Thursday, November 19, 2026
Deborah Horan
- Despite a month-old High Court ruling ordering the immediate release of a group of jailed West Bank students held for months without trial, Palestinian security services continue to hold nine of them in a Ramallah prison.
Lawyers and human rights activists here say the students’ plight is only the latest in a series of incidents calling into question the independence of the judiciary in the Palestinian self-rule areas on the West Bank and Gaza.
“The government ignores the authority of the courts,” said Will Walsh, a lawyer at the human rights research group, the Mandela Institute. “There’s no reason these students were picked up and there’s no reason they were released.”
Lawyers from six Palestinian non-governmental organisations, including the Mandela Institute, petitioned the High Court in Ramallah for the release of ten Palestinian students from Birzeit University held without charge or trial since a March security sweep following a series of suicide bombings in Israel.
On Aug. 18 in a landmark decision, a panel of five Palestinian judges ordered the Palestinian Authority to show cause why the students were being held or to immediately release them. The order was ignored pending “a reply from Gaza” — an oblique reference to Palestinian Authority President Yasser Arafat, say activists.
Since then, five of the ten students have been released, apparently arbitrarily and with no connection to the High Court order, said Walsh. “These things are done by the security services and undone by the security services,” he said. “The High Court has nothing to do with it.”
In the same period, four other students were arrested, also without charge, bringing the total number of jailed students to nine, according to the Birzeit University Human Rights Action Project, a university group that spent years during the Palestinian uprising working to release students from Israeli jails.
In the two years the Palestinian Authority has been operating in the West Bank and Gaza, about two thousand prisoners have been arbitrarily arrested and released, the Mandela Institute estimates.
At least eight Palestinian security services operate in the West Bank and Gaza, say Palestinian observers. At least three have overlapping jurisdictions which often results in one suspect being arrested and released by one service only to be arrested again by a different service for the same offense, human rights activists said.
Only 47 cases have been brought before a court, said Walsh. All of them have been brought before the hastily created “state security” courts set up by Arafat under pressure to crack down on Islamic militants.
State security courts typically hear cases in the middle of the night and have been roundly condemned by human rights activists as “kangaroo courts”. The hundreds of other cases simply have not been heard.
Palestinians say they are worried that the lack of respect for the High Courts has created a police state and weakened attempts to create a democratic form of government in the wake of Israel’s withdrawal from Palestinian towns in the West Bank and Gaza.
“The government has marginalised the judiciary,” said Khalil Shkaki, director of the Centre for Palestine Research and Studies, a well-respected West Bank-based think tank. “They have put it out of business.”
Rather than respecting High Court decisions, the Palestinian government has tried to silence dissent. While the Birzeit student petition was being heard before the court, several of the lawyers for the students came under heavy pressure from elements within the government to withdraw the case, said Palestinian sources.
After the decision was handed down, Arafat summarily “retired” Ramallah Chief Justice Amin Abd el-Salam, ostensibly because of his age. Human rights activists allege the real reason lay in his decision to release the Birzeit students and in an earlier decision, also by his court, calling on the government to release several prisoners who were also being held without charge.
Efforts by the Palestinian Legislative Council have also been met with silence at the top. Members called on the Palestinian Authority to release all prisoners held without charge.
Instead, they settled for a list drawn up by Palestinian Justice Minister Freih Abu Middain detailing where each prisoner was being held.
Human rights activists say the biggest problem surrounds the lack of legal procedure. Walsh said his organisation spent weeks attempting to determine who ordered the arrest of the ten students.
The general prosecutor in Ramallah passed on responsibility to the military prosecutor, who responded that the matter was not under his authority.
“Nobody takes official responsibility for locking these people up,” said Walsh. “The security services just go pick you up and put you in jail. Why you are in jail is a matter of conjecture.”