Thursday, November 19, 2026
Abid Aslam
- The World Bank has launched a pioneering effort to set up an international market in ‘greenhouse gases’, which are blamed for global warming.
The lending agency says its ‘Prototype Carbon Fund’ (PCF), launched Tuesday, will promote the transfer of finance and climate- friendly technology to developing countries. The scheme remains controversial among environmentalists, however.
The PCF is like a mutual fund – except that, in this case, the securities traded are not stocks and bonds but tons of carbon.
Carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases are released mainly when fossil fuels such as coal and oil are burned. Most scientists blame them for raising atmospheric temperatures, with far-reaching implications for climate, health, and economic activity.
Four governments and nine companies from the industrialised world have committed some 85 million dollars to the fund, becoming investors in efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in poorer countries.
Eligible investments will include efforts to promote renewable energy, such as solar power, or to improve existing projects by boosting energy efficiency and replacing “dirty” technologies with “clean” alternatives – for example, by switching from incandescent to compact fluorescent light bulbs.
The PCF is capped at 150 million dollars and operations are scheduled to begin in April. The Bank expects to invest the fund’s capital in 20 or so projects over the next three years. Officials says most of these will emerge from the agency’s own portfolio but may also originate from the private sector.
The resulting decreases in emissions will be independently verified and then transferred to the fund’s investors in the form of certificates rather than cash.
Participants in the scheme are betting that, eventually, they will be able to convert their PCF certificates into licenses to spew equivalent amounts of carbon into the atmosphere.
Thus, they would be able to use the certificates to meet their commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions under the 1997 Kyoto Protocol. The treaty requires countries to cut their emissions at least to 5.2 percent below their 1990 levels by the end of 2012.
Rules to govern emissions trading remain to be agreed when countries that have signed the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change meet later this year. Environmentalists have chided the World Bank for seeking to influence the outcome by pushing through its own model of a market-based approach to the problem.
Critics also have assailed emissions trading as enabling recalcitrant, wealthy countries to effectively buy all their reductions abroad rather than improve performance at home.
Supporters counter that the scheme makes economic sense because carbon-reducing projects are cheapest in the Third World.
“There are many opportunities to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases in developing countries at a cost of between five dollars and 15 dollars a ton of carbon,” says PCF Manager and World Bank official Ken Newcombe. “This compares with a marginal abatement cost of upwards of 50 dollars a ton of carbon in advanced countries.”
The difference in cost, Newcombe adds, “provides the opportunity for mutually beneficial trading relationships.”
The Bank will broker negotiations on a price for the emissions reductions and Newcombe says he hopes to settle this at around 20 dollars per ton of carbon.
Governments participating in the PCF are those of Finland, the Netherlands, Norway and Sweden. Private-sector investors include Japan’s Mitsubishi and Mitsui trading houses, a number of the country’s electric power companies, and the Belgian electric utility Electrabel.
Potential participants include Statoil and NorskHydro of Norway, French utility Gaz de France, US-based Environment Banc and Exchange, and SK Power of Denmark.
These are “firms with significant investment resources but also an underlying interest in the carbon emissions market because they are large-scale energy industries,” says Charles Feinstein, chief of the World Bank’s Global Climate Change Unit.
Some countries already have fulfiled their commitments under the Kyoto Protocol. For those that have not, however, trading schemes like the PCF are “a low-pain option,” says Charlie Kronick, director of Britain’s Climate Action Network.
“As currently defined, the central feature of an emissions trading regime will allow for notional pollution reductions, where country one can buy the unused emissions of country two,” Kronick explains.
Trouble is, “emissions that are avoided (can simply) be traded back into the atmosphere, with no actual emission reduction taking place,” he adds.
The world can afford to keep burning fossil fuels at the current rate – releasing six billion tons of carbon per year – for less than 40 years before courting major ecosystem damage, according to the environmental group Greenpeace.
Given the high stakes involved, many ‘greens’ favour direct state intervention to promote renewable energy. Ideas include withdrawing an estimated 300 billion dollars in worldwide subsidies for fossil fuel use and exploration.