Tuesday, November 17, 2026
David Cronin
- European countries have been urged to allow detainees in Guantanamo Bay to settle on their soil.
In a letter sent to the European Parliament this week, John Bellinger, legal adviser to the U.S. State Department, said that around 25 of the 275 people still being held in the controversial camp have been “cleared for release or transfer but cannot be repatriated because of long-standing human rights concerns with respect to their countries of origin.”
According to Bellinger, European Union member states have been approached by the U.S. on a bilateral basis over the past 12 months with requests that they accept some of these detainees. So far, however, this effort has not resulted in any transfers, he said.
Despite being highly critical of how the U.S. has conducted its ‘war on terror’, human rights advocates have argued that European governments should respond favourably to the U.S. request.
Emi Maclean from the Centre for Constitutional Rights in New York said it is “understandable” how many in Europe feel the “U.S. should independently undig the hole it has dug” in using Guantanamo Bay for the detention of people who have never been charged with a criminal offence. Yet, she argued, European governments should act because “human lives are at stake”, and to “help close an ugly chapter in the Guantanamo story.”
Some 45 of the detainees at the prison camp have either expressed a fear that they would be persecuted after being returned to their home country, or said they were recognised as refugees at the time of their arrests. These detainees hail from such countries as Algeria, China, Jordan, Libya, Russia, the Palestinian territories, Syria, Sudan, Tunisia and Uzbekistan.
Human rights campaigners have documented how others sent home from Guantanamo have been tortured. Seven men who were deported to Russia in 2004 were placed in custody and ill treated, even though the Russian authorities had provided guarantees that they would be dealt with humanely.
So far only two European countries have accepted detainees from Guantanamo. In 2006 Albania took in eight men from Algeria, China, Egypt and Uzbekistan. And in August last year, the London government sought that five men who had lived in Britain prior to their arrest (but were not British citizens) should be released to the UK. To date, the U.S. authorities have transferred three of the five.
Jean Lambert, a British Green member of the European Parliament (MEP), pointed out that the British government’s call for the five men to be released “was largely the result of a strong and sustained campaign for the UK to do that.”
Her Liberal compatriot Sarah Ludford noted that one of the British residents still in Guantanamo, Ahmed Belbacha, is held “in almost permanent isolation”, despite having been cleared for release. Belbacha is held with the “lights permanently on in his cell,” she added, stating that he has been prevented from covering his eyes with items of clothing.
About 800 have been held in Guantanamo since the first military plane arrived there in January 2002. Most of the remaining 275 have been in the camp for five or six years, without any charges being brought against them and without having an opportunity to contest the grounds on which they are being held.
Jennifer Daskal from Human Rights Watch said that the continuing detention without trial of prisoners in Guantanamo does little to make the U.S. safer.
“Consider the lessons from the United Kingdom’s experience dealing with the Irish Republican Army,” she said. “In the 1970s, the British Army rounded up close to 2,000 individuals it believed to be associated with the IRA, and interned them in prison camps, where they were held without charge. Violence increased, not decreased, as anti-detention anger led to a flood of recruits and helped fuel the conflict (in Northern Ireland).”
Meanwhile, the European Parliament’s committee on civil liberties decided Feb. 28 to undertake a follow-up to a previous probe into the use of European airspace and territory for a programme of kidnapping and secret detention by the Central Intelligence Agency of the U.S. The decision follows an acknowledgment by Britain earlier this month that two CIA flights involved in the programme – known officially as extraordinary rendition – had landed in Diego Garcia, a British territory in the Indian Ocean, in 2002. Britain had previously denied that any such flights had landed on its territory.
Last year a European Parliament investigation concluded that at least 1,245 flights operated by the CIA flew into European airspace or stopped at the continent’s airports between the end of 2001 and the end of 2005.
Portuguese Socialist MEP Ana Gomes said that European countries have been “deeply involved” in these secret flights, many of which were destined for Guantanamo.
The main reason, she added, why governments from Europe do not wish to accept detainees from Guantanamo is because “they do not want to accept their responsibilities.”