Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS-US: Death Penalty Opponents Rally Around Texas Inmate

Katherine Stapp

NEW YORK, Jun 20 2000 (IPS) - With just two days to go before his execution, supporters of Texas death row inmate Gary Graham and opponents of capital punishment held rallies in cities around the United States to plead for a last-minute stay from Texas governor and presumptive Republican candidate George W. Bush.

In New York, six protesters were arrested at the 10th floor offices of the Republican state headquarters, as a crowd of some 600 people marched through midtown Manhattan chanting and waving signs that read: “Don’t Let Bush Execute an Innocent Man.”

Rallies were also held in Washington, DC, Houston, San Francisco and Los Angeles.

Graham, also known as Shaka Sankofa, faces the death penalty for the 1981 murder of a man in a Houston parking lot when he was 17 years old. He has been sitting on death row for the last 20 years.

Graham’s lawyers say his trial was seriously flawed, noting that he was convicted on the testimony of a single eyewitness who saw him only fleetingly at a distance of some 40 feet. No forensic evidence (blood, fingerprints, hair or fibres) linked him to the crime, and his original lawyer, Ronald Mock, put up a minimal defence.

Mock called no witnesses during the penalty phase of the trial, and failed to interview others who said that Graham was not the shooter. Mock, who recently told the New York Times that he has more clients on death row than any other attorney in the United States, has been reprimanded and suspended by the Texas bar on numerous occasions.

Graham, an African-American, confessed to a string of violent robberies and assaults, but denies any involvement in the shooting death of the Houston victim, Bobby Lambert.

Graham’s case has taken on new urgency in the wake of recent studies and news articles that show high rates of error in capital cases, as well as a pervasive bias against black and Latino defendants in many jurisdictions.

On Jun. 12, researchers at Columbia Law School in New York released a comprehensive analysis of all capital cases in the United States between 1973 and 1995, which found that they were “persistently and systematically fraught with error.”

According to the study, 68 percent of all cases in which the death penalty was imposed were overturned by higher courts due to “serious error” – primarily “egregiously incompetent” defence lawyers, suppression of exculpatory evidence by police and prosecutors, and faulty instructions to jurors.

On retrial – which often took many years of appeals – seven percent were found to be innocent, and 82 percent received sentences less than death.

Although the Colombia Law School study did not examine race as a factor in capital punishment, others have shown significant disparities in death penalty sentencing.

According to the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), 40 percent of those executed in the last three decades have been African- American, and of the 232 death sentences carried out since 1977, only one involved a white person convicted of killing a black person.

In January, the Republican governor of Illinois declared a moratorium on all executions in his state after 13 death row prisoners there were exonerated by new evidence, including DNA analysis.

A critical five-part investigative series by the Chicago Tribune newspaper over a month earlier found that “capital punishment in Illinois is a system so riddled with faulty evidence, unscrupulous trial tactics and legal incompetence that justice has been forsaken.”

At least 35 times, a black defendant was sentenced to die by an all-white jury, and at least 33 times, defendants who ended up on death row were represented by an attorney who was later disbarred or suspended.

Formerly a supporter of the ultimate penalty, Illinois Governor George Ryan has since said he doubts that anyone else will be put to death on his watch.

With the death penalty under intense media scrutiny, the Graham case has become emblematic of a capital system that often seems to grind inexorably ahead despite serious questions of innocence.

The ACLU noted in a Jun. 15 press release on Graham’s case that: “In the last 24 years, 85 innocent people have been released from death row, and 20 states have reversed at least one capital punishment decision since 1976. These facts beg the question – how many innocent people have been killed or are threatened with execution in this country?”

Amnesty International has also launched a campaign on Graham’s behalf. “Gary Graham’s execution looms at a time when the error- prone nature of death sentencing in the USA has become abundantly clear. His case is a textbook example of the fatal flaws that riddle the US capital justice system,” Amnesty said last week. The rights group also raised the issue of Graham’s status as a minor at the time of his conviction.

“The USA leads a handful of countries that still flout the international prohibition on the use of the death penalty against those convicted of crimes committed when they were under 18 years old,” Amnesty said, a practice which “flies in the face of standards of decency and justice.”

Having exhausted all state and federal appeals without success, Graham’s lawyers are now desperately seeking a stay from Governor Bush – who has presided over more than 130 executions since 1995.

Even assuming Bush is receptive, the Texas parole board could block a stay of execution because Graham already received one from a previous governor.

If his sentence is carried out on Thursday, Graham will be the 23rd prisoner executed by lethal injection in Texas and the 48th in the United States this year.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags