Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Jim Lobe
- Senate Republicans Wednesday gave up on their effort to sharply tighten the 33-year-old U.S. trade embargo against Cuba by deleting a key section of a proposed sanctions bill in order to end debate on the controversial measure.
The decision to delete ‘Title Three’ from the so-called Helms- Burton bill came after it became clear that Senate Majority Leader Robert Dole and Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman Jesse Helms lacked the votes they needed end a Democratic filibuster against the original bill.
“White House inflexibility has forced the change made today,” a clearly frustrated Dole, the current frontrunner for the Republican presidential nomination, told his colleagues.
Title Three would permit the Cuban exiles and U.S. companies whose property was expropriated by the government of President Fidel Castro to sue foreign firms and individuals who “trafficked” in those properties. Dole admitted this section was by far the most important part of the proposed bill.
“The strength of this bill was Title Three,” said Dole after a unanimous vote to finally end debate, thus setting the stage for a final vote on the bill Thursday.
He added that the controversial provision might still be considered by a joint Senate-House of Representatives conference committee which must reconcile two different versions of the bill before sending it on to Clinton.
Dole’s main Republican rival, Texas Senator Phil Gramm, said he hoped that Title Three would be included in the bill reported out of conference.
“The rest of the bill is mainly window-dressing,” agreed Geoff Thale, an analyst at the Washington Office on Latin America (WOLA), who has been monitoring the debate.
Among other provisions, Titles One and Two require the administration to seek an international boycott of Cuba, to oppose the country’s admission to the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. The bill would also ban U.S. aid to the states of the former Soviet Union if they provided concessional aid to Cuba.
The last provision, if included in a final bill, may still cause problems for the administration of President Bill Clinton, which, however, indicated Wednesday that it could live with the amended bill, at least for now.
The Helms-Burton bill, named for the ultra-right Senate committee Chairman, and Rep. Dan Burton of Indiana, was approved last month by the House of Representatives in a lopsided vote of 294-130.
The House version includes Title Three, which would enable any U.S. citizen whose property was confiscated after the 1959 Cuban Revolution to sue any foreign individual, company, or government body involved in business dealings in Cuba related to property claimed by the plaintiff.
A companion provision, Title Four, which was also dropped by Dole and Helms, provided that the heads of companies “trafficking” in confiscated properties and their immediate family members should be denied visas to enter the United States.
In addition to the staunch anti-Castro Cuban American National Foundation (CANF), a major backer of Title Three was one of the world’s biggest rum producers, Bacardi, which suffered substantial losses after the Revolution.
Helms and Dole argued that the only way that Castro could continue holding onto power in Cuba was to secure sufficient foreign investment to keep the island’s economy afloat.
“The way you stop that foreign investment is to tie up the investors in the courts in the United States,” noted Thale, who added that the threat of possible lawsuits under Helms-Burton has already helped “create a climate of concern among some investors” thinking of putting their money in Cuba.
“It is the chilling effect on foreign investment that worries Fidel Castro the most,” Dole said Wednesday.
But the White House and Senate Democrats insisted that, while they share the goal of ending Castro’s role, Title Three was far too blunt an instrument. For one thing, it could tie up U.S. federal courts in a flood of new litigation.
Second, the proposed bill’s foes said it threatened ties with some of Washington’s closest allies. Canada, Britain, the European Union and Mexico have been among those countries which have spoken out against the bill as jeopardising their own commercial interests and independence.
Finally, some analysts, notably former Costa Rican President and Nobel Peace Laureate Oscar Arias, argued that the property provisions of the bill would actually bolster Castro’s rule in Cuba by suggesting that Cuban exiles here are bent on trying to reverse the Revolution’s most popular achievements.
Noting these concerns, Secretary of State Warren Christopher released a written statement two weeks ago in which he said he would urge Clinton to veto the bill if it passed both houses.
The White House, however, wanted to avoid a vote on the measure, primarily for political reasons. With the CANF still strong among Cuban Americans in Florida and New Jersey, Clinton himself never pledged to veto the bill if it came to his desk, even with Title Three included.
As a result, Democrats adopted a strategy — or filibuster — designed to prevent any vote on the bill on the Senate floor. Under Senate rules, a filibuster cannot be ended unless 60 senators vote for “cloture.” Last Thursday, Dole and Helms failed in the first cloture vote, 56-37. On Tuesday, they tried and failed again, this time by only one vote, 59-36.
They had intended to try one more time Wednesday, but three moderate Republicans indicated they would oppose cloture. At that point, Dole and Helms threw in the towel and announced they were deleting the objectionable provisions.
Still, the bill as amended may pose problems to the administration whose Cuban policy has zig-zagged almost from the date of Clinton’s inauguration. Besides requiring no votes against Cuba’s admission to international financial institutions, it codifies limits on the right of Cubans here to send remittances to relatives back home and to visit family members there.
It also restricts U.S. banks and lending institutions from making loans to any foreign institution for investments in Cuba.
Title Two also sets out detailed conditions under which the U.S. government can provide aid to any “transitional” or “democratic” Cuban government in the future. The administration has objected to this on the grounds that it seeks to “micro- manage” U.S. foreign policy.
A more significant problem for the administration is posed by provisions relating to aid to Russia and other former Soviet states. Russia, in particular, has moved to renew ties with Cuba, most recently through a new sugar agreement and by promising to provide aid in building a controversial nuclear plant in Cuba.
The Senate bill requires that U.S. aid to third countries which themselves provide aid to Cuba should be cut by the amount they supply to Cuba. The same rule applies to aid to any third country which participates in the building of the reactor.
The administration has strenuously objected to a similar provision aimed at Russia if it provides help to Iran’s nuclear programme, arguing that ties to Moscow should not be held hostage to its relations with other nations.
Jim Lobe
- Senate Republicans Wednesday gave up on their effort to sharply tighten the 33-year-old U.S. trade embargo against Cuba by deleting a key section of a proposed sanctions bill in order to end debate on the controversial measure.
(more…)