Thursday, November 19, 2026
John Roberts
- For eighteen years the U.N. has sought to hold the ring in South Lebanon, but its original mission has proved impossible in the face of Israeli intransigence and its own inability to protect Lebanese civilians.
These twin realities were graphically illustrated by the destruction wrought by Israeli artillery on a key U.N. base in South Lebanon Thursday. At least 100 people died and 104 were wounded. Yet while the scale of Thursday’s devastation was unprecedented, the U.N. has faced these problems ever since it was first despatched to the region in March 1978.
Its original mission was to supervise the withdrawal of Israeli forces from a large swathe of Southern Lebanon, which the Jewish state had occupied in what it called ‘Operation Litani’ — staged, like the current ‘Operation Grapes of Wrath’, to clear the border region of hostile forces.
But Israel decided to only withdrew from two-thirds of this territory — the rest, a border strip which now constitutes the bulk of Israel’s so-called ‘security zone’ — was handed over to an Israeli supplied militia force known as the South Lebanese Army.
The U.N. troops have always tried to keep their areas clear of guerrillas. But this has proved increasingly impossible as, first Palestinians guerrillas and then Hizbollah and Amal Shi’ite militants infiltrated through its lines to the Israeli security zone.
The countryside consists of a maze of low hills and undulating valleys leading from the Mediterranean to the slopes of Mount Hermon. Such contours aid lightly equipped guerrillas, whilst a multiplicity of small roads and tracks enables them to ferry Katyusha rockets in the backs of their cars to within range of Israel’s northern towns.
Israel’s refusal to effect a complete pullout changed the U.N.’s role. When then U.S. President Jimmy Carter unexpectedly threw the full weight of U.S. power behind the despatching of the U.N. Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL), it was largely because Washington considered its main role would be to help prevent Palestinian infiltration into Northern Israel.
But Israel and the SLA then started targeting UNIFIL and U.N. forces found themselves focusing as much, if not more, on deflecting Israeli and Israeli-inspired attacks as in dealing with Palestinian infiltrators. The officer commanding an Irish U.N. Battalion told IPS at the time: “We came here to face North, but found ourselves facing South.”
Israel’s 1982 invasion of Lebanon, and its occupation of much of the country until 1985, forced the Palestinian Liberation Organisation (PLO) to pull its guerrilla forces out of the country.
But again, Israel’s refusal to effect a complete withdrawal resulted in the emergence of an even more formidable foe — the Hizbollah. The majority of the population of Southern Lebanon are Shi’ite Muslims and Hizbollah is their principal organisation.
Its fighters routinely cross U.N. lines, although they endeavour to carry out most of their attacks in the so-called Israeli security zone. On Thursday, a senior Lebanese official said quite simply “Hizbollah is part of the Lebanese resistance”.
The official, Mohammed Obeid, described Hizbollah as “the result, and not the reason” for the fighting in South Lebanon. He added that “if Israel withdraws from Lebanese territory, there will be no reason for the Lebanese resistance, or for Hizbollah.”
Its military role rendered irrelevant by both Israel and Hizbollah, UNIFIL’s 4,500 men essentially become a kind of armed humanitarian force, cooperating with local civilians to build roads, schools and hospitals, and provide basic services.
Their major encampments at Cana — the base struck with such destructiveness Thursday — Tibnine and Mansoura, are commonly regarded as havens for civilians fleeing Israeli attack. The U.N. base at Cana is of major importance. It is the headquarters of the Fijian Battalion and commands a five-way intersection.
Israel, which says its forces are not supposed to open fire on positions within 500 metres of such U.N. installations, has full details of U.N. operations at Cana, which lies just 12 kilometres north of the border with Israel.
Yet Israel’s immediate argument was that it opened fire on a site some 300-400 metres from Cana, from which it said Hizbollah had launched Katyusha rockets.
It also has constantly stressed in the past the accuracy of its shooting. Reports from the area indicated a mood of scepticism in UNIFIL ranks concerning Israel’s assertion that the carnage at Cana had been a mistake.
Such scepticism focused on the paradox that whilst the attack on Cana was said to be a mistake, in the past Israel has never missed when it has deliberately fired at or near U.N. positions. A U.N. convoy passing through the Irish Battalion’s area Thursday came under Israeli fire.
UNIFIL also has a long memory where reports of Israeli shelling are concerned. In 1979 a Lebanese army column marching southwards under U.N. escort to deploy alongside U.N. troops was dispersed by heavy shellfire from the south.
The Lebanese mission had been approved at the highest international levels, with Israel promising it would not block the deployment. United States Army officers who investigated the incident for the U.N. reported that back-bearings from the shells showed they had been launched by Israeli army officers, firing from positions within Israel.
Ironically, Israel’s official spokesman, Uri Dromi, on Thursday reiterated recent Israeli Government calls for the Lebanese Government to accept responsibility for restraining Hizbollah.
“We have no territorial claim on even one inch of Lebanese territory,” he said, “but the reason we have to deploy some of our forces is that we were subject to so much aggression from Lebanon, with the Lebanese Government doing nothing about it.”
The U.N. itself would no doubt find another of Dromi’s comments equally ironic. “We had no intention of hitting the U.N. — on the contrary, we work with them on a daily basis.”
Shortly after UNIFIL was first established in 1978, IPS interviewed the Force’s first Commander, Ghana’s Lieutenant Colonel Emmanuel Erskine.
He said bluntly that while Israel was prepared to provide cooperation and logistics — vital since UNIFIL was at that time largely supplied via Israel — he secured no political or military cooperation from Israel. Nothing seems to have changed since then.