Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS: Defenders Thwarted by Anti-Terrorist Laws – Report

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Nov 11 2003 (IPS) - Hina Jilani, whose U.N. mandate is to protect the world’s human rights defenders, believes that support for human rights worldwide continues to be eroded by a rash of new anti-terrorist laws that threaten civil liberties and the rule of law.

These domestic laws are being used ”to criminalize accepted forms of dissent and suppress the right to hold governments accountable,” she told IPS.

In a new report to the 191-member U.N. General Assembly, Jilani says such security legislation has resulted in ”deplorable violations of international human rights law, are extremely damaging to international peace and security, and are in fact harmful to counter-terrorism efforts”.

Jilani who – as U.N. special representative on human rights defenders has antagonised several member states, been publicly denounced by a head of government, and barred from visiting at least one Asian country – named several countries, including Australia, Canada, India, Nepal, Pakistan, Russia, South Africa and Thailand, which have either enacted or are contemplating new anti-terrorism laws that violate basic human rights.

”Despite protection under international and regional human rights instruments and national constitutions, the right to freedom of expression has suffered the most severely due to the adverse impact of restrictions imposed by national security or anti-terrorism laws,” she said in a 24-page report on defenders released here.

The study says that security legislation and states of emergency represent contexts in which human rights work is increasingly restricted and defenders targeted.


”Both are used as a smokescreen to allow dereliction from human rights obligations and the persecution of defenders. These acts harm the genuine struggle to prevent and end terrorism,” it warns.

Jilani said human rights defenders include a wide range of people, including lawyers, journalists, representatives of NGOs and political activists.

In an interview, she specifically singled out the USA Patriot Act as a new law under which rights defenders are finding it increasingly difficult to perform their twin functions of monitoring and promoting human rights.

That is because access to information and freedom of expression are both restricted by the controversial U.S. law, the brainchild of Attorney General John Ashcroft.

”Human rights are indivisible. You cannot say: ‘I am protecting this human right, but I am violating the other’,” Jilani said.

The New York-based Centre for Constitutional Rights (CCR) and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) have legally challenged the constitutionality of the Patriot Act, which has been described as one of the most insidious pieces of legislation in the United States.

It was conceived in the name of fighting terrorism following the September 2001 terrorist attacks on the United States.

At a seminar at the U.S.-based Carter Centre on Tuesday, former U.S. president Jimmy Carter said that while it is natural to want to defend people, the Bush administration’s post-9/11 laws have ”worked against the spirit of human rights”.

”We have encouraged governments to tighten up on state control – and freedom of speech,” he said.

In a report released Tuesday, the Carter Centre criticised two countries – Eritrea and Colombia – for violating civil liberties under the guise of fighting terrorism.

Asked if any of the world’s authoritarian regimes have used the Patriot Act as a model for their own repressive legislation, Jilani said the opposite was true – ”the United States has taken the worst practices of these countries and incorporated them into the USA Patriot Act”.

She said she would like to dispel the impression that the United States is necessarily seen as the defender and champion of human rights the world over. ”It may see itself as one. But that ‘s another question altogether,” she added.

Jilani said the objective of her U.N. mandate ”is not just finger pointing but to hold constructive dialogues with governments”.

”But that does not mean we cannot raise issues,” she added.

So far, she has been barred from only one country: Indonesia. But Jilani said others have turned down her request for visits by not responding to her letters. ”I find that regrettable.”

After a 10-day visit to Thailand last May, Jilani was critical of the ”climate of fear” created by public statements against non-governmental organisations (NGOs) by high-level government officials.

”I have sensed a level of insecurity among human rights defenders (in Thailand) which ranges from general unease to actual fear,” she said.

”The basic support I look for is the support of the international community,” she added. ”The United Nations is therefore an essential organ. It is very important that if human rights defenders are to feel protected, the international community should stand behind them.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags