Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

MEXICO-US: New Approach Needed to Tackle Immigration Problem

Diego Cevallos

MEXICO, Mar 18 2000 (IPS) - If current levels of growth of the Mexican economy continue, the present average of 1,000 Mexicans who cross into the United States every day will also remain steady over the next 15 years, according to a report by a Mexican government agency.

A study by the governmental National Population Council (CONAPO) points out that the phenomenon has defied the recent stiffening of US laws and controls, and argues that without a change in policy, nothing will change.

Not even the recent rallying of the Mexican economy stemmed the legal and illegal flow of emigrants to the United States, because the phenomenon is fueled by extensive family and community networks of Mexicans in the United States, says the report that was released last week.

CONAPO director Rodolfo Tuirán maintains that Mexico and the United States should establish immigration mechanisms that “cut the social and economic costs of the phenomenon, which is very unlikely to be eradicated in the next three decades.”

Despite the stiffening of US laws and immigration controls, including an expansion in the number of agents and patrols and the use of state-of-the-art technology, 364,000 Mexican emigrants crossed the border in 1999. Of that total, 96 percent found jobs, says the study.

Of the 7.5 million people born in Mexico who live in the United States, 2.3 million are undocumented. The average age of Mexican immigrants is 30, 40 percent have gone to school for less than five years, and 6.8 percent are illiterate.

“It is not hard to get in. I did it without much trouble, and quickly found work as a carpenter’s assistant near Los Angeles for more than 800 dollars a month, but working like a dog,” Fausto Cantor, who went to the United States in 1998, told IPS.

Cantor was working as doorman in a building in an upscale part of Mexico City and earning less than 200 dollars a month. After he went to the United States, he returned twice to visit his family, and later made it back across the border illegally.

The flow of Mexican emigration to the United States cannot be staunched, said Juan Pedro Sarmuda, an expert in migration issues at the Ibero-American University. At the most it will remain steady, or fall off slightly, over the next 15 years, but only if the Mexican economy continues growing, he told IPS.

Mexico and the United States, partners with Canada in the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which opened up the cross- border flow of goods, but not people, must redefine its agenda, because emigration is a phenomenon that cannot be curbed, he argued.

The Mexican economy has grown at an average annual rate of 5.1 percent over the past four years. If, in the worst-case scenario, the economy slumps, emigration to the United States could increase even further, CONAPO warns.

But if the current level of economic growth remains steady, by 2015 the current total of 1,000 immigrants a day could drop, according to Sarmuda.

Senior officials from the two countries, which share a 3,200-km border, meet at least once a year to assess bilateral relations.

Authorities reach agreement on measures to curb the trafficking of persons and crack down on organised syndicates that foment the flow of migrants. But tension flares up because Mexico sees it as a broader social issue, while Washington frequently takes a strictly police approach to the problem.

In a 1997 study financed by US and Mexican authorities, experts from both countries argued that the immigration policy followed by the government of Bill Clinton had failed.

Clinton ordered that police controls be stepped up, walls and fences built, sanctions stiffened and war technology used to detect movement along the border. But none of those measures curtailed the flow.

More than 20 million Mexicans and their descendants live in the United States, comprising one of the largest ethnic groups in that country.

Mexicans, like most Latin Americans living in the United States, tend to take the lowest paid jobs, and have few years of formal schooling. Rights groups frequently protest the discrimination and xenophobia suffered by the immigrants.

The chairman of the Federal Reserve, Alan Greenspan, stated in January that the best policy would be to open US borders to legal, orderly immigration. His remarks stirred controversy at home, but met with applause in Mexico.

“The United States can no longer continue to ignore the fact that immigrants are a productive, not criminal, element in society. For that reason, Greenspan’s position seems sensible, and I hope it produces a response,” said Sarmuda.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags