Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS: Canada, U.S. Courts Limit Forced Treatment of Mentally Ill

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Jun 24 2003 (IPS) - The highest courts in Canada and the United States have handed down decisions that strengthen the rights of mentally ill people who refuse to be treated with drugs, say experts.

In the decision here earlier this month, the Supreme Court of Canada expanded the rights of psychiatric patients to refuse treatment. In a 6-3 ruling, it by quashed a government order that a man held in an institution for criminal offenders with mental disorders be forced to accept drug treatment for bipolar disorder (formerly known as manic depression).

In the U.S case, the Supreme Court ruled that doctors could not force a patient to take psychiatric medication to make him mentally fit to stand trial.

The U.S. decision clarifies the rights of accused people to refuse treatment, says Julie Ruiz, counsel for the California-based Centre for Cognitive Liberty and Ethics, which filed a brief with the Supreme Court in support of Dr. Charles Sell, 53. Different states had been followed varying rules, she told IPS.

”The Supreme Court clarified this issue, which had been interpreted different ways by different courts. This is a situation where a person’s medical rights conflicted with their legal rights, and the court found that accused people do have rights to refused to be drugged.”

The Canadian case concerned Scott Starson, who had been held at the prison-like Oak Ridge institution north of Toronto in central Ontario province. Starson, 47, is an accomplished scientist who has had papers published in major academic journals despite having no academic degrees.


His work has been successfully peer reviewed by some of the world’s top physicists, some of who wrote letters of support to Canadian courts on Starson’s behalf.

The Supreme Court ruled Starson should not have to accept drug treatments, despite evidence of diminished mental capacity.

The decision "is a really strong endorsement of self-determination, such that only in the rarest cases will someone not be able to make their own treatment decisions," says Marshall Swadron, counsel for the Mental Health Legal Advocacy Coalition in Toronto.

The Ontario Superior Court, the Ontario Court of Appeal, and now the Supreme Court, in a 6-3 decision, all found the decision of a provincial treatment board that Starson should be medicated to be "unreasonable".

"The board disregarded clear evidence of (Starson’s) capacity," Supreme Court of Canada Justice John Major wrote for the majority.

The court noted that "by all accounts, Professor Starson is an extraordinarily intelligent and unique individual”. Among his publications, the self-taught physicist wrote a 1991 Stanford University paper entitled ‘Discrete Anti-Gravity’.

Since 1985, Starson has been admitted to several mental institutions in both the United States and Canada. He has most often been diagnosed as having a bipolar disorder.

Starson was put in Oak Ridge in 2000 after uttering death threats against a doctor. Starson’s psychiatrists prescribed a treatment including neuroleptic medication, mood stabilisers, anti-anxiety medication, and anti-Parkinsonian medication.

But Starson did not agree with doctors that he suffered from an illness and refused to take the medication, saying its effects "would be worse than death for me, because I have always considered normal to be a term so boring, it would be like death."

The drugs, he said, would transform him "into a struggling-to-think drunk", and would therefore limit his pursuits in physics.

The Ontario Consent and Capacity Board held that despite cogent evidence of a medical disorder, Starson was in "almost total" denial of his illness. It concluded that because Starson did not acknowledge he was ill, he lacked the ability to relate treatment information to his own disorder. Therefore, he clearly lacked the capacity to refuse treatment.

(In Canada, mental health care policy is under the jurisdiction of provincial governments).

Doctors appealed the courts’ reversal of the board’s decision all the way to the country’s top court, losing the appeal each time. Ultimately, the Supreme Court ruled, "a patient’s failure to recognise consequences does not necessarily reflect an inability to appreciate consequences".

Swadron predicted the decision would transform the way the Ontario board rules on capacity decisions.

"With the appeal having been dismissed, the board is now going to have to recognise that the test for capacity is not the high threshold that I understand has been applied," he said in an interview.

Doctors will now have to "deal with the law as it is," said Swadron. This means coming up with more creative treatment options than simply prescribing medications, he added.

The same week, the U.S. Supreme Court, in U.S. v. Sell, limited the government’s authority to forcibly medicate mentally ill criminal defendants to make them well enough to stand trial.

The 6-3 ruling means that the government will have to meet certain conditions before putting defendants on anti-psychotic drugs before their trials.

Sell has been diagnosed with a delusional disorder. Court records show that he has seen imaginary leopards, believes the FBI is trying to kill him and wants to go into combat.

Justice Stephen Breyer, writing for the majority, said the government must show that involuntary medications "will significantly further" the goal of bringing the case to trial.

Courts, in considering individual cases, must consider "alternative, less intrusive treatments" of defendants, he added.

The case required the court for the first time to balance the government’s interest in punishing non-violent crime with a person’s constitutional right to control his or her body. Justices said the U.S. Constitution allows the government to administer drugs "in limited circumstances".

The U.S government puts hundreds of defendants on medication each year to make them competent to stand trial.

Breyer said that a lower court should reconsider whether the government could medicate Sell, who has spent more than four years in a prison hospital as his lawyers fought over his drugging.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags