Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

UNITED NATIONS: Poverty-Stricken States Shun Security Council

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, May 21 1996 (IPS) - Small Third World nations are not represented in the United Nation’s most powerful body, the Security Council, for one simple reason — they cannot afford to join.

A diplomat from a tiny Caribbean state offered this assessment as United Nations members debate how the influential Security Council can be expanded to provide for broader representation.

“Let’s be honest about it. The larger states can afford to carry the seats in the Security Council. But the smaller states have kept away because they are too poor and cannot afford to be in the Council,” Ambassador Edward Laing of Belize told IPS.

A former British Crown colony with a population about 200,000, Belize has thrown itself into the middle of a fractious debate on the reform and restructuring of the Security Council currently underway at the United Nations.

With a 185-member working group deadlocked on the issue of Security Council expansion, Belize has taken up the cause of the poorer states by proposing a new concept — “shared seats.”

Since too many countries are chasing too few seats in the Council, Belize wants some of the countries to share the limited number of seats.

Laing says regional neighbours and members with common interests should be allowed to share single seats– both permanent and non-permanent– on the Security Council, the U.N.’s executive body.

“The shared seats notion does what no other proposal so far permits,” he said. “It provides for the participation of the more than 50 percent of the members of the United Nations which have never, or almost never, occupied seats — not because of the selfishness of larger states, but because we are simply too poor to field … even modest delegations which are required.”

On an average, smaller states have two or three diplomats serving in their U.N. missions in New York. But, Laing says, any country serving in the Security Council has to have at least twice that number, or even more.

However, most small states cannot afford the expenses involved in running such relatively big U.N. missions in one of the world’s most expensive cities. The sharing of seats also means sharing expenses on behalf of a single country representing collective interests.

Of the 185 member states, about 77 have never served even a single term in the Security Council: 15 from Africa; 28 from Asia; 12 from East Europe; 14 from Latin America and the Caribbean; six from Western Europe; and two that do not belong to any of the groups at the United Nations.

The 15-member Security Council, created in the context of the Cold War more than 50 years ago, has five veto-wielding permanent members and 10 rotating non-permanent members. The big five in the Council are the U.S., Britain, France, China and Russia.

After nearly two years of closed-door sessions, the working group has failed to reached agreement on how the politically important U.N. body should be expanded and restructured. The group, however, is expected to submit its recommendations to the upcoming General Assembly in September.

The need for restructuring has been prompted by the fact that the current Council is heavily weighted in favour of industrial nations, while the overwhelming majority of U.N. members are developing nations.

But none of contenders for the new seats in an expanded Council is a small states.

At least nine countries are battling it out for the new permanent seats: Japan and Germany, as industrial powers; India and Indonesia, representing Asia; Nigeria, South Africa and Egypt, representing Africa; and Brazil and Argentina, representing Latin America and the Caribbean.

With the working group deadlocked, Laing said, there is a need for bold and visionary action. “If existing concepts won’t work any longer, we must use new ones,” he said.

He also pointed out that seat-sharing has been working effectively in such agencies as the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank.

Additionally, Laing said, a very substantial proportion of peacekeeping exercises in recent years has been conducted by regional agencies or arrangements. “The solidarity in security matters which has epitomized those actions is the thrust of our proposal,” he said.

Even Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Ghali, Laing noted, has repeatedly emphasized that peace and security should increasingly be viewed as a shared endeavour between the global organisation and regional agencies.

“It is, therefore, fair and rational to facilitate the participation on the Council of small states,” he said.

Laing said that while small states have been underrepresented in the Council, during the past 15 years they have been deeply involved in many of the matters of the most crucial importance dealt with by the Council.

He cited the examples of Maldives, Comoros and Grenada threatened by mercenaries and insurrections, the Pacific and Caribbean states threatened by nuclear testing and passage of nuclear waste and Central America embroiled in regional conflicts.

“The locales of many of the unrepresented small states are also included among the world’s most strategic areas,” he said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags