Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Jim Lobe
- Two days after almost 100 million US citizens cast their ballots for a new president, it appears that the next occupant of the White House will ultimately be decided by the courts, and perhaps not for many days or even weeks.
The election’s extraordinary denouement is forcing many citizens to take a new and closer look at the way presidents are elected. Already, a chorus of voices is demanding that the electoral college system, adopted under the constitution more than 200 years ago, be radically revised or abolished.
While the particular focus of concern now is on the final vote count in the key state of Florida, larger questions are being asked about a system in which the candidate who received the most popular votes, in this case, Democratic Vice President Al Gore, may be defeated by Republican Texas Governor George W. Bush, who claims to have won a majority of the electoral vote.
The unprecedented indecision results from the extraordinarily close vote in Florida, where Democrats appear poised to demand that voters in one predominantly Democratic county, where almost 20,000 ballots were disqualified, be permitted to re-cast their votes.
In an initial count of the votes Tuesday night, Bush appeared to win the state and all of its crucial 25 electoral votes by an 1,800-vote margin out of six million votes cast. Winning Florida – no matter by how little – would give Bush the 271 electoral votes he needs to claim the presidency, under the US’ unique electoral system.
Bush’s margin, however, had fallen to just 350 votes about 90 percent of the way through an official re-count, which is required in very close elections under Florida law. But even if Bush, as expected, is confirmed as the winner of the re-count, several thousand votes from Floridians overseas remain to be counted over the next several days.
And even if both candidates agree with the official totals at that point, the question of almost 20,000 spoiled ballots is still likely to be referred to the courts.
There is no question that the next presidency is at stake. With 260 electoral votes firmly in his column, 25 more from Florida would send Gore over the threshold and into the White House.
If the United States were a direct democracy, in which each vote cast was counted equally and the candidate with the most votes would gain the presidency, the election would already have been decided in favour of Gore, who officially won by about 200,000 votes nationwide.
But contrary to its international image, the United States is a republic in which votes for the presidency are cast indirectly, through a state-based electoral college where more rural or sparsely- populated states wield proportionately greater influence than more densely populated states – a system originally designed to appease concerns by southern, slave-holding states that they would be consistently outvoted if the United States were a true democracy.
Under this system, each state is allotted electoral votes equal to the combined total of senators and representatives it has in the Congress.
Altogether, there are 538 “electors” in the electoral college, equal to the 100 senate seats, 435 House seats, plus three more for the District of Colombia which has no senators and only a non-voting representative in Congress, another relic of the slave-holding era.
While the 435 seats in the House are allocated according to population, each state – no matter how large or small – has two senators under the constitution. Thus, Wyoming, with a population of less than 500,000, has the same number of senators as California, with a population of some 32 million people.
Thus, each Wyoming senator represents 250,000 people; while California senators each represent 16 million.
In the electoral college, California gets 54 votes, or one for every 610,000 people; Wyoming gets only three votes, but that translates into one for every 150,000 people – a huge disparity.
That disparity in recent years has given a special advantage to Republicans whose base is precisely among more rural and more sparsely populated states of the deep South, the Midwest, and the Rocky Mountain region, where white voters remain predominant.
Bush took every state in these three regions, except those states with large minority populations – New Mexico, Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Illinois.
While it is in both the immediate and longer-term interests of the Democrats that the electoral system be changed in favour of a more democratic system, the Gore campaign has said it considers itself bound by the existing constitutional system.
But the fact that Gore won the popular vote appears to be making the Democrats more willing to fight over the results. Normally, according to legal experts, courts are extremely reluctant to order new votes and have done so only in the cases where fraud appears to have taken place.
But the Democrats now appear to be preparing a case to submit to the courts. Their focus is Palm Beach County, home to a large number of Jewish-Americans, who normally vote overwhelmingly Democratic.
Election authorities in that county printed a ballot which, according to the Democrats, made it very easy for voters to punch one hole believing they had voted for Gore, when, upon closer examination, they had actually voted for Reform Party candidate Pat Buchanan.
As a result, Buchanan received more than 3,000 votes in that county – more than three times what he got in a much more populous neighbouring county.
“My guess is, I probably got some votes down there that really did not belong to me and I do not feel well about that,” Buchanan said Thursday.
Moreover, many of the 19,000 ballots thrown out by the Palm Beach electoral authorities were “double-punched” – strong evidence that voters wishing to vote for Gore had initially punched Buchanan’s hole, realised their mistake, and then punched Gore’s, the next one down.
Many voters reportedly complained about the problem after they had deposited their ballots, and some have already filed suit in local courts to seek redress.
“We’ve come to believe that there are serious and substantial irregularities resulting from the ballot used only in one county,” said former Secretary of State Warren Christopher, who was dispatched by the Gore campaign as the leader of a group of more than 60 party lawyers.
For its part, the Bush campaign pointed out that the controversial ballot had been approved in advance by a Democratic election commissioner and had been displayed publicly for weeks before the election without anyone objecting to its design.
It also noted that the margins of Gore’s victory in several states was less than 10,000 votes, and that recounts there could also uncover some discrepancies, as they had in Florida.