Thursday, November 19, 2026
Judith Perera
- As fears about the safety of organophosphorous (OP) pesticides grow, farmers world-wide are increasingly turning to pyrethroids as a supposed “safe” alternative.
Pyrethroids are deemed by their manufacturers to be less harmful to man and mammals, though highly toxic to fish and some beneficial insects such as bees.
But evidence is now mounting that their toxicity in water is far greater than was previously thought, raising the possibility that the poisoning of natural resources by pesticides may be more widespread than first thought.
Britain’s Environment Agency and the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (SEPA) have called on the government to review guidelines which allow farmers to pour waste dip into holes or onto fields where it will biodegrade. British farmers have been using pyrethroids as sheep dips over the past few years in preference to the supposedly more dangerous OPs.
The guidelines were drawn up with OPs in mind, says Ray Prigg, a senior ecologist with the Environment Agency’s north-west region. However, pyrethroids are so toxic that “if dipped sheep drip while grazing near streams, that can provide the few nanograms of pesticide per litre of water required to kill freshwater shrimps,” he told IPS. The agencies say that river life is being decimated by the increased agricultural use of pyrethroids.
Up to a half of all sheep farmers in Britain are believed to have stopped using OP dips over the past two years after fears about the health effects of workers being exposed to the chemicals. The synthetic pyrethroids which are less harmful to humans, are killing thousands of invertebrates in rivers and lakes.
According to Donny Morrison of SEPA: “Pyrethroids are undoubtedly safer for farmers than the conventional OPs. But we estimate they are at least a hundred times more toxic in the aquatic environment than OPs, especially to invertebrates.”
Pyrethroids are the third type of pesticide to be used extensively in agriculture since the Second World War. In the 1950s and 1960s organochlorines (OCs) such as DDT, aldrin and dieldrin were the chemicals of choice.
But in the 1970s they were mostly withdrawn from use and many were banned as evidence mounted that they were accumulating in the environment and the food chain. Their use still continues in some developing and ex-communist countries where there are also large stocks of old OC chemicals awaiting safe disposal.
OCs were replaced by OPs which are less persistent in the environment.
Perhaps surprisingly OPs were developed on the back of military research into nerve gases. Perhaps unsurprisingly it has now been shown that they can cause permanent nervous system damage either as a result of a single exposure to a high dose or long-term exposure to low doses.
Many sheep farmers in Britain who were legally obliged to dip their sheep twice a year for many years claim that their health has been permanently damaged as a result and are now seeking compensation from the government.
Compulsory dipping was ended in 1995 in face of increasing complaints about serious health effects.
OPs are also the main suspect as a major cause for the Gulf War Syndrome — a cluster of symptoms experienced by thousands of troops in Britain and the U.S. who served in the 1991 Gulf War against Iraq.
After denying the existence of a specific syndrome for several years the British and U.S. authorities are now both carrying out extensive research to investigate the ill health of their troops and identify a cause.
Troops were exposed to OPs in the form of insecticides sprayed into their living accommodation and even inside their clothes to protect against sand flies. There are also allegations that troops may also have been exposed to chemical weapons (also OPs) as a result of the destruction of captured Iraqi weapons.
The situation is complicated by the long list of vaccinations most troops were given before they left for the Gulf.
Defence Department and Veterans Administration officials in the U.S. admit that at least 5,000 of 80,000 Gulf War veterans examined so far have illnesses that cannot be diagnosed. But they insist that no single ‘Gulf War Syndrome’ has been found.
Two recent studies in the U.S. suggest that the ill health of the troops may result from combinations of low-level chemical weapons, pesticides and other agents such as insect repellent (DEET) and anti-nerve-gas tablets.
One of the studies concluded that 2,000 Gulf War veterans in Iowa reported more illnesses than veterans who did not go to the Gulf, probably because of the Gulf War veterans’ greater exposure to chemicals, solvents and other agents.
The other study, of 249 Navy combat construction units known as ‘Seabees’, conducted by University of South-western Texas Medical Centre researchers, found three primary Gulf War syndromes and three secondary ones.
Dr Robert Haley, director of the study, said they were caused by combinations of low-level exposure to chemicals including pyridostigmine bromide anti-nerve gas pills, insect repellents and pesticides.
“Many Gulf War veterans are suffering from three primary syndromes. The syndromes are due to subtle brain, spinal cord and nerve damage,” he says.
The most serious confusion syndrome was found in Seabees who believed they had been exposed to chemical war gas attacks or reported excessive side effects after taking the anti-nerve gas pills.
An “impaired cognition” syndrome of bad memory, depression, insomnia, fatigue and headaches was suffered by Seabees who wore flea collars to ward off insects. A third Gulf War syndrome of muscle pains and weakness was found in Seabees who were exposed to concentrated insect repellent containing 75 percent of DEET and who had excessive side effects from taking pyridostigmine bromide.
The two studies contradicted the conclusion of President Bill Clinton’s advisory committee on Gulf War illnesses, which said on Jan. 7 that no such specific causes of unexplained illnesses had been found but that stress was a major factor.
With evidence from British sheep farmers and Gulf War veterans, it seems that OPs may soon suffer the same fate as OCs. This leaves only the pyrethroids. But these too now seem to have their problems.
“This effectively leaves no major class of insecticide which can be considered safe,” says Peter Beaumont of the London-based Pesticides Trust. “It may not be too long before integrated pest management and organic farming come into their own.”