Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

DEVELOPMENT BULLETIN-BRAZIL: Fiscal Adjustments Wipe Out Micro- Entrprises

Mario Osava

RIO DE JANEIRO, Aug 22 1998 (IPS) - Some 3.9 million of the five million small and micro-enterprises created in Brazil since 1988 have folded up, many of them victims of monetary and fiscal adjustments like those adopted in the wake of the Asian crisis.

But although 78 percent of small and micro-enterprises have gone bankrupt – generally in their first year of existence – the number of such businesses has increased from 1.3 million in 1988 to 2.6 million today, according to experts.

The sector is one of the few that have been providing more jobs, whereas the overall unemployment rate, according to official statistics, has doubled in the past 10 years and now stands at 7.9 percent.

Brazil’s high interest rates, and the scarcity of credit for micro-enterprises are the biggest obstacles to such businesses consolidating themselves, according to small entrepreneurs interviewed in surveys done by organizations linked to the micro- enterprise sector.

Things took a turn for the worse last October, when the government increased interest rates and several taxes to deal with the international financial upheavals unleashed by the collapse of the Hong Kong stock market.

The subsequent economic stagnation has affected nearly all sectors since early this year, but it has hit small businesses in non-essential areas, such as tourism, particularly hard.

“Never in the 12 years since I have been here has there been a period with so few guests,” said Jose Luis Souza Dantas, owner of the Carapeba Hotel, located on the Sao Pedro da Aldeia beach, 135 kilometers from Rio de Janeiro.

In July, a month of high tourist flows due to school vacations, the majority of the small hotel’s rooms were vacant. Its convention room, normally in use all the time, only attracted one group in the last week of the month.

A survey by the National Confederation of Industry showed that production declined in 45.5 percent of micro-industries in January- March of 1998 and in 34.2 percent in April-June. Unused capacity in this sector amounted to 30percent, since most businesses have seen their sales drop.

Small industrialists’ biggest complaint is Brazil’s interest rate, cosidered the highest in the four-country Southern Common Market (Mercosur) and one of the highest in Latin America.

In addition to the monthly wages workers receive, Brazilian employers have to fork out the equivalent of 102 percent of their employees’ salaries for various contributions including social benefits, a vacation allowance and a thirteenth-month paycheck.

However, a systm to simplify and reduce contributions was put in place two years ago to improve micro-enterprises’ fiscal and administrative situation and to encourage the informal businesses that have mushroomed throughout the country to become legal.

Small businesses employing up to 10 workers account for 56 percent of the people in formal employment in Brazil. This job- creation capacity has made the sector a priority for the main candidates in the country’s Oct. 4 presidential polls.

But without cheap credit, it will be difficult to quicken the expansion of these businesses. Interest rates in Brazil’s commercial banks remain ten times higher than those of industrialized countries, at 70 to 80 percent annually.

Brazilian banks are “a big system for capturing resources to finance a single client, the State,” says Jes Domingues Alonso, who heads MicroBank, an institution which seeks to implement the successful microcredit model developed by the Grameen Bank in Banglaesh.

In order to refinance the high public debt of nearly 200 billion dollars, the government has retained its stranglehold over the country’s savings, thus limiting the credit available to other borrowers and causing interest rates to remain high.

In Brazil, financing comes up to only one-third of the country’s annual gross domestic product, compared to 100 percent or more in developed countries.

The expansion of foreign banks in developing countries has improved the administration of their financial systems, but this may also make credit less accessible for micro-enterprises which lack collateral, according to Chahid Javek Burki, vice-president of the World Bank for Latin America.

For this reason, in addition to institutional reforms, these countries should create organisations like the Grameen Bank, in which the community ensures payment of loans made to individuals as well as micro-enterprises, said Burki.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags