Development & Aid, Europe, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

IRELAND: Refugees Confront Wave Of Racist Anger

Sarah O'Hara

DUBLIN, Jun 16 1997 (IPS) - The eyes of the friendly open-faced young man in the corner shop shift sideways as he speaks: “My friends told me that there’s a gang of them going around Dublin robbing shops, and they’re coming this way!”

He speaks almost as if their footsteps can be heard on the busy street outside. ‘They’ are the ‘Romanians’ and ‘Bosnians’, who by popular legend at least, have invaded the Irish capital, bringing theft, fraud and general disorder in their wake.

The stories that accompany them are lurid in the extreme: talk of ‘beggars’ driving Mercedes, of gangs trafficking in people, of obscure religions and their ‘sacrificial ceremonies’, even the story how one Romanian beggar cut off the finger of her own child to gain more sympathy on the streets.

While more refugees have looked to Ireland as other European states adopt restrictive policies towards refugees, the numbers arriving in Ireland have always been minuscule by the standards of other European Union nations, at about 1,300 so far this year.

However, even that is double last year’s number of 1,197 in all, and 32 times the number for 1992 when there were just 39 applications for asylum.

So far most of the public antagonism as voiced in the media has been directed against other white Europeans, the Bosnians and Romanians who have been labelled as beggars, thieves and scroungers.

“It’s a disgrace that I worked 47 years in my life and they just walk into the country and get everything I don’t get — a medical card, free rent and 64 pounds a week in the pocket,” the Irish News quoted one fruit seller in Dublin’s working-class Camden Street.

“But if you look in their heads, from the youngest up, you’ll see 500 or 600 pounds (755-930 dollars) worth of teeth, all in gold.”

But it is acting as a trigger for what one refugee describes as “the closet racism that has always existed” in Ireland.

“I feel more Irish than the Irish themselves but am being judged recently by my country of origin, and worse still, by that which I cannot conceal, my colour,” wrote a long-time Iraqi refugee in the newsletter, ‘The Voice of Refugees’.

“We’re getting black people — Somalis, Zaireans — coming in here and saying they find Irish people on the street are making abusive comments. Particularly in the past month,” says Pat O’Brien of Dublin’s Irish Refugee Council, organisers of the asylum conference.

There have also been abusive phone calls and insults on the office intercom. The sign on its front door was spray painted out. “It surprises me that there are people prepared to go to those lengths,” says O’Brien.

As for the refugees themselves, a good deal of buck passing is going on as Bosnians blame Romanians and Romanians blame the ‘Roma’ — Central Europe’s centuries old ‘gypsy community, a large number of whom are Romanian citizens.

A spokesman for the 700 Bosnian refugees in Ireland has released a statement saying that “other nationalities” were using the sympathy generated by the Bosnian plight to gain money.

The Irish Times said that while street traders blamed ‘Bosnians’ for the thievery in Camden Street, “the trouble is caused almost exclusively by Romanians”.

“They have no inhibitions about begging,” said a volunteer working with political refugees from Africa who preferred not to give his name to IPS. “They put on the really successful manipulative ‘poor mouth’ and then you see them with a car. They wouldn’t be able to do that on 64 pounds (99 dollars) a week.”

The Romanians disown the Roma as well. “(Even) they don’t call themselves Romanians”, says Radu Brinzan, 25, a Romanian student in Dublin helping refugees to find accommodation. “They’re called Romanian because they hold Romanian passports.”

The Roma face discrimination across central Europe; the most marginalised of the regions’ impoverished, with their own language and culture.

Lack of information fuels the speculation. The gypsies refuse to talk to reporters, perhaps because of their poor English, or perhaps because they fear it will affect their status as asylum- seekers.

They have been dubbed ‘economic refugees’ — a phrase that has taken on a pejorative meaning to distinguish them from the hundreds of supposed ‘genuine’ asylum seekers who fled Bosnia during the 1992-1995 conflict. Under the law different immigration rules apply to the different groups. Officially most of their cases are yet to be decided by the Department of Justice.

The saddest irony of the whole affair for many — including the country’s widely respected president Mary Robinson — is how badly the situation squares with Ireland’s own history.

For hundreds of years the Irish have left home to seek better fortunes elsewhere, mainly to Britain and the United States but further afield, to Latin America and Australsia.

The Irish ‘chancers’ can even be found hard at work in central Europe, running the ‘Irish pubs’ that are the craze across the continent.

The year 1986 was the first in decades when there were more people coming to live in Ireland than were leaving to make new homes and lives for their families elsewhere.

The current wave of racism in Ireland betrays that definitive tradition of migration, Robinson told a conference on racism Friday, billed ‘Asylum – An Opportunity for Ireland’.

“If we have the right approach, then we will have no difficulty in coping with the practical problems,” she told the group.

She cited the special arrangements made for Irish migrants to the United States in recent years, as well as the 150th anniversary of the Great Potato Famine in Ireland, that sent more than a million Irish over the Atlantic to make new lives in the 1840s.

“Yes, there are practical problems, there are issues that must be dealt with and they are in the realm of policy,” she said.

“But if our mind is right, if our approach is right, if we seize the opportunity to be true to our own history, to our story as a people, then we will cope with those practical problems and we will do it in the right spirit and we will do it in the right way.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags