Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

UNITED NATIONS: U.N. Peacekeeping Seems Less Risky for Insurers

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Aug 13 1996 (IPS) - Insurance companies in the United States and Western Europe are changing their view on U.N. peacekeeping operations, no longer dismissing them as risky investments that potentially require heavy payouts.

Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Ghali says big Western insurers who shied away from the United Nations two years ago because of high body counts are now willing to provide cover to U.N. soldiers serving in the cause of world peace.

Boutros-Ghali has attributed the change to a “perceived reduction in risk-level” with the winding down of major peacekeeping operations in Cambodia, the former Yugoslavia, Somalia, and Mozambique.

Since its creation 51 years ago, about 1,304 peacekeepers have died serving the United Nations. The largest number deaths have been in missions in the Congo (234), the former Yugoslavia (211) and Somalia (136).

The peacekeeping missions in the former Yugoslavia and Somalia were both established in early 1992, while the mission in the Congo lasted from 1960 to 1964.

Boutros-Ghali says he has had positive responses from a number of international insurers who are now willing to cover accidental death and disability risks for the 25,296 U.N. troops currently serving in 17 peacekeeping operations worldwide.

In 1992-1994, when insurance companies were refusing coverage, the number of U.N. troops amounted to more than 75,000.

Currently, the largest contingent of troops are from Pakistan (1,715), followed by Russia (1,267), Bangladesh (1,170) and India (1,166).

The new offers have come from insurance companies in the United States, the Netherlands and Belgium.

The cost ranges from about 25 dollars per soldier/per month to about 40 dollars per soldier/per month for coverage in the base amount of 50,000 dollars in case of death.

However, coverage at the principal sum or base amount of 100,000 dollars is being offered at a proportionately higher monthly premium.

In a report to the 185-member General Assembly, Boutros-Ghali has spelled out details of the offers he has received. The Secretary-General is seeking the “guidance” of the General Assembly before making a final decision.

The search for insurance cover was prompted primarily by charges that the United Nations was paying about four times more to soldiers from developed nations who die in peacekeeping operations than for Third World troops who lose their lives in the same cause.

The U.N. Secretariat, at one time, paid about 85,300 dollars each to families of some soldiers, mostly from industrial countries, as compensation for the lost of life, while families of other soldiers, mostly from Third World countries, were paid about 19,500 dollars.

The difference in disability compensation was even more dramatic, ranging from as low as 1,500 dollars each for some soldiers to a high of about 224,200 dollars for others.

This staggering difference in the dollar value for human lives sparked a firestorm of criticism from developing nations, which accused the Secretariat of imposing double standards on compensation payments.

Critics were led by Tanzania, India, Kenya, Nigeria, Pakistan and Egypt — countries whose troops were serving in peacekeeping operations.

Ambassador Daudi Mwakawago of Tanzania said there is no way to understand the logic behind the differences in the death and disability benefits paid to peacekeepers from various nations.

“How,” he asked, “can the compensation for death range as widely as 19,500 dollars to one soldier and 85,300 dollars for another?”

“The loss of human life in similar circumstances and duty assignments, under the same Organization, should not be compensated differently,” he argued.

Brajesh Mishra of India said his country was disappointed with “the continued reluctance of the Secretariat to heed appeals for equal treatment.”

Mishra said it was imperative that the United Nations review the present system of payment of such benefits, and base the new arrangements on the principle of equal compensation for equal work in every respect.

He said there should be no distinction in these benefits on grounds of nationality or otherwise.

“This is the only appropriate course of action to follow when soldiers of different nationalities who are fighting together for the cause of international peace are killed or disabled in action,” he added.

The United Nations pays a standardised salary of about 950 dollars per month for each soldier wearing the U.N. uniform and the blue beret. But compensations, however, differ from country to country because the United Nations bases such payments on national legislation.

Since compensation for death and disability is relatively lower (in dollar terms) in developing nations, the payments made by the United Nations to countries such as France and the U.S. are much higher compared with payments to India, Pakistan or Bangladesh.

According to a U.N. report released last year, the death compensation claims — stemming from missions in Mozambique, Rwanda, Lebanon, the former Yugoslavia, Somalia, and Cambodia — totaled about 14.9 million dollars based on individualised rates for each country providing troops.

Under a standardised rate for all troops, the cost could be reduced to about 5.9 million dollars resulting in savings of about 9 million dollars. For disability claims, a standardised compensation would result in a savings of 1 million dollars.

These claims– both on death compensations and disability– cover peacekeeping missions in Mozambique, Rwanda, Lebanon, the former Yugoslavia, Somalia and Cambodia. ITEM CLOSED

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags