Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT-US: Mining Safeguards Hang in the Balance

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Jun 7 2001 (IPS) - Environmentalists and mining executives anxiously await a government decision on whether to suspend mining regulations designed to protect the environment and public health.

Both sides lobbied the Bureau of Land Management, a unit within the interior department that is pushing to suspend the rules, which govern hardrock mining. According to the government’s Environmental Protection Agency, the industry is the country’s top polluter.

Gale Norton, the interior secretary, proposed in late March that the rules, in place only since January, be suspended. The move angered environmentalists but pleased mining executives opposed to clauses requiring them to finance any future clean-ups tied to past contamination by their mines.

The land bureau is expected to announce its decision mid-July. A 45-day public comment period in response to Norton’s announcement ended last month. Officials said some 30,000 people had submitted comments and that those in support of preserving the current mining safeguards outnumbered those against by a margin of 50 to one.

The current regulations were put in place following four years of study and public hearings. They require mining companies to post clean-up bonds before mining commences. Such bonds ensure that if a mine causes pollution, enough money is available to clean it up.

If the government strikes down the January regulations, a previous set of rules written in 1980 would once again take effect. Environmentalists and communities affected by mining pollution said that under those rules, private companies were able to mine public lands and then declare bankruptcy, leaving taxpayers to pay the clean-up bill.

“The old rules the administration wants to return to have allowed environmental devastation on an enormous scale on public lands,” said Steve D’Esposito, executive director of the Washington-based Mineral Policy Centre. Overturning the rules would amount to a violation of the National Environmental Policy Act,” he charged.

Environmentalists said the 1980 rules were not written with the capabilities of modern mining technologies in mind. Since then, the industry has dramatically changed to incorporate the use of cyanide and sulfuric acid in open-pit mines that can be thousands of metres deep and cover thousands of hectares.

Mining companies, however, said the disposal of mining wastes is already strictly regulated through the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, Water Act, and various state laws.

Jack Gerard, president and CEO of the National Mining Association said the new rules would reduce the company’s output and could mean the loss of mining jobs in rural communities.

“This action by the Bureau of Land Management demonstrates its pursuit of balance between the important goals of environmental protection and responsible development of our nation’s mineral resources,” Gerard said.

The Association and Denver-based Newmont Mining Corp. both filed lawsuits seeking to block the new rules.

Hardrock mining is at the top of the Environmental Protection Agency’s 2001 Toxic Release Inventory. The government body found that mining is responsible for more than 96 percent of all arsenic released into the environment.

According to the Mineral Policy Centre, hardrock mining has contaminated 40 percent of the headwaters in the western United States. Environmentalists and officials estimate that the cost to clean up past mining damage will be between 32 billion dollars and 72 billion dollars.

Jill Lancelot, legislative director for the non-governmental group Taxpayers for Common Sense, seized on those estimates and industry subsidies that would be restored if the January rules were overturned. “If George W. Bush is truly a fiscal conservative, he will not roll these rules back,” she said.

Although all taxpayers share the clean-up costs, residents of the western states where most of the hardrock mining takes place would feel the greatest impact.

Stephanie Shammel, a rancher from the state of Montana, recently came to the capital to urge the administration not to repeal the mining rules.

“Water on my property, for my cattle has been contaminated by hardrock mining companies,” she said. Rolling back the regulations, she added, would be “a slap in the face of all Westerners who expect fair play.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags