statement that he would not implement it. If he were to reintroduce it, we will take him to task."

Coon Come says the Canadian government "should spend more time implementing treaties and solving land disputes" than on trying to regulate Native representatives.

The bill is opposed by all but one of the country’s five major First Nations group. An association representing natives and mixed-race people who do not live on reserves supports the Chretien government’s initiative.

Coon Come says he is not trying to protect crooked native leaders. He argues the bill imposes a nationwide regimen on some 400 very diverse native communities.

"We need to have respect for diversity. There’s no one-size-fits-all legislation. If you want to do something, you have to do something that has never been done, which is set a timetable for negotiations, and the implementation of treaties, which would eventually replace the Indian Act

"The (1999) Royal Commission on Aboriginal People had over 400 recommendations, including an aboriginal Auditor General to develop administrative by-laws and reporting requirements," he said.

Coon Come says a native auditor and aboriginal-run accounting system would be accepted by native leaders, but one imposed by the federal government "reeks of colonialism."

Federal New Democratic Party MP Pat Martin has helped stonewall the legislation as it worked its way through the parliamentary committee system. He joined with other MPs to prevent the bill from passing until, at least, the fall.

"It’s a throwback to the century before last in terms of its content, and it so offended First Nations peoples across this country that no attempt should be made to bring it back without serious revisions," Martin says.

"The animosity across the country was escalating, and it was doing permanent damage to the relationship between First Nations and the government."

Indian Affairs Minister Bob Nault says the bill may still make it through Parliament. "I’m very confident it will be on the agenda this fall,’ he said.

He argues "many First Nations people are too frightened to speak of their support of the Bill for fear of reprisals." In a recent speech, he declared the Assembly of First Nations to be "ineffective, irrelevant" and "structurally incapable of working with the government."

The fight between the Assembly of First Nations, an organisation that used to be on good terms with the national government and even took part in constitutional amendment negotiation sessions, and the federal minister probably will end when the assembly picks a new grand chief in August or when the next prime minister appoints a new Indian Affairs minister.

"Maybe, with new leadership in the federal government, we’ll see a law that is workable and fair," Coon Come said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags