Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Costa Ricans Win Triple Damages from Chemicals Giant

Elizabeth Walker

NEW YORK, Aug 17 2001 (IPS) - The largest U.S. chemical company has been handed defeat in a court battle over a fungicide blamed for destroying crops and causing birth defects and health problems.

The ruling, in a case brought by two Costa Rica-based plant nurseries, could set a precedent for more than 100 cases waiting to go to trial against DuPont Co.

A jury in the U.S. state of Florida has ordered the company to pay 88.5 million dollars to settle a claim for damages under a civil lawsuit over Benlate, a pesticide that kills fungi and their spores. Once among the most widely used fungicides in the world, the chemical has been blamed for environmental and health problems over the past decade.

DuPont denied the product is harmful, scored the jury’s Aug. 10 findings as “based on a smear campaign and pseudo-science”, and said it would appeal the decision.

Adam Moscowitz, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, expressed satisfaction with the outcome. “We look forward to having our other cases, which are pending in the same court, being heard by a jury as well,” he said.

Claims pertaining to Benlate and amounting to more than 150 million dollars are pending in Florida’s Dade County.

In last week’s ruling, the jury found DuPont liable for damages stemming from negligence, fraud, and racketeering.

Jurors heard evidence for the first time that DuPont conducted secret Benlate tests in 1992 and then destroyed dead and dying plants, mislabeled documents, and produced illegible records in an effort to conceal negative results.

DuPont criticised the court’s exclusion of certain evidence and noted that jurors were not told that lawsuits by the growers brought in Costa Rica had already been thrown out by courts there.

“The conclusion that it is a crime for a company to defend its product, particularly based on a smear campaign and pseudo- science, as this trial was, is an absurdity,” the company said in a statement. It plans to appeal the ruling.

Under Florida’s Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO), the awards to the two nurseries, Palmas y Bambu and Productura de Smillas, have been tripled. Palmas had been awarded 15.5 million dollars and Productura, 14 million dollars. In addition, DuPont will be responsible for the plaintiffs’ legal fees, which may also be subject to a multiplier.

Racketeering charges in this case involve putting out a defective product as well as a cover-up of the evidence. Similar evidence is presented in criminal racketeering cases, but the standard of proof in a civil case is lower. RICO has traditionally been used in criminal cases against members of organised crime syndicates.

The two growers sued for compensatory damages for crop losses dating back to 1990. Witnesses testified that some plants treated with Benlate became too distorted to sell, grew to only 10 percent of their expected height, or dropped all of their leaves soon after treatment.

When farmers in several countries first complained in 1991 that Benlate ravaged fruit orchards and vegetable crops, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) temporarily recalled the product and DuPont initially paid more than 500 million dollars to cover growers’ losses.

A year later, after conducting field tests that DuPont claimed proved the product safe, the company halted payments of crop damage claims. Hundreds of lawsuits resulted, 120 of which are still pending. Litigation and settlement charges related to Benlate totaled 1.3 billion dollars over the last 10 years. Sales of the product amounted to 96 million dollars in 2000.

DuPont blamed a contaminant found in some boxes of Benlate for the reported problems, but complaints of crop damage continued well after the contaminants had been eliminated.

So far, lawsuits for major birth defects and health problems blamed on Benlate have been unsuccessful.

In a 1996 case, the parents of a boy born without eyes after the mother was sprayed with Benlate was awarded 4 million dollars in damages. Although the ruling was later overturned on appeal, similar birth defects in areas where Benlate is used have been reported in Australia, Britain, Canada, and New Zealand.

DuPont was previously ordered to pay damages in two separate cases for poisoned shrimp populations in Ecuador caused by Benlate run- off. Benlate has also been linked to fungal resistance.

The company has announced plans to pull Benlate from the market by the end of the year, citing the bother and cost of litigation.

“Benlate is a pesticide that should have been taken off the market years ago,” said Monica Moore, programme director for the non-governmental Pesticide Action Network North America. “It’s tragic that this kind of economic, environmental, and human health harm has to happen before the company takes action.”

Benlate’s withdrawal from the market notwithstanding, critics say DuPont’s behaviour has not inspired confidence in the company’s claims that the fungicide is “a good and worthwhile product” that is safe when used as directed.

DuPont sought to shield information about its fungicide through protective orders and confidentiality agreements. In addition to the ruling in the recent racketeering case, the company has been reprimanded five times by courts around the country for abusive litigation tactics and misconduct, including concealing evidence that supported the growers’ claims.

The EPA also filed two unsuccessful administrative complaints against DuPont.

Following a settlement with 20 farmers in 1996, DuPont made a secret agreement with the growers’ lawyers, paying the attorneys 6.4 million dollars on the condition that they would never again bring a Benlate case against the chemical company.

Moore said the removal of a single pesticide from the market only after years of damage claims and company misconduct exposes crucial problems in the regulation of toxic chemicals.

“It’s not enough to take pesticides off the market,” she said. “There has to be a much greater level of support for ecologically compatible pest control. The system where every chemical is innocent until proven guilty is a dysfunctional system.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags