Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

EGYPT: Crimes Of Violence By Women Under Study

Yasser Talaat

CAIRO, Mar 11 1996 (IPS) - Egyptian social scientists are considering the complex factors that lie behind crimes of violence committed by women, often against their own husbands and frequently in response to attacks in the home.

The cases of the 20 wives who murdered their husbands in 1995 have shocked the country — the image of Egyptian woman as presented by tradition is one of domestic obedience in both youth and marriage. And the salacious nature of some cases have drawn widespread media attention.

In one widely publicised case a 22 year old wife stabbed her 65 year old husband, then faked an assault by cutting herself with a razor and accusing her step-son of the murder. The investigators found that the husband had a history of violence and jealousy.

“There many reasons for women to commit crimes of violence,” said Ahmed el-Magdoob, a researcher at the National Centre for Social and Crime Research, “and include fights that get out of control, family quarrels, disputes over money or sex, simple desire for vengeance or fights over inheritance or land ownership.”

The actual numbers of reported cases of women committing crimes of violence are almost negligible given Egypt’s 55 million plus population — just 692 cases brought to trial during the period 1984-1993.

And the Egyptian National Police Academy calculates that the number of wives murdered by their husbands is far greater than vice-versa and most jailed women, 62 percent, are there for narcotics related offences.

Also, the figures may be distorted by outside factors. Thirty percent of all reported crimes of violence by women were committed in the country’s thinly populated western governates, while the cases in the huge megapolis of Cairo, even when combined with those from the city of Alexandria, accounted for only 15.7 percent.

Some of this may be due to reporting and arresting trends, as policemen in some areas may be reacting to the ‘shocking’ nature of such culturally challenging crimes — and may be arresting a higher proportion of women than men in cases of alleged criminal violence.

Similarly the proportion of crimes of violence as measured against non-violent crime is normally much higher among men than among women in other countries. Yet in Egypt the proportions are closer; 62.9 percent of all reported crimes committed by men are violent, while 60.5 percent of crimes by women are so.

But Sameeha Nasr, an expert at the National Centre for Social and Crime Research, says the figures still highlight the increasing pressures faced by women within the home, which is for many women a place of violence as well as sometimes backbreaking labour. Many convicted women had also suffered abuse as children.

And if the figures can tell the researchers only a little about the phenomena of female violence, they do say something about the changing social circumstances in different quarters of Egypt.

Over 78 percent of Egyptian women tried for all crimes are illiterate. The higher the educational level of an Egyptian woman, the less chance she has of ending up in front of a judge on a charge of criminal violence.

Those who could merely read made up 13.8 percent of the total, while high school or university graduates made up just about 1.5 percent each. Overwhelmingly, by 81.9 percent, the tried women are married. Eleven percent are single and most convicted women are in the 20-30 years age group.

“This percentage is so high between married women due to the daily pressures and the different role conflicts that women face which imposes a disproportionate burden on them,” said Nasr.

The statisticians also looked at the type of weapon used by the women. Some 21.5 percent of cases involved knives and 14 percent blunt instruments, while methods indicating premeditation, such as cases involving poison (three percent), were much less common.

The most significant conclusion to be drawn from these figures is that they often represent only the most desperate responses to the crime of domestic violence by husbands against wives — a crime that is often suffered in silence and frequently goes unpunished.

Some 20,000 writs for divorce are brought by Egyptian wives against their husbands each year. According to the Egyptian Ministry of Justice about 90 percent of divorce cases before the courts are based around physical cruelty allegations.

“Around 66.6 percent of Egyptian women are hit by their husbands,” said Farida el-Nakash, an Egyptian activist who helped prepare Egypt’s presentation on the issue to the 1995 Beijing U.N. World Conference on Women.

“This is due to new cultures that are appearing in society, but also due to the pressure which poor men in society face. As they lose ability to express themselves or protest, they hit their wives to release the pent-up violence that frustration generates.”

The courts are relatively lenient in these cases. Divorce in Muslim marriages is an established right but even members of Christian faiths that prohibit divorce have successfully petitioned for legal separation before an Egyptian judge.

“The easiest way to get divorce in an Egyptian court is to prove that your partner has assaulted and harmed you, especially if it happened in front of witnesses,” said lawyer Mohammed el-Saeed.

There have also been a number of high profile cases that have convinced women trapped in violent relationships that escape through the courts is possible.

The famous dancer and actress Tahia Karioka, now 70 years old, divorced her actor-director husband Faiez Halawa in 1980 because he used to hit her in public. Fellow actress Shereen, 36, won a divorce from her husband Osama Mustapha on the same grounds.

But a final conclusion of a different kind was drawn by Laila Abd el-Wahab, sociology professor at Banha university. The application of justice, she noted, was no answer to the need to find ways of preventing the criminal act in the first place.

“No one must be hit either a man, a women, a boy or a girl,” she told IPS. “It is the rejected way of barbarians. There must be another solution.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags