Development & Aid, Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE: Israeli Security Squeeze Impoverishes ‘Self-Rule’ Areas

Deborah Horan

HEBRON, West Bank, Mar 12 1996 (IPS) - On a dingy street in the Wadi Tuffah neighbourhood of Hebron, the Ramko shoe factory has closed its doors. Across the street, the manager of Reem Sports Shoes estimates that he too will have to close down within a week.

Shoe manufacturing was once the thriving key to the Hebron economy and employed some 8,000 workers. Today, as Israel seals up the region in reply to a string of suicide bombs that killed more than 60, it and the entire Palestinian economy are in dire straits.

A ban on travel between towns and villages in the West Bank, as well as a total cessation of imports into Gaza, has locked up Palestinians in their communities, preventing goods and people from coming in or going out.

Hebron, the last town still waiting to be turned over to Palestinian rule under the post-Oslo peace accords, is torn by constant friction between Palestinians and radical Jewish settlers. Its economy had been slowly worn down by repeated Israeli security closures and curfews, even before this latest siege.

Other towns are feeling the crunch. In Ramallah, shops are boarded up; in Nablus, factories are shut; at the post office in Arab East Jerusalem, lanes were closed because employees could not get to work.

“We don’t know how many days we can withstand this abnormal state,” complained Jibreel Natsheh, owner of Reem Sports Shoes. “The feeling of the people is very bad, hopeless.”

To Palestinians, the travel ban is a harsh response, an unfair collective punishment. To Israel, it is a necessary evil in the face of a cruel campaign of indiscriminate bombings carried out on buses and busy street corners by the military wing and a splinter group of the Islamic Resistance (Hamas) organisation.

“I am opposed to collective punishment,” said Israeli Prime Minister Shimon Peres. But if there is collective planning of terrorism, “there is no other way to break down their resolve.”

While Palestinian officials say that they understand the reason for the measures and intend to do what they can to prevent further attacks, they also say the situation is deteriorating fast.

“It is virtually impossible for an already weak, in fact destroyed, Palestinian economy to function with any degree of normality under such strangulation,” senior Palestinian negotiator Ahmed Qure’i told the Jerusalem-based Palestine Report.

Palestinian economists say it is difficult to tell how long the economy can endure the siege. Some cities are worse off than others. The jig-saw puzzle of jurisdictions in the West Bank that was ushered in by the Oslo accord, whereby much of the land was left under Israeli control, means that not all Palestinians are equally locked up.

Those living or working in areas still under full or partial Israeli control have some freedom of movement. But the seven major population centers under complete Palestinian jurisdiction are surrounded by Israeli checkpoints.

Gaza is in a much worse state, say most economists, with no supplies being allowed in and an Israeli-imposed naval blockade preventing fishermen from fishing.

Economists say the Palestinian economy as a whole loses about six million dollars per day, some 1.3 million dollars of which comes from lost wages of day laborers working in Israel. The rest results from lost exports, lost tourism, and lost agriculture, which spoils before it gets to market.

Samir Huleileh, an economist with the Palestinian Economic Council for Development and Reconstruction (PECDAR), says that the short term ability of Palestinians to survive is not the most worrying economic issue.

“The problem is survival of the people in the medium and the long term,” he said. “The (long term) economic effects of this closure is what’s important.”

“In industry, a few sectors depend on subcontracting to Israel,” Huleileh added. “They risk losing their contracts. In Nablus, a dairy products factory has closed. Who will pay for these two or three weeks?”

Analysts say the duration of the travel ban depends on Israel’s appraisal of the nascent Palestinian government’s ability to reign in Hamas. In recent days, Peres has expressed satisfaction with Palestinian president Yasser Arafat’s crackdown on militants and Israeli newspapers have printed stories casting Arafat’s efforts in a positive light.

But the crackdown is not yet complete, and meanwhile, the peace process hangs in the balance. Israelis, devastated by this latest spate of bombings, have lost confidence in a peace process that has brought them no peace. Opinion polls show opposition right- wing Likud leader Binyamin Netanyahu slightly ahead of Peres.

Israeli patience has worn so thin, says Israeli analyst Gershon Baskin, head of a left wing Jerusalem-based think tank, that they want only two things: “The Israeli public wants to see Palestinian blood and the Israeli public wants to not see Palestinians,” he bluntly states.

On their side, Palestinians initially appalled by the bombings are becoming angry at the security measures that are squeezing them. Oslo, they say, has not lived up to their expectations of an end to Israeli military occupation of the West Bank and Gaza nor of an end to Israeli government control over their lives.

Rumors, albeit unfounded, abound about pregnant women being prevented from getting to hospital and young children dying because of lack of medicine. More ominously, whispers of discontent are flying through the ranks of the Palestinian police, which is supposed to work in coordination with the Israeli army in the West Bank and Gaza.

The international community, at the behest of Peres and U.S. president Bill Clinton, will be showing support for Peres’ version of peace when they meet to re-endorse the current peace process in the Sinai, Wednesday, but under the circumstances, many analysts here are questioning the point of the conference.

If Likud does come to power, it has pledged to stop the process where it is. There will be no further Israeli ‘redeployment’ (withdrawal) of troops in the West Bank and Palestinians will be enclosed in seven isolated ‘cantons’ which make up a mere six percent of West Bank territory and 80 percent of Gaza. The rest Israel will keep.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags