Thursday, November 19, 2026
Raul Ronzoni
- A young woman who shot and killed her husband after two years of constant abuse was absolved in a landmark legal ruling in Uruguay.
Prosecutor Cristina Gonzalez asked for a 10-year sentence on charges of “especially aggravated homicide.” But Judge Luis Charles absolved the defendant, who committed the murder just hours after being subjected to a brutal beating.
The verdict, to which IPS had access, was not appealed by the prosecutor. It was based on the “state of need” provided for by article 27 of this South American country’s penal code, which addresses cases in which a person inflicts harm equal to that which he or she is in risk of receiving.
According to Charles, it was clearly demonstrated that Gonzalez had been brutally beaten the day before the homicide.
Five hours after the last instance of abuse, the 20-year-old woman took a revolver, wrapped it in clothing, and shot her husband while he lay in bed. The dead man’s body showed five bullet wounds.
The judge described the dead man as an habitual drug user who did not work and kept his wife from doing so.
The defendant, “a very young woman, with two small children, was under a real, imminent threat, unavoidable by any other means, and bearing a distressing situation,” the ruling stated.
The woman had been “physically and psychologically attacked and degraded as a human being, and faced an imminent risk to her life.”
The judge wrote that the dead man “was even feared by his closest relatives,” and that the woman had “no other feasible or less serious means to prevent harm to herself.”
Charles underlined in his verdict that the dead man’s brother declared that “he had five girlfriends, who left him because he always hit them…Today, if they ask me if I am happy about what happened, I say yes.”
The judge also heard testimony by the dead man’s mother, who said “the girl put up with too much, her body is all black and blue.” She added that it looked as if her son was “a psycopath. I have no hard feelings against her, on the contrary, she was a really good mother with her two little daughters.”
The legal ruling added that the woman had no family or friends to whom to turn for help, and that when she resorted to the legal system last year, a judge dismissed the case.
Although arguable from a legal point of view, the sentence constitutes an unprecedented vindication for women suffering domestic abuse in Uruguay, who since 1995 have been protected by a law criminalising domestic violence.
Since then, three-quarters of the cases on domestic violence against women heard by the courts have involved the partners of the defendants. The rest were former partners, boyfriends or relatives, according to data from the Technical Forensic Institute (ITF).
In all cases in which women attacked men, the aggression came in response to previous abuse.
Despite the slow progress in changing the habits of citizens, police and the courts, analysts say the 1995 law has provided a key tool for women in situations of domestic violence.
However, some experts see it as counterproductive for the law to provide for intervention by the state in cases in which the victim has not filed charges.
Beatriz Scapusio, a law professor at the public University of the Republic, told IPS that in such cases, intervention by the penal system “resolves nothing.” On the contrary, it can even “aggravate the situation,” she maintained.
The legal system intervenes, it is proven that domestic violence has taken place, the individual is tried as a first-time offender and not sentenced to prison, and then “returns home even more aggressive than before,” said Scapusio.