Thursday, November 19, 2026
Danielle Knight
- When Louis “Buzzy” Agard fished in the remote Northwestern Hawaiian islands in the 1940s and 1950s he thought he had found the “nirvana” of the Pacific Ocean since the waters seemed to have a never-ending supply of fish.
He was wrong. “What I didn’t know was how fragile the area was,” says Agard, a native Hawaiian. “I caught the stock and the species didn’t come back for years.”
Since then Agard has been very careful to fish only small quantities, but he and other small-scale fishermen are reporting that the size and number of marine species has dwindled in recent decades as a result of commercial fishing vessels.
“If commercial fishing is allowed, these populations will be wiped out and will never return,”he told reporters here this week.
Agard is part of a group of native Hawaiian fishermen and environmentalists that are frustrated with the state’s efforts to protect the remote and fragile Northwest Islands. They are urging US President Bill Clinton to designate the islands a national monument, which would put them off-limits to most commercial fishing.
Stretching for 1,900 kilometres north of the main island Kauai, the Northwest Hawaiian Islands of the Pacific are home to coral reefs, endangered monk seals, sea turtles and hundreds of species of nesting birds. Scientists say the islands provide critical habitat for the monk seals, green sea turtles and other species that populate the main Hawaiian islands.
But the Northwest archipelago is threatened by commercial lobster fishing, according to Agard and other native fishermen and environmentalists.
Half a dozen large commercial lobster vessels are overfishing the lobsters, an important source of food for the endangered monk seal, according to Cha Smith, co-ordinator of Kahea, an environmental group based in Honolulu, Hawaii’s capital. Marine biologists have found Hawaiian monk seals starving in the area.
According to Kahea, the lobster catch last year was 10 percent of the 1983 take.
“In the past five years, it was over-fished by 1 million lobsters,” says Isaac Harp, a Maui fisherman who initiated public involvement in protecting the area.
The lobster traps weighted down with lead also drag along the bottom, destroying the reefs, he says.
Small scale-fishermen like Harp say the commercial fishermen have more of a financial incentive to haul in lots of lobsters since the islands are so remote and fuel expenses are high. Large amount of by-catch, or marine life not intended for capture, has also been reported by the fishing industry. Octopus, one of the staples of the endangered monk diet, has been high on the by-catch list.
The archipelago is considered fragile because of lack of rainfall. There is little vegetation along the sandy beach islands and little nutrients in its clear aqua waters, compared to other areas.
Agard and Smith say the current fishery management practices are inadequate. Members of the Western Pacific Fisheries Management Council, the body in
charge of regulating fishing, have been accused of conflict of interest since many have financial ties to the fishing industry.
“Continuing current management practices would be disastrous,” says Harp. Opponents of the plan to name the area a national monument, including Governor Ben Cayetano, argue that the area is already being managed.
Kitty Simonds, director of the fishery management council, was quoted in the Hawaiian press as saying the quick establishment of a national monument would violate the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), which requires public participation.
“This thing by-passes the public process and all the congressional acts,” says Simonds.
Jack Sobel, director of ecosystem protection for the Center for Marine Conservation, a national advocacy group based here, disagrees. He says that the creation of the national monument requires compliance with NEPA.
“The creation of a national monument does not by-pass NEPA,” he says.
Simonds also argues that storms cause as much damage to the reefs as fishing. But scientist Sobel says the added pressure from over-harvesting fish and lobster, as well as destruction to the reefs makes the ecosystem much more vulnerable to storms.
“Over-fishing undermines the ability of nature to restore itself,” he says.
Earlier this year, President Clinton ordered several federal agencies to work with the state to come up with a plan to protect the Northwestern Hawaiian Island coral reefs, which comprise about three-fourths of all coral reefs in the United States.
While a series of public meetings about conservation of the islands were held in August, Agard, who served from 1976 to 1985 on the fishery management council, says the government agencies are not doing enough and a national monument is needed.
The establishment of a national monument would ban most commercial fishing and the gathering of corals throughout the stretch of islands.
Under the US Antiquities Act of 1906, national monuments can be established by the president without the approval of Congress. Since his taking office nearly eight years ago, Clinton has created more monuments than most other presidents.
From giant sequoia trees in California to archaeological sites in Colorado and ancient ironwood trees in Arizona, President Clinton has created or expanded more than 10 national monuments, covering about 1.5 million hectares in western states.