Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Industrial Pollution Up in Canada and United States

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, May 30 2000 (IPS) - Industrial pollution in North America rose slightly in 1997, reversing progress made in earlier years, according to a report released Tuesday by an inter-governmental environmental commission.

Using government data from Canada and the United States, the Commission for Environmental Co-operation (CEC) said pollution levels went up 1.2 percent overall in North America from 1995 and 1997.

This increase could pose significant health risks. According to the report, “Taking Stock 1997”, about 15 percent of the pollutants released directly into the air, land and water were carcinogens, such as lead.

“This is not the kind of trend we want to see,” said Janine Ferretti, executive director of the Montreal-based CEC, which was set up under the 1993 North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) at the request of environmental groups.

Since the CEC began producing these pollution reports four years ago, communities have used this information as a tool to monitor the impact of pollution on their environment.

A glaring omission in the report, however, is that “Taking Stock” does not include pollution information from Mexico since its government only just issued its first pollution report in 1999, covering the 1997 reporting year.

According to the 551-page report, while two-thirds of the pollutants were released directly from industrial sites into the air, land and water, the rest were transferred to other locations, including other North American countries.

On-site pollution releases in North America were down by nine percent overall in 1997, compared with 1995.

Canada had a larger reduction of 13 percent than the United States’ decrease of eight percent, said “Taking Stock,” which is based on government statistics that are comprised of toxic release inventories authored by the companies themselves.

Yet transfers of pollution sent to other locations for treatment or disposal increased dramatically since 1995. Canadian transports of pollution rose 31 percent from 1995 to 1997 and US transfers increased 27 percent during the same period.

When asked by reporters about the quality of facilities where waste is to be recycled or disposed of, Janine Ferretti, executive director of the CEC said that the report is only helpful in terms of what is going on where with regard to pollution output.

“It doesn’t adequately explain the ‘whys’,” she said.

According to “Taking Stock”, one of the main reasons for the increase in transfers of pollution is the rise in production in the metal industry.

Despite some pollution controls introduced into this industry, metal companies in both Canada and the United States reported increasing their pollution releases and transfers by more than 25 percent during the reporting period.

Steel mills accounted for the sectors’ largest releases and transfers, followed by aluminium, copper, zinc, nickel and lead refineries.

Pollution released by Canadian facilities were greater than equivalent US factories. Reported releases by Canadian industrial facilities were 1.3 times larger than the average for US facilities. And air emissions from Canadian factories were almost twice the average of equivalent US facilities.

Ferretti said she couldn’t explain what caused the difference. The US chemical industry reported the largest releases and transfers in 1997, followed by metals and paper products. Most of the pollution sent out of the United States went to Canada for treatment or disposal. While it sent 36 million kilograms of pollution to Canadian sites, US companies also sent 26 million kilograms to Mexican sites in 1997.

Almost half of the chemicals sent outside the United States went to Mexico – about 30 million kilograms. Most were chemicals sent to the city of Monterrey for recycling, according to the report.

Hazardous waste sent from US-owned Mexican maquiladoras to the United States is estimated at 9.24 million kilograms, half of which was toxic waste from the border town Tijuana, said “Taking Stock”.

Environmentalists suspected that if Mexican statistics were included in the CEC’s report, North America’s total environmental picture would be worse.

One of the environmental groups’ concerns over NAFTA was that the trade agreement would enable dirtier industries to relocate to Mexico to escape tougher enforcement of environmental laws in Canada and the United States.

“Without Mexican statistics it is hard to judge what is really happening,” said Stephen Porter, a senior attorney with the Center for International Environmental Law here in Washington.

Mark Vallianatos, an international policy analyst with Friends of the Earth here, said the CEC’s report proves that free trade needs equally binding environmental laws to ensure that increasing imports and exports do not lead to boosts in the production of pollution.

He said that the absence of Mexican statistics shows that US law should force companies operating in other countries to publicly report at least some minimal ‘right-to-know’ information – such as pollution releases, as is mandated in the United States.

“This way the public in other countries would know about what is happening in their communities and US citizens would know what their companies are doing abroad,” said Vallianatos.

The CEC’s report is “sadly consistent” with the pessimistic global environmental picture, added Porter.

“While we’ve made progress in some areas, I don’t think we’ve turned the corner yet,” said Porter.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags