Thursday, November 19, 2026
Thalif Deen
- Upstaging longstanding claims by its regional rivals Argentina and Mexico, Brazil publicly re-asserted its “legitimate right to demand” a permanent seat in the 15-member U.N. Security Council.
“The largest country in South America has a rightful claim to be a permanent member,” Brazilian President Luis Inacio Lula da Silva told reporters Thursday.
A country with a population of 178 million people, Brazil shares boundaries with every single South American country except Chile and Ecuador.
For nearly 60 years, the president said, the United Nations has remained static. “It has to change. It has to become more democratic and it has to adapt itself to the political realities of today,” he added.
The dominance of the world’s five declared nuclear powers as veto-wielding permanent members – the United States, Britain, France, China and Russia – has been criticised over the years, primarily because the overwhelming majority of member states from developing nations have been shut out of the Security Council’s inner sanctum.
“There has to be equal participation,” the Brazilian president said, “and countries from South America, Asia and Africa have the right to be permanent members of the Council.”
The United Nations has been debating the reform and restructuring of the Security Council for over 10 years now. But a proposal for expanding the Council beyond the current five permanent members has remained stalemated for several reasons.
The African seat has been claimed at least by three countries in the region: South Africa, Nigeria and Egypt. The strongest contender for the Asian seat has been India, with a possible challenge by Indonesia.
Brazil has remained the front-runner for the South American seat, which has also been claimed, at various times, by Argentina and Mexico.
Besides regional representation from the developing world, two other member states have claimed their right to permanent seats in the Council: Japan and Germany, both of which are world economic powers.
Although the world body has remained divided over representation for Africa, Asia and Latin America, most member states have little or no objections to Japan and Germany.
But most members are opposed to the inclusion of the two industrial countries in the Council if there is no simultaneous representation for developing nations.
Last week Brazil enhanced its international profile by providing 850 troops to lead the newest U.N. peacekeeping force in Haiti. The Brazilian contingent was followed by Chile (650 troops) and Argentina (600 troops).
“This is, I believe, a testimony of Brazil’s generosity and commitment to international cooperation and the United Nations,” Secretary-General Kofi Annan told reporters last month.
Brazil, South Africa and India – while pushing their claims for permanent seats – are also playing a dominant role in the powerful G-20, created shortly before a ministerial meeting of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in Cancun, Mexico, in Sep. 2003.
Currently, the G20 is leading the developing world in the disputed trade talks with Western industrial nations over agricultural subsidies.
Last week, Brazilian Foreign Minister Celso Amorim confirmed speculation that Brazil, India and China are likely to be invited to join the world’s most powerful grouping of countries – the G8 – comprising the United States, Britain, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Canada and Russia.
Asked about Brazil’s role in promoting economic cooperation among developing nations, Annan told reporters at a U.N. meeting in Sao Paulo last week: “I think Brazil is a dynamic presence on the international scene today, and also very active in South-South cooperation. I think there is a group of countries that are working with Brazil to try and foster the interests of developing countries.”
Asked about the reform of the Security Council, Annan said: “My position has always been clear. I believe the Council does good work but it could become more democratic and representative and through that, also gain greater legitimacy.”
The world of today, he said, is no longer the world of 1944 when the United Nations was created. “The structure of the Council reflects that world and the world has changed and we need to adapt and deal with today’s reality.”
Annan admitted that the debate over the expansion of the Council has been going on for over 10 years with no success. He said he has appointed a panel of eminent persons who are now taking a close look at the United Nations.
“They will be looking at the Security Council and the General Assembly, and they will probably make recommendations which I will share with member states. I think there is a bit more energy behind the discussion of U.N. reform this year than had existed in the past few years. And it is possible that next year, we may make progress,” he predicted.
Asked if Brazil has a rightful claim for a permanent seat, Annan said: “This is an issue for member states to decide. But I can say that Brazil would have a reasonable claim, a justified claim to it.”