Thursday, November 19, 2026
Interview with social movements expert Dieter Rucht
- Social movements are responsible for some of the most important transformations taking place lately in our societies and minds, says Prof. Dieter Rucht from the Berlin Centre for Social Sciences (WZB).
IPS: Which contemporary social movements would you evaluate as effective?
DIETER RUCHT: First it is necessary to specify the term “effects” of movements. Usually, effects are only considered to the extent that they relate directly to the explicit goals of the movement. But a movement may fail in its primary goal and still have a lot of effects which may be important in the long run; for instance, creating critical awareness among the population at the national level.
I think that the women’s movement has been fairly successful in a historical perspective, looking at one or two hundred years, but also in a more recent perspective.
The environmental movement is also quite effective, but here we have to differentiate. I think that the main effect of the environmentalists is to create awareness about climate change. Of course, this is not only an effect of the movements, but also of natural scientists, climate experts, who were studying and discussing this for a long time – but there was no resonance for it. However, over the last years, debate was widened, affecting politicians and the general population, and I think this is, not exclusively, but mainly due to the activity of environment movements.
IPS: What about movements in Latin America?
DR: At the moment, it looks like a victory, because certain policies in Latin America were more or less terminated. A hardcore neo-liberal policy as was implemented in Chile after 1973, or later on in Argentina, is no longer possible, because, first of all, these experiments largely failed on a purely economic level – or they were successful for some people who became very rich, but they were a failure for the rest of the population – and because left movements were effective.
But I am not so sure about the long term impacts because there is much ambivalence about these victories. Quite often, as the case of Nicaragua has shown, left groups, democratic, grassroots oriented groups, once in power, tend to misuse it and become more or less repressive, at least regarding certain segments of the population. If I look for instance at the Venezuelan case, I have mixed feelings: on the one hand, the gap between the rich and the poor is diminishing, the living standards of poor people are rising, the level of education and healthcare is going to be improved. On the other hand, civil liberties are in danger. It’s hard to say in the long run whether there will also be an improvement as regards civil liberties, or there will be an authoritarian regime, which will in the end enrich the power holders rather than serve the people at large.
IPS: Moving to Europe, are we assisting in the emergence of a cycle of far-right activism?
DR: Since the 1990s, we have had two large-scale and significant developments in the social movements sector. One is the rise of right-wing extremism in most Western countries, and it’s a very important rise in terms of the number of events, but not so important, and this may be surprising, in terms of participation – the number of people involved in these protests is fairly small.
On the other hand, there were severely strong counter-mobilisations, which is underestimated by most observers. Again, protest event data show that, in Germany, counter-mobilisation is 20 times as much as right-wing mobilisation, not in terms of number of events, but in terms of participants.
So, the rise in extremism and its increased self-confidence in occupying the public sphere is one big phenomenon we have witnessed in the last 15 years or so. The second big development is the rise of so-called global justice movements in the Western world and some of the Eastern world. It’s not a completely new phenomenon but it’s a kind of agglomeration coming mainly out of the new social movements of the 1970s and 1980s. Numerically, it is not so important, but it is quite significant in terms of public visibility.
IPS: Are societies in Central and Eastern Europe more vulnerable to far-right movements because of their overall antipathy for the left?
DR: I think these societies are more vulnerable than Western societies for several reasons. First of all, change happened so quickly and people were submitted to economic and political shocks. Then, some people are very clever, and make a tremendous amount of money, in Russia for instance, and the rest have the impression that there was not so much progress.
There has been progress in terms of the possibilities to express oneself, but in terms of the actual living conditions, the situation of many people has not improved much. This could be potential for movements of the left, but the problem is that the left, because it’s associated with the old socialist system, is so discredited that it’s very hard to promote leftist slogans. Even though this is a new generation of the left and they do not want the same system as existed in the past, the slogans may remind people of the past and create some kind of emotional resistance.