Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

IRAN-UNITED STATES: Waiting On World Court’s Opening Ruling

IPS Correspondents

THE HAGUE, Dec 11 1996 (IPS) - Iran’s campaign to win compensation for oil platforms damaged by U.S. forces in the 1980s reaches a key moment on Thursday when the International Court of Justice at the Hague, popularly known as the World Court, rules on the case.

The Iranians hope that the court will issue a ruling confirming its own authority over this case; this will then enable them to ask the World Court to condemn the ‘wilful destruction’ of Iranian property during two U.S. attacks on Iranian oil installations in the Gulf in 1987 and 1988.

Two weeks of hearings preceded the judicial review in which the U.S. disputed whether the World Court was in fact competent to judge the main issue.

But if the court decides Thursday that the Court is fit to rule on the merits of Teheran’s case against Washington, it could well be two years before full court proceedings take place in which the U.S. would be, in effect, on trial for committing acts of war against Iran. The disputed incidents took place at the height of the Iran-Iraq war of 1980-1988.

But the proceedings at the Hague may at least eventually cast some light on the murky problem of the extent to which military actions can be justified in circumstances that fall short of all-out war.

Iran says the U.S. committed a breach of international law and was responsible for destroying three sets of oil platforms in the Gulf during two incidents, one in October 1987 and the other in April 1988. Should the Court decide to hear the case, the U.S. will argue that the platforms were used by Iranian military forces running attacks on U.S. and international shipping in the Gulf.

There are three main ways in which the court’s jurisdiction can be invoked on Thursday.

One is if it is specifically covered in a straightforward bilateral treaty, the second is if both parties are signatory to a multilateral treaty which says cases like this are the provenance of the World Court; the third is a general bilateral treaty which provides for the World Court to determine any interpretation of the treaty.

Iran chose this third route, citing the 1955 Treaty of Amity concluded between the former Imperial government of Shah Reza II Pahlevi and the U.S. government, which provides for ‘peaceful and friendly relations’ between the two countries, and also for freedom of commerce and navigation.

The treaty contains a provision that if matters of interpretation cannot be settled by friendly diplomacy, then either side could go to the World Court. The U.S. action, argues Iran, violates that treaty.

The U.S. is contesting the court’s jurisdiction. It argues that the 1955 treaty has nothing to do with the kind of treaty that underlines Iran’s claim to reparations; that the 1955 treaty essentially deals with commercial and consular affairs and is not designed to regulate use of armed force.

Washington therefore asserts it is thus not relevant to the issue of the U.S. attacks on Iranian oil platforms.

After the September hearings, the Court’s judges deliberated behind closed doors on whether they are competent to hear the case.

If the Court’s competence is upheld in the face of U.S. objections it will then ask for written pleadings from both sides on the real issue of merit. The U.S. would be expected to raise a plea of self- defence, arguing that an American frigate, the USS Roberts, had been hit by a Iranian mine, and that a Kuwaiti tanker flying under the U.S. flag, the Sea Isle City, had been hit by an Iranian Chinese-made Silkworm missile.

“No doubt, when the day comes to contest the merits of the case, those issues will be hotly contested — but we’re not at that stage yet,” a source close to the case told IPS. The written pleadings would be expected to take at least a year, while open court hearings on the core issue of whether the U.S. was justified in attacking the oil platforms may well not take place for two years or so.

Both sides deployed top legal experts for the current proceedings at the Hague, in the Netherlands. One member of the Iranian team, Paris-based international lawyer Rodman Bundy, is a member of the New York bar, whilst the Iranian team was further buttressed by two noted professors of international law from Britain’s Cambridge University, one of whom, James Crawford, is also a member of the International Law Commission.

The U.S. team, though it could draw on a greater array of legal talent within its own government ranks, chose instead to rely on just one academic specialist: Professor Andreas F. Lowenfeld, the Rubin Professor of International Law at New York University.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags