Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS: States Use ‘War on Terror’ to Target Defenders, says U.N.

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Nov 11 2002 (IPS) - The global war against terrorism is jeopardizing the work of human rights activists, who have become the new victims of state repression, says a senior U.N. official.

”Some human rights defenders have been killed, while others have either disappeared or been arrested and detained arbitrarily,” said Hina Jilani, U.N. special representative for human rights defenders.

Jilani said that in some countries – which she refused to name – existing national security laws that had undermined human rights in the past, have been strengthened and more forcefully enforced in the aftermath of the Sep. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the United States.

In one country, people fighting and struggling against land evictions were being charged under anti-terrorist laws, and in another, media laws were amended to make it a crime to report statements made by ”so-called terrorists”, putting journalists and human rights defenders at risk.

”I am afraid that these laws and policies are affecting human rights in general, and have resulted in gross violations of the rights of human rights defenders,” she added.

The official said that human rights defenders, and in some cases their families, were targets of intimidation and harassment.

”As a result, many of those human rights defenders had to flee their home countries,” she told reporters last week.

In a 15-page report released here, Jilani complained that U.N. member states are not cooperating with her, either blocking on-site visits or dragging their feet over requests to investigate complaints.

At least 14 countries have not responded to her request for visits: Bhutan, Egypt, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Tunisia and Uzbekistan. More recently, additional requests and reminders were sent to six countries: Belarus, Chad, Nigeria, Togo, Turkey and Zimbabwe. But there have been no responses to date.

Jilani said that the ”most serious conditions” she found during her visits were in Latin America, where there had been a dramatic increase in threats to the security and safety of human rights defenders.

”The militarisation of public security has increased noticeably in the region. This has promoted the dominance of military logic, military legislation and military practices in approaches to social control,” the study noted.

In many African countries, on the other hand, a common trend is to target those who strive for democratic rights and criticise undemocratic governance, or who expose corruption and abuse of power. African governments also tend to use the judicial system as a means of harassing and punishing human rights defenders, says the report.

In several Asian countries, national security laws have been imposed in the ”severest forms”. Repressive anti-terrorist or security laws existed in some of these nations before the Sep. 11 attacks, ”but (Asian) governments are using the present circumstances to justify these practices”.

”These laws are being used in a manner that has further eroded due process and the rule of law,” the study said.

In June, former U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights, Mary Robinson, called for an independent expert or a new international body to monitor the impact of anti-terrorism measures on human rights worldwide.

Robinson regretted that no international institution was assessing whether measures taken by member states to combat terrorism are in violation of human rights standards that those states have accepted.

She said that a new counter terrorism committee created by the U.N. Security Council late last year does not believe it has a mandate to monitor these excesses.

"The great concern now is that where mature democracies blur the lines or set a bad example, undemocratic regimes consider they are given a green light to pursue repressive policies, secure in the belief that any excesses will be ignored," Robinson added.

Several nations, particularly the United States, Britain, Germany and Canada, along with Egypt, Russia and Uzbekistan, have introduced far-reaching anti-terrorism measures, some of which are deemed in violation of basic human rights.

These include detention of non-citizens, tightening of immigration laws, electronic surveillance without court order, deportation of those overstaying their visas, and monitoring of mail and communications between a prisoner and an attorney.

The new restrictive measures also cover privacy rights, fair trial, the right to seek asylum, political participation, freedom of expression and peaceful assembly.

Robinson said that the post-Sep.11 environment "is reinforcing a fortress mentality within Europe", as controls are tightened and there is a coarsening of debate and of language used in speaking of asylum seekers and immigrants.

Jilani told reporters last week that she was also ”very concerned” that governments were using the war on terrorism ”to justify the policy of detaining asylum seekers.”

She said that far too many governments were formulating new laws defining ordinary forms of civil disobedience as ”terrorism” by creating new offences related to ”incitement”, restricting rights of assembly and suspending normal legal guarantees by extending the period allowed for detentions without trial.

U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan has also warned member states that there should be no "trade-off" between the fight against terrorism and the protection of human rights.

Although Annan refused to identify countries by name, he said that the anti-terrorism measures now being adopted by some countries should "not unduly curtail human rights or give others a pretext to do so”.

In its annual report this year, London-based Amnesty International (AI) specifically criticised the United States and Britain for undermining human rights in its fight against terrorism. AI Secretary-General Irene Khan said that the U.S.-led coalition was riding "roughshod" over international humanitarian law and principles.

AI also listed several "significant human rights failings" by the United States, including authorisation of military tribunals to try alleged terrorists; selective application of Geneva Convention guarantees for Taliban and al-Qaeda prisoners held at the U.N. naval base in Guantanamo Bay, and indefinite detention of foreigners held without charge or access to lawyers.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS: States Use ‘War on Terror’ to Target Defenders, says U.N.

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Nov 11 2002 (IPS) - The global war against terrorism is jeopardizing the work of human rights activists, who have become the new victims of state repression, says a senior U.N. official.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags