Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE: Parliament Harangues Arafat’s Men On Rights Abuses

Deborah Horan

RAMALLAH, Aug 7 1996 (IPS) - Tension between the Palestinian Legislative Council and the government led by president Yasser Arafat was turned up another notch Wednesday as Council members blasted it for the death of a prisoner under Palestinian interrogation last week.

During the two-day Council session, held Tuesday and Wednesday in the West Bank town of Ramallah, members used harsh language against the government and its security forces, calling the death of Mahmoud Jumayal, 26, an “organised crime” and asking if torture was an “official practice” in Palestinian prisons.

The incident raises questions about human rights abuses in Palestinian prisons, the rule of law under the new Palestinian Authority (PA) government, and the ability of the Council to check the powers of the executive — including the security forces under Arafat’s control as PA president.

“We visited Palestinian prisons in Gaza and everyone complained of torture,” said Council member Ziad Abu Amr. “Is torture an official policy in Palestinian prisons? The credibility of the Palestinian Authority and the Legislative Council has been shaken.”

Jumayal was pronounced dead in a Ramallah hospital Wednesday, where he was taken after interrogation with visible signs of torture on his body. Several Council members attended his funeral Thursday, where more than 2,000 Palestinian youths gathered and shouted anti-government slogans.

Tuesday, the Council called for the immediate release of all security prisoners being held in Palestinian prisons and set up a six-member committee to investigate the death of Jumayal. But there are questions as to how effective the Council’s investigation will be in curbing human rights violations.

Because of the questions surrounding its effectiveness, Haidar Abdel Shafi, one of the Council’s most respected members, declined to participate in the Council’s investigation of Jumayal’s death.

“We should understand whether or not the Authority will help us,” Abdel Shafi said during the Council session Tuesday, in an oblique reference to an anticipated lack of regard for the committee’s findings on the part of the government.

“I say this because the Authority has ignored the Council’s resolutions in the past.”

The harsh treatment of the hundreds of security prisoners languishing in Palestinian prisons has been at the top of the Council’s agenda for some time, with limited results. Several weeks ago, Council members succeeded in getting a list of all prisoners from the Justice Ministry. They also succeeded in including a section protecting human rights in the draft Basic Law.

But the Council’s resolutions calling on the government to release all prisoners who have not been charged with a crime have gone unanswered and there is some scepticism that the Council’s draft Basic Law will ever be passed. Arafat has a draft drawn up by his executive officials that he wants passed instead.

Several Council members expressed a sense of betrayal because they had agreed to vote to confirm the government’s ministerial appointees on condition that Arafat would release prisoners jailed without charge. Since the June vote, no significant steps have been taken by the government to release the prisoners.

“We voted yes on the government after being promised the prisoners would be released,” said Council member Salah Taamari, who had planned to vote against the government until he received assurances from Arafat on the prisoner issue. “But they have not been released.”

Jumayal is the seventh Palestinian to die during interrogation in a Palestinian Authority prison. He apparently was interrogated by the Coastal Security, one of numerous security branches that Arafat has set up since his arrival in Gaza two years ago.

Sources estimate there are anywhere from nine to 13 such security branches operating in the West Bank and Gaza. Council members responded angrily to the revelation that the Coastal Security was responsible for the death, which took place in the land-locked West Bank, and condemned the apparent lack of a defined jurisdiction for each security branch.

“What does the Navy have to do with detaining Palestinians in Nablus?” Council member Hosam Khader asked. Khader, a member of Arafat’s own Fatah party and one of the top leaders during the Palestinian uprising, has been vocal in his opposition to Arafat’s policies, once stating that democracy was only possible in Palestine “after Arafat’s death”.

On Tuesday, he went on Israeli TV saying he had been arrested by Israeli security forces 23 times and was never treated the way Palestinian security forces treated Jumayal, a comparison which angered several members of the Council.

A popular activist during the ‘intifada’ uprising against Israel, Jumayal’s death angered the large following he has in Nablus and precipitated two days of violent demonstrations and rioting.

He was arrested eight months ago in connection with a Nablus- based gang which had been extorting money from local merchants during a lawless period just prior to the Palestinian Authority’s arrival in the city, but his alleged connection with the extortion ring did not dim his local popularity.

During a simultaneous demonstration in nearby Tulkarem, security forces shot dead a member of the Islamic opposition Hamas organisation, prompting a call from the militant group for an intifada against the Palestinian Authority.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags