Thursday, November 19, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- Nobody seems happy with Canada’s new endangered species bill – not politicians, not environmentalists and not businesses.
The Species at Risk Act threatens the property rights of loggers, miners and ranchers, says the neo-conservative government of the province of Alberta. It is so weak it will make no difference for plants and animals on the brink of extinction, say the conservationists.
Still, the bill, introduced into Canada’s House of Commons last week, is the first Canadian legislation to try to protect the country’s endangered species. An attempt by the government and most of Canada’s 10 provinces to reach an agreement on animal protection died in 1996 because the separatist government of Quebec refused to take part in negotiations.
Since then, Canada has been under pressure from the Clinton administration and US-based environmental groups to pass legislation with as much teeth as US environmental laws.
But with the opposition arrayed against it, even if it passes into law, the act may not survive long. The resource-dependent province of Alberta for instance, is threatening to take the government to court to have the bill declared unconstitutional. Land management is a provincial responsibility under Canada’s constitution.
And environmentalists are denouncing the bill as too toothless to protect animals and are demanding changes to it.
“This is a very weak bill. It will leave endangered species with no assurance of protection, and that is something that should be of great concern to Canadians who care about our wildlife heritage,” said Stewart Elgie, a lawyer with the Sierra Legal Defence Fund.
The new law will make it illegal to kill species Canada’s government deems worthy of legal protection, and envisages a co- operative regime with the provinces and land owners and users to design and implement species recovery plans. A scientific committee will decide which species are slipping away, but it will be up to the country’s cabinet to decide which ones deserve legal protection under the bill. The environmental groups want the cabinet to defer to scientists.
Corporations would be fined up to 1 million dollars and their officials could go to jail for five years for killing a member of an endangered species. Individuals could face fines of 250,000 dollars. The fines could be doubled for the second conviction
Kevin Scott, director of Canadian Programs for Defenders of Wildlife, called the bill “an environmental embarrassment on an international scale.” He said it gives Canadians the false sense of security that the country’s wildlife was being protected, when in fact nothing was being done to ensure that.
But Environment Minister David Anderson said he will not entertain any suggestion that there be major changes to the proposed legislation. The bill, he said, is a careful balancing act between the need to protect the country’s wildlife and the rights of landowners. It will offer limited compensation to property owners who lose income because they have protected species on their property.
But if someone is wilfully eliminating a species, Anderson said, “the bill has fines of over 1 million dollars, and for second offences 2 million dollars. They say this has no teeth? They must be joking.”
Environmentalists, however, say the fines will mean very little in the struggle to save endangered species. They want a law that protects habitat, and say the bill leaves that to the discretion of politicians rather than making it mandatory, because it is the cabinet and not scientists who will determine which of the species identified as endangered are worth saving.
Some endangered species, including the beluga whale and the whooping crane, are well known to Canadians and would be difficult to leave off the list. However, many fish, amphibians, reptiles and plants that scientists say are at risk of extinction are far more obscure and potentially easier to ignore, environmentalists say.
“Instead of ensuring protection, what we seem to be getting is a bill which will allow the government to step in only if it chooses to protect endangered wildlife,” World Wildlife Fund Canada president Monty Hummel said.
Anderson has been bracing himself for a major public-relations battle with environmental groups since December, when he unveiled his blueprint for the bill. He said it would be irresponsible to allow a non-elected group of scientists to make decisions that could have serious social and economic consequences.
Mark Bourrie
- Nobody seems happy with Canada’s new endangered species bill – not politicians, not environmentalists and not businesses.
(more…)