Thursday, November 19, 2026
Gustavo González*
- ”You shall earn your bread by the sweat of your brow” – even if you cannot find a stable, permanent job that pays a living wage.
It is becoming more and more difficult to do so in Latin America, as the informal economy continues to grow, and more flexible labour practices increasingly become the norm.
Critics say the deregulation of the labour market fuels precariousness of employment and the loss of labour and trade union rights, while proponents argue that it is the best way to guarantee the generation of jobs in a free market economy.
”Deregulation deepens inequality and the lack of protections, because the working conditions offered fail to guarantee a minimum level of well-being for workers and their families. And in turn, growing insecurity and precariousness lead to a rise in poverty,” says Arturo Martínez, president of the Central Unitaria de Trabajadores (CUT), Chile’s central trade union.
But Chilean economist Juan Luis Correa, with the Instituto Libertad, a right-wing think tank, told IPS that ”Making the labour market more flexible has only positive, not negative, effects, because it allows employers and workers to generate free choice based on their own needs.”
Trade unions staunchly opposed to more flexible labour practices and business associations and governments that promote them frequently clash in Latin America.
The issue is a heated one in Chile, because the aim of bringing about more flexible labour market arrangements forms part of the ”modernisation” efforts that the centre-left coalition government of Ricardo Lagos agreed on with business associations, and which it is now negotiating with the parties represented in parliament, to secure passage of amended labour laws.
In Mexico, a reform of the country’s labour legislation has been pending in Congress since it was introduced by the government of Vicente Fox in Nove mber 2002.
But it faces stiff resistance from labour unions, social groups and academics, who have held demonstrations and are lobbying hard to keep the lawmakers from voting in favour of the more flexible labour legislation.
Brazil is an exception in the region, because flexibility arrangements are no longer discussed since President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, the head of the leftist Workers’ Party and a former trade unionist, took office on Jan. 1.
The Brazilian Senate shelved an initiative sponsored by the previous government of Fernando Henrique Cardoso, a social democrat, which had already made it through the lower house of Congress.
In Argentina, the government of Fernando de la Rúa (1999-2001) pushed labour reforms through Congress in 2000 that had been sponsored by the administration of Carlos Menem (1989-1999).
But the passage of the amended laws was tainted by allegations that the de la Rúa administration ”purchased” the votes of opposition senators by means of bribes.
At any rate, the new labour laws have not yet been implemented in Argentina, due to a recession that erupted into a severe economic crisis in the three years since the amended labour legislation was enacted.
Above and beyond initiatives aimed at overhauling labour laws, more flexible rules in the labour market have accompanied the drastic ”neo-liberal” structural adjustment measures that have been widely implemented in Latin America since the 1980s, and have ended up being imposed in a de facto manner thanks to the globalisation process, according to the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC).
The regional United Nations agency stated in a May 2002 report on ”Globalisation and Development” that proponents of deregulation argue that it is a necessary condition for bolstering competitiveness, especially that of sectors in Latin America that are most directly involved in the process of integration into the global economy.
In simple terms, the move towards a more flexible labour market is aimed at eliminating rigid rules that entail fixed expenses for employers, in terms of wages and social and health benefits, which trade unions have negotiated through collective bargaining and on the basis of a pre-established workday.
According to Correa, the rigid rules ”lead to the inadequate assignation of resources and to rising costs, which means less companies enter the market to hire workers, and thus the offer of employment diminishes.”
On the other hand, more flexible labour practices ”enable new companies, new employers, to join the market, and the ratio of workers to employers thus shrinks. By being free, workers have greater negotiating power, which generates improved benefits for them,” the economist maintained.
Employers also benefit because ”they have a greater chance of developing as productive enterprises,” Correa added, arguing that ”workers lose their guarantees when there is a scarcity of employers.”
But in the view of CUT president Martínez, those premises are false. The aim of the arguments set forth by the advocates of greater flexibility, he said, is to ensure high levels of labour mobility, flexible wages, and a reduction in costs for employers. He also refuted claims that more jobs are generated in a deregulated labour market.
Deregulation has led to the proliferation of poor quality, unstable, low-paid jobs in inadequate working conditions, that lack social benefits and protections, according to ECLAC, which warns of the growing weight of unstable informal employment in Latin America.
The informal economy employs between 40 and 70 percent of the labour force in the nations of Latin America.
In Argentina, the percentage of wage-earning workers who have no contract – and thus receive no benefits – climbed from 21.9 percent in 1990 to 33 percent in 1997, while the proportion rose from 35.1 percent in 1990 to 46.3 percent in 1996 in Brazil, and from 32.4 percent in 1989 to 37.7 percent in 1996 in Mexico, according to ECLAC statistics.
In Venezuela, 52.3 percent of the 11.8 million people who make up the economically active population depend on the informal economy for their livelihood.
Néstor de Buen, a Mexican labour lawyer, told IPS that Fox’s proposed labour reforms are ”profoundly reactionary and conservative,” as they are aimed at ”doing away with basic social rights, while they undermine stability in employment and curb the growth of the independent labour movement.”
Venezuela’s labour legislation was overhauled in 1996 under president Rafael Caldera (1994-1999), and a further ”de facto” deregulation is now being adopted by employers, to make up for the losses they suffered in the two-month (December-January) general strike that unsuccessfully attempted to topple President Hugo Chávez.
Carlos Ortega, the head of CTV, Venezuela’s main labour union, which is opposed to Chávez, agreed – from political exile in Costa Rica – to temporary measures like a unilateral reduction of jobs and wages and modifications of work schedules and working conditions.
But the leading business assocation, Fedecamaras, apparently wants the measures to remain permanently in place.
In Chile, CUT complains that the labour market was sufficiently deregulated by the labour laws imposed in 1982 by the dictatorship of Gen Augusto Pinochet (1973-1990).
In the 1990s, the freedom of workers to organise and other labour rights were restored. But the freedom enjoyed by businesses to unilaterally set employees’ daytime and nighttime schedules has increased, said Martínez.
In Santiago, IPS briefly consulted seven workers from different productive and services sectors of the economy.
Six of them said they approved of more flexible labour laws, and the seventh said he did not know what they consisted of. But three said they had recently changed jobs against their will, and all seven agreed that job stability is not protected in Chile.
*Diego Cevallos in Mexico, Marcela Valente in Argentina, Humberto Márquez in Venezuela and Mario Osava in Brazil contributed to this report.