Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Jim Lobe
- Declining wild fish stocks combined with human population growth, particularly in developing countries, will lead to higher prices for what has been called ”the protein of the poor” over coming decades, says a new report by two major international research groups.
Released on the eve of next week’s meeting of the WorldFish Centre in Penang, Malaysia, the report notes that aquaculture (fish farming) will help make up the gap but not to the degree that would be required to make fish more affordable to the poor in developing countries.
Under the most likely scenario developed by the Centre and the Washington-based International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI), total fish production will increase at an annual rate of 0.4 percent less than the likely human population growth through 2020. That will cause prices to rise at between four and 16 percent in real terms over the period, depending on the species.
While that is the most likely scenario, it is also possible that a greater than anticipated decline in the wild fish harvest, brought on by the collapse of key fisheries, and static growth for farmed fish could produce price increases of between 26 and 70 percent, finds the report, which is being submitted as a background paper to next week’s meeting.
”Fish is the fastest growing source of food in the developing world,” said Meryl Williams, the Centre’s director-general, yet demand greatly exceeds supply, and the problem is growing.”
”Almost three-quarters of the 130 million tonnes extracted in 2000 came from fish stocks already depleted, over-fished or fully exploited,” she continued. ”Many of these stressed fish stocks will not be able to produce even at current levels, let alone cope with the increase in demand that results from 90 million more mouths to feed each year.”
Fish is currently the main source of animal protein for some one billion people worldwide, the vast majority of whom live in poor countries. It also contributes about seven percent of the world’s total food supply.
As wild fish stocks decline and aquaculture is unable to fill the gap, the impact, especially on poor people, could be dramatic, according to the report, Fish as Food: Projections to 2020.
”To understand the difference in access to fish between the rich and the poor,” noted Williams, ”consider that a person on the poverty line (living on the equivalent of one U.S. dollar a day) in a developing country would have to work for two days to pay for a kilogram of local fish such as tilapia, carp, or milkfish, whereas the average person in the developed world would need to work for less than an hour to earn enough for a kilogram of salmon or trout.”
The problem has been building for decades as huge – and heavily subsidised – commercial fishing fleets have trawled the world’s most abundant fisheries to the point of exhaustion.
In 1989 the world’s total fish catch reached its highest point – 86 million tonnes, a four-fold increase over 50 years before. The average amount of fish consumed per person has almost doubled since the 1950s.
At next week’s "Fish for All Summit” in Penang, where the Centre is also based, policy-makers, scientists, and representatives from the fishing industry and non-government organisations (NGOs) from more than 40 countries will launch a 10-year effort – ”The Fish for All Initiative” – to increase understanding and cooperation in dealing with many of these challenges.
The Inititiative grows out of the recent World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg that set a goal of restoring depleted fisheries by 2015.
But that goal will be tough to meet, according to the Centre, which noted that, given present trends, some species are likely to disappear from global markets altogether, while the quality of seafood caught will likely decline, and competition between and within countries for the declining catch is sure to increase.
The most likely scenario calls for global production of food fish to rise 1.5 percent annually through 2020. Two thirds of the increase will come from aquaculture, which is expected to make up 41 percent of global food fish production by 2020, up from 31 percent in the late 1990s.
Most of the growth is likely to take place in poor countries, which will account for almost 80 percent of global food fish production by 2020, up from 65 percent at the present time. Much of the increase is likely to come from China, while production in the European Union, the former Soviet states, and Japan, is expected to decline.
At the same time, the world’s human population is expected to rise from six billion today to an estimated 8.5 billion in 2020. In order to keep pace, fish production would have to double in that time.
”But this is a time when the (Food and Agriculture Organisation) has estimated that a drastic reduction of at least 30 percent of world fishing capacity is needed to rebuild over-fished resources,” according to M. S. Swaminathan, chairman of the steering committee for the new Initiative.
”Aquaculture offers a partial solution to the need for higher productivity. The question is: can we do this in a sustainable way, without harming the environment and will the poor benefit?”
Aquaculture, whose contribution to global fish food supply skyrocketed from eight to 25 percent between 1984 and 1998, poses serious environmental problems, including the tremendous amount of pollution it generates in surrounding waters.
Escapes by farmed salmon, which tend to be bigger and more aggressive than indigenous species, have already resulted in serious impacts on both coasts of North America, according to recent studies reviewed in scientific publications.
Major questions are also being posed by the recent development of genetically modified fish, particularly if they are released or escape into the natural environment where they may compete with and interbreed with native species, which could produce any number of additional impacts on the surrounding ecosystems.
Another major concern is the impact of climate change on fish stocks. During the 1998 El Nino, the warmer climate devastated some fish stocks, just as it did major coral reef structures in the Indian Ocean and the South Pacific. Reefs are a key source of bio-diversity in the world’s oceans.
Finally, demand is rising in industrialised countries for high-value carnivorous fish, such as farmed salmon, which consume far more fishmeal than the fish itself produces when it is finally cooked and eaten.
Increasing amounts of low-value fish may thus be used as fishmeal for shrimp, salmon and other high-value fish for wealthy fish-lovers, rather than to feed hungry and protein-poor people in poor countries.
Jim Lobe
- Declining wild fish stocks combined with human population growth, particularly in developing countries, will lead to higher prices for what has been called “the protein of the poor” over coming decades, says a new report by two major international research groups.
(more…)