Economy & Trade, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

FINANCE-BRAZIL: Auction Outcome Shows Telebras Badly Valued

Mario Osava

RIO DE JANEIRO, Jul 30 1998 (IPS) - Telecommunications in Brazil joined the world game of the big international groups Wednesday, in an auction marked by mistakes and ignorance of this market from the experts.

The total overpricing of 63.74 percent took everyone by surprise, and this figure would have been 98 percent if the Brazilian government had accepted the evaluation of consultancies it had contracted.

In the event, the government had decided to tack an extra 20 percent onto the proposed minimum price.

Judging by the sum obtained, 18.93 billion dollars, the Brazilian telephone system is worth the 100 billion initially estimated, including the monopoly price.

For, what was privatised Wednesday was barely 19.26 percent of Telebras shares. Telebras is the conglomerate which controlled the system.

Private evaluators had estimated the total value of Telebras at between 50 and 65 billion dollars, following its division into 12 companies for privatisation.

But the underestimation was even more serious in the mobile cellphone sector, where the eight companies were sold at 8.120 billion dollars, nearly three times the minimum price of 2.8 billion.

Tele Leste Celular, which covers the states of Bahia and Sergipe, in northeastern Brazil saw unprecedented overpricing of 242.4 percent, prompted by the enthusiasm of the Spanish bidders for four of the 12 companies up for auction.

Their voracity surprised the market and competitors, and was one of the most influential factors generally elevating offers. Telefonica de Espana and Portugal Telecom, who are allies, head consortia responsible for 50.6 percent of the total 18.93 billion dollars raised by the auction.

With the adquisition of the Sao Paulo telephone market (Telesp), Spain’s Telefonica consolidated its leadership in South America where it already owns large shares of the market in Chile, Argentina, Peru and Venezuela.

This was the objective of the agressive Telesp proposal of 4.95 billion dollars, 64.28 percent above the minimum price, admitted president of Telefonica, Juan Villalonga.

Thus the number of fixed phones operated by the company in Latin America will be lifted to some 18 million with the possibility of adding a further eight million in a few years – the current figure of the unsatisfied demand for the 34 million inhabitants of Sao Paulo state, equal to the whole of Argentina.

Its biggest rival in the regional market, Telecom Italia – present in Argentina, Chile and Bolivia, as well as Cuba – made the most of the Brazilian opening to take one fixed telephone company and two cellphone concerns.

And while it is a minority shareholder in these companies, compared with the pension funds and other Brazilian partners (like Globopar, linked to the media empire including the O Globo television channel), it will take a leading role as it is the operator with most international experience.

The Italians did not expect “such aggression” from the Spanish, said Aldo di Sanzio, director general of Italia Telecom International, the company ranking eighth in the world on income, at more than 25 billion dollars in 1995 according to US magazine ‘Fortune.’

By luck rather than judgement, Telecom won the bidding for Tele Centro Sur, a fixed telephone service covering eight states in the south and west of Brazil. Its main interest had been in Tele Norte Leste, which covers double the number of states, people and installed telephones.

But as it had already won the former, auctioned earlier, the rules of bidding prevented it from taking its preferred target, as there is a ban on any one company taking two areas of fixed or cellphone services.

In any case, the Europeans far outdid their US colleagues – the other lead players of the world telecoms market – here in Brazil.

But MCI took over Embratel, dealing with long distance communication, in an intense struggle with its compatriot Sprint. As a result of their competing, the overpricing in this case reached 47.22 percent, against expectations of it being bought for the minimum price of 1.54 billion dollars.

BellSouth, another strong US player on the Latin American pitch, was surprisingly absent. This was believed to be due to the swollen prices, but the company is expected to bid for one of the “mirror companies,” predicted communications minister, Luiz Carlos Mendonza de Barros.

Toward the end of the year, the Brazilian government is planning to open bidding for concessions on four companies, known as “mirrors” as they will compete with the three fixed telephone companies auctioned off and Embratel. The aim is to avoid monopolies in any area of the country, taking heed of the the errors made in the Argentine privatisation process.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags