Africa, Headlines, North America

RIGHTS-AFRICA: Concern Over U.S. Policy in Nigeria, Congo

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Apr 9 1998 (IPS) - Human rights activists in the United States, increasingly concerned about developments in the Congo and Nigeria, are frustrated by mixed signals on both countries emanating from the administration of President Bill Clinton.

Clinton, who spoke out strongly for democratisation and human rights during his unprecedented trip to Africa earlier this month, so far has failed to clarify confusing remarks he made about Nigeria in Cape Town, South Africa. Neither has he condemned the crackdown against human rights groups in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, just two weeks after he met its president, Laurent Kabila, in Uganda.

“If you can’t get it right in Nigeria and the Congo, then there’s nothing we can do about a ‘new African renaissance,”‘ said Salih Booker, director of Africa studies at the Council on Foreign Relations here. Clinton referred frequently to “a new African renaissance” during his 12-day trip to the continent.

“When it comes to U.S. credibility vis-a-vis democracy in Africa, the two major cases are Nigeria and Congo,” according to Leonard Dees, who heads African programmes at the government- funded National Endowment for Democracy (NED).

Since Clinton met Kabila during a conference of regional leaders in Entebbe, the Congolese leader, who ousted long-time Zairean dictator Mobutu Sese Seko last May, appears to have launched a crackdown against human rights groups in Kinshasa.

Late last month, soldiers reportedly forced their way into the home of Floribert Chebeya, president of the Voice of the Voiceless, one of the country’s leading human rights monitoring groups, took him at gunpoint, and beat him severely in nearby vacant lot.

While some reports have suggested the attack may have linked to a long-standing property dispute, New York-based Human Rights Watch (HRW) charged that it was “indicative of increasing government attempts to stifle independent voices.”

Then, last Friday, Kabila’s Justice Minister, Mwenze Kongolo, appeared on national television and declared that the Association for the Defence of Human Rights (AZADHO), Congo’s main human rights group, had been outlawed and ordered the police to immediately close their offices throughout the country. He charged that AZADHO had violated the law by receiving foreign funding, failing to register with the government, leading political activities, and keeping the letter “Z” in its acronym, a reference to the former Zaire.

HRW declared the decree was the latest in a series of attacks on human rights groups, especially in the eastern part of the country, where Kabila’s insurgency began, and more recently in the capital.

The State Department Tuesday “deplored” the banning of AZADHO, saying it sent “exactly the wrong message when the United States government and other donor governments are looking for ways and means to assist the (Congo) in its search for democracy, stability and the rule of law.”

In a somewhat more ambiguous statement, it noted that “while we do not endorse all of AZADHO’s reports and activities, we believe it serves an important role in the Congo’s political development.”

“It’s astounding that the State Department felt it needed to distance itself from the content of a group’s work to affirm its right of association,” complained Adotei Akwesi, Africa specialist at Amnesty International USA.

He added that Washington’s reaction was consistent with a worrisome pattern of criticising recent independent human rights reports about the governments of Congo, Rwanda, and Ethiopia, including those of a U.N. mission charged with investigating alleged massacres committed by Kabila’s own forces during last year’s insurrection.

If US remarks on the situation in the Congo have disappointed activists here, Clinton’s and other officials’ handling of Nigeria policy during and after the trip has infuriated them.

These same forces were greatly encouraged by the new Assistant Secretary of State for Africa, Susan Rice, who, just before the trip, warned that Nigeria could not expect improved relations with the United States if Head of State Sani Abacha, who took power in a military coup d’etat in 1993, won the presidency in what are seen here as rigged elections scheduled for later this year.

“Electoral victory by any military candidate in the forthcoming presidential election in Nigeria would be unacceptable,” she said. “Nigerians need and deserve a real transition to democracy and civilian rule, not another military regime dressed up in civilian clothes.”

But during a news conference with South African President Nelson Mandela in Cape Town, Clinton surprised his own entourage by saying, “If (Abacha) stands for election, we will hope he will stand as a civilian. There are many military leaders who have taken over chatoic situations in African countries but have moved toward democracy, and this can happen in Nigeria.”

Aides quickly tried to undo the damage, but only contributed more to the confusion over U.S. policy, which officially has been under review since Nov. 1995. The State Department insisted that Rice’s remarks stood, while others on the trip claimed, somewhat feebly, that the two statements were consistent. Meanwhile, exultant Abacha officials depicted Clinton’s words as a repudiation of Rice’s tougher line.

Last weekend, the Rev. Jesse Jackson, Clinton’s special envoy for democracy and human rights in Africa further added to the perception that Washington was moving in Abacha’s direction when he warned that a confrontation with Abacha could have “awesome” ramifications for Nigeria and its neighbours.” He suggested further that Washington use the same kind of “aggressive, assertive engagement” in Nigeria that it uses in China.

“That’s essentially the same line that’s used by Nigeria’s paid lobbyists here,” said Dees, who adds that the different policies clearly reflect the existence of two camps within the administration.

“It’s just outrageous,” agreed Booker, who favours toughening existing sanctions against the regime while engaging it in a more intense dialogue and providing support for pro-democracy groups in Nigeria – the kind of policy Washington pursued towards apartheid South Africa.

“It’s going to take a very clear statement by Clinton himself that the transition process in Nigeria is a joke to repair the damage,” said Akwesi.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags