Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, North America

LABOUR-U.S.: Contention Clouds Outlook for Immigration Reform

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Aug 10 2001 (IPS) - The United States and Mexico have reached broad agreement on resolving the status of millions of undocumented Mexican immigrants. But the issue is far from settled, with U.S. politicians, employers, labour leaders, and civic groups all at odds over the administration’s plans.

Secretary of State Colin Powell and Attorney General John Ashcroft met their Mexican counterparts – Foreign Minister Jorge Castaneda and Attorney General Santiago Creel – here Thursday to discuss the immigration problem. Their talks laid the groundwork for a meeting here next month between U.S. President George W. Bush and Mexican President Vicente Fox.

“We want to make sure that we have a humane approach to the solution of the migration challenge,” Powell told reporters at the State Department after the meeting. “We want to make sure that migration to the United States from Mexico is safe, legal, orderly, and dignified.”

Specific reforms remain to be worked out but these would respect “the enormously valuable role that Mexican immigrants continue to play in helping us in building our nation,” he said, adding that the administration also would ensure that the changes do not disadvantage U.S. workers.

Castaneda added that the measures would take into account “the rights and the benefits Mexicans need – all Mexicans.”

Proposals under discussion include allowing Mexicans already in the United States, and those seeking entry, to work legally on a temporary basis. So far, the number of Mexicans who would be eligible to benefit has not been discussed, officials say.

Some three million undocumented Mexican immigrants live in the United States, out of a total of between seven million and nine million so-called illegal aliens, according to official estimates.

For Mexico, the émigrés are an important source of repatriated earnings. They also have become an important political bloc: Fox’s election campaign included a number of stump speeches and outreach efforts among Mexican communities in the U.S. states of California and Texas.

For the United States, the Mexicans represent potential help with an anticipated labour shortage. According to government estimates, some 154 million U.S. workers will be available to fill 161 million U.S. jobs by 2008. Officials from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, which represents employers, met Castaneda and Creel earlier this week and support giving Mexican workers temporary legal status.

The AFL-CIO, the premier umbrella for U.S. labour organisations, has dropped its traditional opposition to migrant workers as it now turns to immigrant communities in a bid to boost union membership.

For his part, Bush is wooing increasingly important Hispanic voters. More than 60 percent of them are of Mexican origin.

Census figures show that the Hispanic population grew 58 percent during the 1990s, to 35 million. Hispanics now rival non-Hispanic blacks as the largest U.S. minority group. Bush garnered 35 percent of the Hispanic vote in last year’s elections.

Nevertheless, the U.S.-Mexican moves have angered immigrant communities from countries other than Mexico, who would be left out of any deal and continue to face deportation.

In addition, labour unions are critical of the temporary work permits proposed by the U.S. administration, saying the arrangement will see the return of abuses – including low wages and restrictions on labour rights – common to past ‘guest worker’ programmes.

The unions, rights advocates, and religious groups are lobbying for broader changes in immigration law. Members of this coalition plan to travel to Central America next week to meet government officials in Nicaragua, Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador. Union officials already have held talks with Fox and other Mexican officials.

The coalition is planning events in 26 cities later this month to build grassroots support. Members have demanded that all undocumented workers and their families be granted permanent legal status; that migrant workers be assured full workplace rights, including the right to unionise; and that new laws and enforcement be used to punish employers that hire undocumented workers.

However, anti-immigrant groups and many members of Congress are opposed to any change beyond allowing some Mexicans to stay temporarily.

Granting legal residency to all Mexican immigrants now living in the United States is “very bad policy (because) it rewards lawlessness,” says Senator Phil Gramm, who is from Bush’s Republican Party and the president’s home state of Texas.

Other key Republicans have said they oppose any changes to U.S. immigration law unless these are accompanied by a thorough overhaul of the Immigration and Naturalisation Service (INS). James Ziglar, the INS chief, took part in Thursday’s U.S.-Mexican talks.

It could be months before all the differences are resolved and the necessary political support for a specific plan is mobilised. Although the U.S. and Mexican officials sounded upbeat during their joint news conference late Thursday, the visiting delegates later told Mexican reporters that next month’s visit by Fox “isn’t a deadline.”

Fox said in late July that Mexicans working in the United States contribute to the U.S. economy and “shouldn’t have to walk around like criminals or stay hidden.” He also has voiced grave concern over the numbers of Mexicans who die while attempting to cross the border and who suffer mistreatment once they reach the United States.

Bush spoke to those concerns last week. “We’ve got hard-working citizens who are willing to walk 400 miles of desert in blistering heat to find work,” he said. “Our nation must treat these folks with respect and help them when they’re hurting.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags