Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

POLITICS/EU: Diplomatic Sanctions Against Austria To Be Lifted

Brian Kenety

BRUSSELS, Sep 12 2000 (IPS) - Diplomatic sanctions against Austria by the 14 other European Union (EU) member states, imposed in February after Austri a’s far-right Freedom Party (FOP) was invited to form a coalition government, could be lifted at any moment.

A report released at the weekend by three independent European adviser s known as the “three wise men”, concluded that Austria respects the rights of minorities, refugees and immigrants at least as well as did other EU stat es.

The sanctions, the first of their kind in EU history, were imposed ove r concerns that the Freedom Party members and then-party leader, Joerg Haid er, had fomented a hatred of immigrants. In giving Austria, as a whole, a cle an bill of health, the report noted that violence against asylum seekers and other foreigners “had been less frequent than in Austria than in many oth er countries of the EU”.

But the authors noted that certain FOP representatives had repeatedly used ambiguous language that was often “xenophobic or even racist” and ha d “exploited and enforced” these elements in its political campaign.

In June the EU asked the European Court of Human Rights to appoint a three-member panel to assess the situation in Austria. Martti Ahtisaari, a former President of Finland, Marcelino Oreja, a former Spanish foreign minister and EU Commissioner, and German legal expert Jurgen Frowein, wer e selected for the task.

Their report said that while the FOP was a “right-wing populist party with radical elements” to continue with diplomatic sanctions would be counter-productive, as they had “already generated nationalist sentiments in Austria… because they have sometimes been wrongly interpreted as sancti ons against the Austrian people.”

Whether in Austria, or anywhere else, the distinction between bilatera l measures, as opposed to action, taken by the EU was not widely understood. Polls showed that the general effect of the sanctions was to turn opinion against European integration.

The report recommends that the EU revise its Treaty so as to formalise a mechanism that would allow similar situations to be addressed, the development of institutional monitoring systems to evaluate the commitmen t of member states with respect to “common European values”.

The authors also propose the creation of a Human Rights Office within the EU Council of Ministers, the appointment of an EU Commissioner for Human Rights and the establishment of a full agency in the same regard. French European Affairs Minister, Pierre Moscovici, whose country now holds the rotating EU Presidency and is therefore taking the lead on what the EU executive Commission has been at pains to describe as a bilateral move by the 14 member states, told reporters in Paris on Monday that the diplomat ic sanctions could be lifted within “a question of hours or days”.

However, he stressed that concerns remained about the presence of the far-right in the coalition government and said measures would be consider ed to monitor the human rights situation in Austria.

European People’s Party (EPP) President, Wilifred Martens, endorsed ca lls for the measures to be lifted “as soon as possible” arguing that “If anyo ne has been helped by this whole unfortunate debacle, it is nationalist demagogues.”

The EPP had commissioned its own report on the Austrian human rights situation after calls from three EPP parties to suspend the membership of the Austrian People’s Party for entering an alliance with the Freedom Par ty and gave the country a ‘bill of health’ .

Austrian, and other members of political parties holding seats in the European Parliament, had argued that the actions of the 14 member states were without any legal base in EU legislation.

“This not only contradicts the spirit of partnership between fellow EU members but also damage(s) confidence in the (Union) based on law applica ble in all member states … It also had a damaging effect in countries that have applied for (EU) membership,” said Hans-Gert Poettering, the Chair o f the EPP-European Democrats Group in the European Parliament.

The Czech Republic, an aspiring EU member, had also imposed sanctions on Austria. Many politicians had argued that the measures were necessary to stem off the inclusion of far-right parties in the somewhat fragile democracies of eastern European governments and in current member states.

In March, United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Mary Robinson, declared her concern about the return to Europe of an extremist right-wing that feeds on nostalgia for the Nazi past and she condemned attacks against immigrant Moroccans in southern Spain.

Her statements, made in honour of International Day on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, specifically targeted electoral advances of the extreme right in Austria and Switzerland.

Although the Haider and other Freedom Party leaders have repeatedly stated that their concerns over immigration levels and did not stem from xenophobia, many politicians here remain extremely sceptical.

Enrique Baron Crespo, President of the Socialist group, said the repor t had “provided evidence of what we have been saying since the formation of this coalition government: the FPO (Freedom Party) is a party with objectives falling outside of the values of the EU. We must maintain our vigilance and ensure that this report does not mean that we turn a blind eye to inflammatory statements and actions by members of the FPÖ.”

However, he tacitly acknowledged that the manner in which the sanction s had been imposed had been ad hoc. “We believe that the action by the 14 h as prevented the normalisation of the extreme right in power,” said Baron Crespo. “Nevertheless, the experience of these sanctions has demonstrated the need for a clearer expression in (EU treaties) of both the nature of our common values and the action to be taken in cases of their violation”.

The report of the wise men concluded that the sanctions had been effective in intensifying Vienna’s efforts to uphold European values.

Against this background, leaders of the Green group in the European Parliament said that while the manner in which the diplomatic sanctions w ere

imposed should be examined, it was important that action had been taken, saying “we will never know how the policy of the Austrian government woul d have developed without pressure from the fourteen (member states)”.

EU Commission spokesperson, Jonathan Faull, told a regular briefing in Brussels on Tuesday that France had not contacted Commission President, Romano Pro di,

with regards to monitoring Austria.

“We await developments – no one has asked us to do anything yet,” he said, whilst reiterating Prodi’s belief that the report of the wise men “is a g ood report… and that the recommendations (therein) cannot be ignored,” he said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags