Africa, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

SOMALIA: Move to Lift Arms Embargo Faulted

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Dec 13 2005 (IPS) - The United Nations Security Council has traditionally tried to cut off arms supplies to some of the world’s politically troubled countries – including Somalia, Cote d’Ivoire, Liberia, Rwanda and Sierra Leone – in order to restore peace and stability in post-conflict situations.

But a move to lift the U.N. arms embargo on Somalia – as proposed by the Inter-Governmental Authority on Development (IGAD) which brokered that country’s reconciliation process – has generated strong warnings from activist groups and Africa-watchers.

“Somalia does not need additional arms, a point that can probably be made for the entire continent of Africa,” says Bill Fletcher Jr., president of the Washington-based TransAfrica Forum.

He said that a process of de-militarisation is necessary. Yet de-militarisation must be accompanied by a combination of African Union (AU) diplomatic initiatives backed up by AU peacekeeping capacity, as well as a continental consensus to take action against threats to democracy and human rights.

“Somalia, in this case, certainly needs no more guns. It does need, however, an AU initiative that reinforces legitimate efforts at national reconciliation,” Fletcher told IPS.

The 15-member U.N. Security Council imposed an embargo “on all delivery of weapons military equipment to Somalia” back in January 1992.


Dr. Natalie Goldring, a visiting professor in the Security Studies Programme at the Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University, points out that even though arms embargoes are often problematic, “ending an existing embargo before the situation has fully stabilised can send conflicting messages – political, economic, and potentially military as well”.

“The situation in Somalia is fragile at best,” Goldring told IPS. “That suggests that ending the arms embargo could easily produce negative consequences for Somalia’s security.”

She also said that when international consensus on sanctions and embargoes is deficient, the flow of deadly weapons tends to continue.

An equally strong warning came from the Brussels-based International Crisis Group, described as an independent, non-profit, non-governmental organisation (NGO) covering over 50 crisis-affected countries and territories across four continents.

“A regional call for the Somali transitional government to arm its security forces, despite the existence of the United Nations arms embargo, is a recipe for further instability in Somalia,” says Gareth Evans, the International Crisis Group’s president.

In a letter to heads of state of the Horn of Africa regional organisation IGAD, he calls on the leaders to reconsider their efforts to lift the arms embargo.

“I urge you and your IGAD colleagues to use your influence instead to promote political dialogue within the Transitional Federal Institutions for the purposes of reconvening the Transitional National Parliament and restoring a functioning national unity government,” Evans said.

The Somalia situation remains of grave concern not only for its neighbours but also for the broader international community, he added. “Continued instability, the growing incidence of piracy and the persistent threat of transnational terrorism all require concerted action,” Evans said.

He said his group has repeatedly underscored the importance of the U.N. arms embargo on Somalia for limiting violence and its humanitarian consequences.

“It remains critical today, as Somali legislators from feuding factions are engaged in an ongoing, if slow, discourse. International engagement could help bolster their efforts to reestablish parliament and resolve their differences,” he added.

He also warned that reluctance to endorse the current dialogue while at the same time challenging the arms embargo sends the wrong messages: that reunification of transitional institutions and restoration of a functioning parliament are unnecessary, and that force is a legitimate alternative to dialogue.

IGAD, with the support of the wider international community, should spare no effort to pursue a political solution to the Somali crisis, Evans added.

In a communique issued last week, the Council of Ministers of IGAD underlined “the necessity in recognising that Somalia has a legitimate government and in line with the transitional federal charter it has the solemn right to establish, train and equip its law enforcement authority while seeking regional and international cooperation towards achieving that goal of lifting the U.N. arms embargo.”

Somalia has had no strong, effective government since opposition leaders ousted the regime of Mohamed Siad Barre in January 1991.The overthrow of that government has been followed by turmoil, factional fighting and anarchy.

Somalia is now under a new Transitional Federal Government (TFG), consisting of a 275-member parliament, established in October 2004.

According to the International Crisis Group, the main achievements of the IGAD-led peace process were a Transitional Federal Charter and a broad-based Transitional National Parliament meant to establish a government able to guide Somalia through an uncertain transition.

The success of the TFG, however, depends on maintaining political consensus, broad public support and legitimacy. “It is failing badly on all counts: the government is deeply divided, parliament has not met since March, and the Charter is repeatedly violated,” the Group said.

In the absence of functioning national institutions, the wing led by interim President Abdullahi Yusuf Ahmed has sought to monopolise the government at the expense of other groups, Evans said in the letter to IGAD.

These dynamics are reflected by divisions in the Somali public and failure of the transitional government, more than one year after establishment, to make tangible progress towards fulfilling its responsibilities, the letter added.

Most disturbing is the military build-up on both sides of that body and the threat of renewed violence if the differences are allowed to widen.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags