Headlines, Human Rights, Indigenous Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

RIGHTS-GUATEMALA: A Light at the End of the Impunity Tunnel?

Diego Cevallos

MEXICO CITY, May 5 2004 (IPS) - Spanish Judge Baltasar Garzón has opened the door for an attack against the impunity surrounding the perpetrators of massacres, torture, and forced disappearances in Guatemala between 1960 and 1996, a period of repression and civil war that killed at least 200,000 people.

But the effort to bring those responsible to justice could take years.

Garzón recently announced that he will make a visit to Guatemala soon to gather testimonies from members of the military and civilians accused of committing crimes against humanity, in the context of a lawsuit filed in 1999 in Spain’s courts by Guatemalan indigenous activist Rigoberta Menchú, winner of the 1992 Nobel Peace Prize.

“We think that in two or three months, Garzón will be arriving in Guatemala to start a new phase in the fight against impunity,” the director of the Rigoberta Menchú Foundation, Gustavo Meoño, told IPS.

Garzón rose to international fame with the 1998 arrest of former Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet, who spent more than 500 days under house arrest in London, awaiting extradition to Spain for a trial on charges of crimes against humanity committed during Chile’s 1973-1990 dictatorship. Pinochet was ultimately released by Britain’s justice authorities.

The Spanish magistrate’s visit to Guatemala first has to be approved by his own country’s foreign ministry and that of Guatemala, as well as by the Guatemalan Supreme Court.


Once those obstacles are cleared, Garzón likely will have to deal with the refusal of the accused to make legal testimonies. Among those involved are former heads of state and retired military officers Fernando Lucas García (1978-1982), Efraín Ríos Montt (1982-1983) and Oscar Mejía (1983-1986), which could seek means to prolong the proceedings for years.

Meoño recognises that possibility, but says he is optimistic nonetheless. “We are above all stubborn and perseverant,” he said, noting that Menchú and her foundation have been pushing the case, originally filed in Spain, for five years already.

If Garzón is able to begin the questioning and to summon the ones facing charges, it would be a giant step forward in the fight against the impunity of human rights violators, he said.

Although the repression and the civil war ended in Guatemala eight years ago with the signing of peace accords, the justice system in the country has not been able to put behind bars any of the military leaders accused of committing serious human rights violations even though there are numerous cases open against them.

During that long period of conflict and violence, particularly in the 1970s when the army clashed with guerrilla groups, 450 villages were razed and more than 600 massacres were documented by a United Nations-sponsored historic clarification commission.

In the Guatemalan civil war, 40,000 to 55,000 people disappeared and at least 200,000 people were killed – 85 percent were Indians.

“The system of impunity in Guatemala remains solid, and that is why we set our sights on foreign courts, because it is a matter of crimes that can be prosecuted globally,” said Meoño.

Garzón’s intention in Guatemala is to question the people accused of and witnesses to the killing of three Spaniards and 34 others who died in an attack by the army against the Spanish embassy in Guatemala City in 1980.

The incident, in which the army tried to remove the people occupying the diplomatic headquarters, claimed the lives of the first secretary of the Spanish diplomatic delegation Jaime Ruiz del Arbol, former Guatemalan vice-president Eduardo Cáceres, former foreign minister Adolfo Molina and Vicente Menchú, Rigoberta’s father.

“I am not a subject of the Spanish Crown,” former dictator Ríos Montt said in announcing that he would not take part in the questioning that Garzón is preparing.

“I have in Guatemala an Attorney General (or other ministries) that could summon me, but those other gentlemen represent the crown,” said Ríos Montt, who has been compared to Chile’s Pinochet for his audacity in denying or justifying the human rights violations that were committed under their military dictatorships.

Although Ríos Montt was in power just two years, at least 11 massacres were perpetrated against peasants, with a death toll of more than 1,200, say human rights groups. Also in that period were dozens of arbitrary arrests and denunciations of torture and forced disappearances.

But the former dictator, now aged 77, maintains that he committed no crime.

Meoño said in the IPS interview, “We don’t know how long it will take to achieve justice in Guatemala, but we hope it happens in time, while the guilty are still alive.”

One of the most important legal proceedings against the military was begun in June 2001 by the Justice Association for the Reconciliation of Guatemala, targeting the crimes of genocide and violations of international humanitarian law.

But although three years have passed, that case has become bogged down in the courts and little chance for progress is seen.

“We are sure that with Garzón it will be different,” said the Rigoberta Menchú Foundation director.

Garzón took up the case of the Guatemalan dictatorship officials this year, begun earlier by fellow Spaniard Guillermo Luis Polanco.

Menchú’s claims against the Guatemalan military officials was initially rejected by Spain’s Audiencia Nacional (the country’s highest criminal court), but thanks to several appeals filed, the case was reactivated.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags