Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Nuclear Reactors Blamed for Harming Endangered Marine Mammals

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Feb 23 2001 (IPS) - The cooling systems of nuclear power plants across the country are killing and harming marine life, including endangered species such as sea turtles, warn conservation organisations.

A report released here Thursday by advocacy groups says 95 percent of the fish, fish larvae and other marine organisms that are sucked into certain cooling systems of nuclear reactors are scalded and then discharged back into the water as lifeless sediment.

“These high destruction rates can overtake recovery rates, resulting in extensive depletion of the affected species,” says the report, co- written by the Nuclear Information and Resource Service, the Safe Energy Communication Council, and Standing for Truth about Radiation.

The cooling system, known as the “once-through” system, sucks in large volumes of water from a nearby body of water in order to cool the reactor. A typical 1000-megawatt reactor requires as much as 130,000 litres of cooling water per minute, says the report. About 50 reactors around the country use this system.

Larger mammals, including endangered sea turtles, crocodiles, and manatees, as well as seals and ducks also end up drawn in by the cooling system and they drown or get burnt, says Linda Gunter, spokesperson for the Safe Energy Communication Council here.

“As marine creatures pass through the reactor they are scalded and pulverised,” she says.

At the St. Lucie nuclear reactor in Florida as many as 900 endangered sea turtles have been taken in by the cooling system annually, says the report. Reactors in the state of Connecticut, known as Millstone, have been blamed for the depletion of the flounder population.

“While fishermen are fined for illegal catches, the Millstone reactors massacre vast quantities of fish and lobsters with impunity,” says Gunter.

She says that 90 percent of a population of black abalone, also a protected species, was destroyed because of the cooling system at the Diablo Canyon reactor in California.

After marine creatures pass through the reactor they are discharged back into the water, creating debris that can cloud the surrounding water and block light from reaching undersea plants, says the report. “The debris that is discharged blocks light, killing kelp and micro-organisms essential to the food chain,” it says.

The report notes that the wastewater is discharged at hotter temperatures forcing marine life suited to colder temperatures to move, disrupting delicately balanced ecosystems.

The nuclear industry claims that the warm water circulated back into the ocean or lake fosters habitat for marine mammals, like manatees, that prefer water at higher temperatures. But according to the report, when the warm water flow is diminished or halted because of maintenance or repair work on the reactor, these species are often “cold-stunned” and some die of hypothermia.

The nuclear industry argues that conservationists exaggerate the impact cooling systems have on the marine environment.

Steve Kerekes, a spokesperson for the Nuclear Energy Institute, a corporate lobby group based here in Washington, says the industry has taken measures to protect wildlife, including the installation of screens to stop fish and other marine life from entering the cooling system.

“The US nuclear energy industry takes extraordinary measures to protect ecosystems and to minimise any adverse impact,” he says.

In response to the report, Kerekes says that the “once-through” systems described are not unique to nuclear power plants. “This is a situation that can occur with any kind of energy generating facility that uses steam to turn turbines,” he says.

Nuclear watch-dogs claim, however, that the industry is violating the US Clean Water Act that requires nuclear power plants to use the “best technology available” for minimising adverse environmental impacts caused by cooling systems.

David Lochbaum, an engineer with the Union of Concerned Scientists says that 11 nuclear reactors across the country use a different type of cooling system that involves a cooling tower that lets steam off into the air. This system uses about 10 times less ocean, lake or river water than the “once through” system, he says.

“The once-through cooling system also discharges nearly ten times as much water – and at high temperatures – to the ocean, lake or river as the cooling tower system,” says Lochbaum. The nuclear industry, however, argues that the tower cooling system is more expensive to install.

Paul Gunter, with the Nuclear Information and Resource Service, says the US Environmental Protection Agency is also to blame because it has failed to establish national performance standards for reactor cooling systems.

“When faced with the opportunity to enforce ‘best available technology’ standards, the EPA has buckled to industry pressure and left the marine environment to pay the price,” he says.

The report also claims that the nuclear industry is violating the Endangered Species Act, which requires federal agencies to consult with either the National Marine Fisheries Service or the Fish and Wildlife Service before taking any action that might harm an endangered species.

By law, nuclear reactors are allowed to kill – or “take” – a limited amount of endangered marine life. But, according to Eric Glitzenstein, a lawyer specialising in wildlife protection issues, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission has allowed the nuclear industry to raise or even eliminate these “take” limits, without consulting environmental protection authorities.

“The nuclear industry should not be permitted to pass itself off as innocuous or friendly to wildlife at least until it and the federal regulators who oversee it bring themselves into full compliance with the federal laws designed to protect and conserve wildlife,” says Glitzenstein, who practices here in Washington.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags