Thursday, November 19, 2026
Humberto Marquez
- Oil prices as the key variable in determining policies of investment, technological development and environmental conservation dominated the Fourth World Conference on Energy despite having been expressly excluded from the agenda.
The informal conference between oil producing and consuming countries, which ended in Venezuela on Wednesday, brought together ministers and authorities from 45 countries to examine three points: the “Global Outlook of Petroleum and Gas”, “Environment and Technology” and “Investment Requirements and the Reintegration of Industry”.
The issue of prices played a leading role in the three-day conference which was designed to provide the context for informal talks, rather than collective recommendations.
The issues of price and volume were put forth openly and with urgency by some producers, or as part of proposals regarding the environment and investment by large consumers.
Meanwhile, short-term prices were analysed in dozens of bilateral and group meetings held parallel to the conference, which in spite of being designed as “an informal, face-to-face dialogue” was heavy on protocol.
Ministers from members of the Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) used the conference to urge the need for higher prices. Some of them even insinuated that such informal conferences should evolve into an official forum designed to reach agreements on fuel prices in the near future.
On the other hand, Jack Carter, adviser to the Department of Energy of the United States – the world’s biggest oil consumer – was much more cautious, because due to legal and strategic reasons, Washington remains far removed from any type of agreement on or “cartelisation” of prices and supply.
But from the developing South, Iran’s Oil Minister, Gholamreza Aghazadeh, called for an official forum to continue the informal conferences that first began to be held in France in 1991.
Aghazadeh argued that “dialogue will not be efficacious if it fails to tackle the issues of prices and production in a realistic manner.
“The first step is for all players (producers and consumers) to coordinate their efforts to keep prices stable and achieve sustainable development and environmental conservation.”
Egyptian Oil Minister Hamdi El Banbi mentioned as an example the need to develop the natural gas industry, predicting that demand could reach 2.8 billion tonnes by the year 2020, compared to 1.7 billion in 1990.
El Banbi said up to one trillion dollars may be needed to develop all necessary gas projects, which in order to be competitive in the case of Europe, for example, would need oil to be worth 25 to 35 dollars a barrel.
“But how can such projects be carried out if prices of crude oil remain significantly below 20 dollars?” asked the minister from Egypt, a non-OPEC producer.
OPEC secretary-general Rilwanu Lukman warned that “the investment needed to be able to guarantee long-term supply depends on a strengthening of prices, which must be sufficiently attractive to capture the interest of investors.”
OPEC and non-OPEC producers will be able to guarantee a stable supply “if investments to increase production capacity are made,” while the resources implied “depend on the strengthening of prices.”
According to Lukman, furthermore, the emphasis industrialised consumers put on environmental standards and the use of clean technologies that favour energy-saving is “only one side of the coin, theirs.”
Paul Toungui, Oil Minister of Gabon – another OPEC member – argued that “the issue of investment is inseparable from prices,” meaning that “in the medium-range these forums should lead to a consensus on prices.”
Meanwhile, from the North, Jens Stoltenberg, Minister of Industry and Energy of Norway, an industrialised non-OPEC oil exporter, stressed that “Green taxes” are increasingly weighing down costs.
In 1980, a barrel of oil cost 35 dollars plus six dollars of taxes in industrialised countries, while in 1994 it cost 15 dollars plus 20 dollars in taxes, including the “Green taxes” that stimulate the market for less polluting fuels, the minister pointed out.
That tax burden “reduces incentives for investing in exploration and production,” which increases risks and makes investors demand greater rates of return, and which in turn will limit the viability of petroleum, Stoltenberg charged.
Such a situation contrasts with the projections of the future growth of demand – which should rise from today’s 69 million barrels a day to 78 to 80 million barrels a day by 2005, according to Luis Giusti, the president of Venezuela’s state-run oil company.
Thus, Stoltenberg is in favour of adequate rates of return with reasonably high and stable prices.
The need to reach an understanding on prices was also insinuated by French Minister of Industry Yves Galland, who called for “a climate of cooperation and energy security.”
According to Galland, what is needed is to learn from “our lack of foresight, which contributed to the difficulties of developing and industrialised countries in the 1970s and 80s.”
The oil crises “of 1973 and 1986 have played a disturbing rather than beneficial role for the global economy, and we have all paid that price.”
Spain’s Minister of Industry and Energy, Juan Eguiagaray, said the demand for cleaner fuels in Europe entails a higher price due to higher costs, “and the consumer is willing to pay for that.”
Finally, the eight OPEC ministers who participated in the conference in this Caribbean resort town examined the issue of prices in informal meetings.
Such talks took the pulse previous to the November OPEC conference, when the organisation’s 12 member countries are to decide whether or not to hold their total production limit down to 24.5 million barrels a day.
The debate on investment in the oil industry also focused on the fact that “more than half of the world’s population lives without access to commercial energy,” according to Giusti, the president of Venezuela’s state-run oil company, the world’s fourth largest.
The segment that lives in the worst conditions “are the more than one billion people who get by on a dollar a day, a standard that was overcome in Europe and the United States 150 years ago.”
Humanity “must decide on the road of development to overcome poverty, and we are optimistic that such a route will bring an increasing demand for energy.
“Regardless of the globalisation that is dominating the world, there are still places and regions with large isolated pockets, off the map when it comes to energy and the economy.”
Giusti advocates “a harmonious triangle” to confront demands for energy, made up of an adequate supply of energy, environmental conservation and financing.
Governments “must create appropriate conditions for investment, in such a way that private capital can be attracted,” the oil executive argued.
“Up to now, the performance of governments in the creation and promotion of effective competition, which translates into adequate prices and environmental protection, has left much to desire,” Giusti concluded.