Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights, North America

POLITICS: Canadian Justice New U.N. Human Rights Czar

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Feb 20 2004 (IPS) - A sitting justice of the Supreme Court of Canada was nominated Friday to one of the most politically sensitive jobs at the United Nations: high commissioner for human rights (UNHCHR).

Justice Louise Arbour, who served as chief prosecutor for the international criminal tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and for Rwanda, is expected to take up the appointment in June, when she is due to retire from the Canadian court.

Her nomination by U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan, which has to be endorsed by the 191-member General Assembly, drew strong positive responses from the two major international human rights organisations: Amnesty International (AI) and Human Rights Watch (HRW).

”The U.N. human rights system could not hope for a better leader at a time that it is under unprecedented attack,” said HRW Executive Director Kenneth Roth.

”Louise Arbour’s broad human rights background, distinguished legal career and service as U.N. prosecutor give her the experience to be both bold and creative in promoting and protecting human rights,” Irene Khan, AI secretary-general, said in a statement released Friday.

As the U.N.’s chief advocate for human rights, Arbour must be prepared to speak out forcefully when diplomacy fails, Khan said.


Speaking on condition of anonymity, a senior Asian diplomat told IPS, ”we hope she will be as forthright as Mary Robinson – and would not hesitate to stand up to the big powers. She will certainly be measured by the standards set by Robinson.”

Robinson, a former Irish president who served as high commissioner from September 1997 to September 2002, was given a one-year extension beyond her four-year term in office.

She offered her services for a further period, but Annan did not re-appoint her, primarily because of strong U.S. pressure.

The administration of President George W. Bush was livid about Robinson’s strong criticisms of U.S. human rights policies in the aftermath of the terror attacks on New York and the Pentagon in September 2001.

She was particularly critical of human rights abuses of suspected al-Qaeda terrorists held by the United States in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

Robinson also publicly deplored the growing anti-Islamic, anti-Arab and anti-Semitic sentiments in the wake of 9/11. She called on the international community to combat the spread of ”Islamaphobia” – an obsessive fear of Islam that has spread mostly throughout the United States and Western Europe.

HRW Advocacy Director Reed Brody said at the time that Robinson’s re-nomination for a full second term was opposed by Washington. ”Mary Robinson paid a price for her willingness to stand up to powerful governments that violate human rights,” he added.

In her statement Friday, AI’s Khan said, "human rights abuses must be confronted wherever they occur and regardless of any country’s economic or political weight".

In a newspaper interview last year, Robinson broke her silence, saying she indicated before her four-year term ended in 2001 that she would not be seeking re-appointment.

”I was then persuaded by Kofi Annan himself and by grassroots human rights people to continue for a further year. And when the terrible attacks took place on Sep. 11, and I saw the difficult aftermath, I felt I am not somebody who leaves a position when things get even tougher.”

Robinson said she then ”indicated quietly to the secretary-general” that if he wanted her to stay for another term, ”I would be certainly open to consider that”.

According to Robinson, Annan consulted with other member states about the offer, and was told by U.S. officials, ”no, she’s too critical”.

Asked about the process of appointing a new commissioner, U.N. spokesman Fred Eckhard told reporters Friday the first step was for Annan to consult with the U.N. Human Rights Commission in Geneva, the supreme inter-governmental human rights body.

After briefing the commission, Annan next met with the chairs of the five regional groups at the United Nations, he added.

The next step will be for the secretary-general to send a letter to the General Assembly requesting its members approve his appointment. This is expected to take place soon, possibly in the next two weeks, added Eckhard.

The 57-year-old Arbour will succeed the late Sergio Vieira de Mello of Brazil, who, while he was high commissioner, was temporarily seconded as the U.N. special representative in Iraq.

Vieira de Mello died along with 21 others in a terrorist attack on the U.N. compound in Baghdad in August 2003.

Human rights receives a tiny portion of the overall U.N. budget, averaging about two percent of the three-billion-dollar biannual spending.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags