Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE: ‘Illegal’ Students Dodge Israel Security Forces

Deborah Horan

BIRZEIT, Occupied West Bank, May 8 1996 (IPS) - Sitting outside the student cafeteria at the West Bank’s most prestigious university, Ra’fat Radwan explained with a nervous smile how two strokes of ‘luck’ will make it possible for him to graduate this year.

First, at the Muslim feast of Eid al-Fitr two months ago, when other students from his native Gaza headed home to visit family, he remained in the West Bank on a hunch — which turned out to be right — that Israel would prevent the students from returning.

Then, a few weeks later, he was sleeping safely in neighboring Ramallah when the Israeli army descended in helicopters on student housing in the nearby village of Birzeit in a sweep aimed at catching Gaza students who defied a military order to return immediately to Gaza.

“I guess it’s my good luck,” said the 26 year-old history and geography student. But he still lives in fear of being caught.

Without proper permits since the March raid, he is technically studying ‘illegally’ in the West Bank. “I haven’t been home in two years and I live in Ramallah because it’s safer.” While he speaks, another Gaza student walks by. “We woke up and heard the Israelis outside, the helicopters and army jeeps,” he recalls.

“We ran away and hid in a construction site for seven hours while they arrested everybody.” Radwan and his friend are two of only 60 or so students out of 300 from Gaza studying at Birzeit who managed to stay on and continue their studies.

Most were not so lucky. Two hundred who went home for the Muslim feast that marks the end of Ramadan found themselves trapped once Israel rescinded their permits and clamped a “closure on Gaza and the West Bank following a string of suicide bombings.

Some 37 more students were shipped back following the dawn raid that Radwan and his friend had narrowly escaped. Israeli soldiers arrested 600 students, handcuffed and blindfolded them — and then sent those from Gaza back home. The others were later released and allowed to continue their studies.

The plight of Gaza students caught the attention of several of the newly-elected Palestinian parliament members, at least two of whom reportedly “smuggled” students in their cars on trips to the West Bank.

Last week, Israel revoked the VIP cards of Palestinian MPs Intisar al-Wazir and Abdul Rahman Hamad — cards that allow them to travel freely between the West Bank and Gaza — because they were caught transporting students.

“They feel with the students,” said Hosam Zomlot, one of the students who went home for the holiday and got stuck in Gaza. “I don’t think they did anything wrong. We’re not dangerous. We just want to study.”

The mood among Gaza’s trapped students is grim. Many, like Zomlot, planned to graduate in June. Most are studying in fields, like engineering and psychology, that are not available at Gaza’s two universities.

“You study at Birzeit or An-Najah [in the West Bank] for a reason,” said Zomlot. “Birzeit is not only the best university. It (instills) a sense of nationalism. It teaches you about your community, your responsibility to your society.”

Israel maintains that sending Gaza students back to Gaza is a necessary security measure because when the colour-coded permits are cancelled — and they are cancelled often — each permit holder must apply for a new one from his home area.

Staff at Birzeit University disagree. “It’s not necessary for Israeli security,” said Catherine Grosso, a U.S. citizen who works for a human rights action project at the university which monitors the arrests of students. “Why do they single out Gaza students?

It’s only because Gaza students are identifiable and therefore easy to punish.” The Israeli measure is not new. Some 1,300 students from Gaza study at the West Bank’s five universities, but in the past ten semesters, students have missed all of part of their studies because permits were cancelled, revoked, or issued after the semester had begun, according to university officials.

The problems is so acute that Birzeit University’s public relations department distributes a poster that reads: “You think the Israeli-Palestinian peace accords have made a difference? Not to Gazan students.”

Gaza students say that for years they have managed to sneak out of Gaza without permits by hiding in tomato trucks or swimming from Gaza to Israel and then crossing into the West Bank. Most students have colorful “war stories” about how they made it to university or narrowly escaped being caught in the West Bank — boastful stories that become hallowed folklore among the students.

For instance, two years ago, when the army raided student housing around Birzeit, Radwan hid for two hours in a water tank on the roof, only to be shot in the foot as he ran into the hills and escaped, he says, taking off his shoe and showing off a bullet wound.

Zomlot, boyish, with light features and sandy blonde hair, he said he has three times dressed as a Jewish settler and driven out of Gaza, calling out a happy ‘shalom’ with a smile and a wave to the soldier at the border.

And Sharif al-Sharif made university history when he was caught in the morning, sent back to Gaza, and reappeared that afternoon — covered with white ash from the cement truck he was hiding in.

“Imagine yourself in our position,” Zomlot said. “You miss everything in your life — your plans, your future — if you cannot complete your studies. That’s why we take these risks.”

Bravado aside, there is a very real cost to the students’ education. University officials estimate that a four year degree takes an average of seven years because of university closures, permit problems, closures and student arrests.

And while most students say they will struggle on to finish their degree, the strain and constant fear takes its toll. Once Radwan gets his undergraduate degree, he plans to go for a Master’s — but not in the West Bank.

Instead, he plans to apply to Georgetown University in Washington D.C., where he has a brother studying.

“I’m tired,” said the 26-year-old student. “I’m tired of sleeping in the mountains, tired of being scared while I’m trying to study at night. I want to go somewhere else. Somewhere safe.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags