Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

DEVELOPMENT-INDONESIA: Rice Shortages, A Political Tinderbox

Kafil Yamin

JAKARTA, Sep 17 1998 (IPS) - “I cannot afford to buy rice now. But thanks to God, I survive because I have generous neighbours,” said Jumni, an elderly Indonesian woman.

But as the price of rice doubled in the last two months, the charity that sustained Jumni, who lives in Pasawahan subdistrict in Central Java, has run out. She has had to shift from rice to dried cassava.

“I wish I could remain generous to her,” said Enung, a 40- year-old housewife next door. “But more and more people come to me for rice. I am not rich enough to serve them all. No, I can only feed myself and my family.”

“They are supposed to go to the government for help,” she points out, but all local officials can seem to do is appeal to better-off people to help those in need.

Jumni is among the 17 million families across Indonesia who face food shortages, as the effects of a crippling recession seep through the economy.

This week Food Minister A M Saefuddin said that in Central and East Java, 60 percent of 7.3 million poor families, averaging four people to a household, can have only one meal daily.

Another 9.7 million families still eat twice daily, but even this is declining fast. This is a “critical situation”, said Saefuddin.

The soaring prices and scarcity of rice, which is Indonesia’s staple food, is particularly worrisome. As in many Asian nations, access to rice is a key measure of well-being — and problems there signal more social and political unrest for Indonesia.

Indonesia’s rice problems has already reversed one of its successes — self-sufficiency in the staple achieved by the Suharto government in the eighties.

Indeed, many see the rice shortage as a threat to national stability. Already, there have been reports of people looting state rice stores and raiding trucks transporting rice.

“If looting is the only way to survive, I will do it,” said 40-year-old Yusuf, waiting with five friends to loot any trucks on the outskirts of Bandung, east of Jakarta.

Desperate Indonesians have broken into rice fields and harvested them, prompting some owners to hire security. In Banyumas and Kebumen regencies, the rice centres of Central Java, farmers harvest paddy fields at night to avoid looting.

“If we harvest by day, our paddy would have been looted the night before,” said Daldiri, a rice farmer in Ayah subdistrict of Kebumen, Central Java.

“For Indonesians, rice is a matter of life or death. They will do anything to survive, even if they have to plunder their better- off countrymen,” said Zarkasih Nur, chairman of the Muslim- oriented United Development House faction.

Added Budi Hardjono of the Indonesian Democracy Party: “It (rice) is this very issue that will determine whether he (President Bacharuddin Habibie) can proceed or fall.”

The Suharto government had supported the rice sector with subsidies, extended also to items like fuel and flour. Imported fertiliser was one of the most heavily subsidised inputs.

Annual economic growth of 7 percent in past decades did much for agriculture, and government spent heavily for crop intensification, farmer training and cheap credit. Rice prices were kept low through the National Logistics Agency or Bulog, which unloaded supply when needed to stabilise prices.

Within the decade 1974 to 1984, Indonesia from went being the world’s largest rice importer to self-sufficiency.

But over the years, low selling prices for rice discouraged farmers from staying in agriculture and many moved to the cities. A national census showed that from 1990 to 1996, the number of agricultural workers dropped from more than half to 45.3 percent.

By 1997, 40 percent of rice fields mostly on Java island had been converted to non-agricultural uses. Yet as areas planted to rice shrank, more farmer families became landless.

The economic crisis — its effects and some of its cures — altered the picture completely.

When the rupiah collapsed, prices of imported fertiliser became impossible for rice farmers to afford. Farmers in Indramayu, West Java’s largest paddy centre, and Karawang, who went ahead without fertiliser, had crop failures last month.

A prolonged drought and projected declines in agricultural production have not helped, forcing the government to import rice.

“Indonesian demand for imported rice will rise to 4.5 million tonnes this year, an increase by 1.5 million tonnes from last year’s rice imports,” said Philip Clarke, Jakarta representative of the United Nations World Food Programme.

Rice prices recently rose to 4,000 rupiah (36 U.S. cents) a kg, well above the government’s target for low-quality rice of up to 2,000 rupiah (18 cents) per kg. High-quality rice goes for 5,000 rupiah (45 cents) per kg, an increase from 1,800 rupiah (16 cents) last year.

Disruptions in the rice distribution network, traditionally handled by Chinese Indonesian traders, and policies of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) that frown on subsidies, have complicated the rice problem as well.

Even government officials say Jakarta has proved incapable of repairing the distribution network hurt by the departure of ethnic Chinese, who had been the victims of mob riots.

The Habibie government wanted to have cooperatives run rice distribution, but this has flopped due to corruption. Officials have been questioned on suspicion of re-exporting rice for profit, and reports say there is hoarding and smuggling as well.

Often lacking funds to buy rice at Bulog’s subsidised prices, cooperatives borrow cash from business and so have to further push up selling prices.

The IMF and the government are trying drastic steps to bring down prices, by releasing cheap rice and letting private entities do rice importation as well. Jakarta has been under pressure from the IMF to cut subsidies for basic items and dismantle Suharto-era monopolies on food distribution.

Meantime, Indonesian patience is running thin. Some 1,000 students gathered at the National Monument last week to demand lower prices — and Habibie’s resignation. “Hungry! hungry! hungry!” they shouted.

Read one protest banner: “People don’t need political parties, people need food.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags