Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

POLITICS: Third World Nations Renew Demand for Racial Bias Probe

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Mar 26 2001 (IPS) - The Group of 77, a coalition of 133 developing nations, is reiterating its demand for a new investigation into charges of racial discrimination in the recruitment and promotion of staffers in the 13,000-strong UN Secretariat.

One Third World delegate told IPS that several members of the Group of 77 were unhappy that the Secretariat has failed to produce a report on the question of “racial discrimination” requested by the General Assembly two years ago.

In a draft resolution, currently being discussed by the UN’s Administrative and Budgetary Committee, the Group requests the Secretary-General “to ensure, without exception, uniform application of the regulations and rules of the Organisation in all departments of the UN Secretariat, in accordance with the relevant resolutions of the General Assembly”.

The draft resolution also “reiterates that the recruitment, appointment and promotion of staff shall be made without distinction as to race, sex or religion, in accordance with the principles of the UN charter and the provisions of the Staff Regulations and Rules of the United Nations”.

In a report to the 189-member General Assembly last September, UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan pointed out that the Secretariat “is not in a position to conduct a comprehensive review of the issue of racial discrimination due to the limitations of its current information systems”.

A primary reason, he said, is the fact that the Secretariat does not record the “race” of individual staff members at any particular point – even in job application forms.

“Therefore, it is impossible for the Secretariat to generate meaningful statistics based on race or to make even general observations which are supported by firm statistical evidence,” he added.

Furthermore, if nationality were to be used as the basis for the review of career progression patterns, staff members of the same nationality might be of different ethnic/racial backgrounds, he noted.

But the Group of 77 says it is not buying this argument. In its draft resolution, the Group “regrets” that the report on racial discrimination requested by the General Assembly was not concluded due to “the limitations in the current information systems of the Secretariat”.

If this is the excuse for the Secretariat’s inability to probe charges of racial discrimination, the Group of 77 is asking the Secretary- General to conduct an investigation through the Office of Internal Oversight Services (OIOS), the UN’s independent oversight body created in 1994.

The results of such an investigation – “relating to the issue of discrimination due to nationality, sex or religion in recruitment, promotion and placement” – should be documented in a report to the General Assembly at its 56th session in September this year, the draft says.

Asked about the charges of “job discrimination”, Annan told reporters last week that the United Nations has a very open and transparent system for recruitment and promotion.

“I have tried to improve gender equality and to bring as many women on board as possible, and I think we have done quite well in the last couple of years. We cannot say it’s perfect and there is much more to be done.”

Annan said he was aware of “some accusations that there is racism in the Secretariat in terms of appointment and recruitment”.

He admitted that the General Assembly asked him to look into the charges back in 1999. “We did set up a group to look into it, and they did not come up with the kind of accusation you are implying here. But of course we will be vigilant.”

“If there are elements of racism and gender mistreatment or harassment, we will act very firmly and without pity,” he insisted.

In a preliminary report, the Working Group has said that most staff members from Europe and North America were offered higher-level jobs – at the time of their recruitment – than their counterparts from developing nations in Asia, Africa and Latin America.

“This was the case even when this group appeared to possess higher qualifications and prior work experience,” the Working Group said in its initial findings.

Moreover, staff members from Europe and North America also “seemed to be able to advance much faster than the others”, it noted.

While it would be premature to establish a pattern, “there were cases of staff members with agile mobility from one department to another usually with a promotion, as well as intra-departmental and inter-agency mobility”, according to the report.

In some cases, it said, “outside intervention” played a role in the re-assignment and subsequent promotion of a staff member.

Although the report of the Working Group has not been released as a UN document, it is now the subject of discussion among members of the Group of 77.

As of June last year, the total number of staffers in the Secretariat was in the region of 13,164, of which 7,470 were funded by the UN’s regular budget and about 5,694 from extra-budgetary resources.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags