Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Human Rights, Labour

RIGHTS-VIETNAM: Crackdown on Child Beggars Ignores Key Issues

Tran Dinh Thanh Lam

HO CHI MINH CITY, Nov 10 2003 (IPS) - Nguyen Thi Thu became a beggar when her parents migrated here three years ago. Each day, the seven-year-old walks the streets and begs for money. Her parents sit nearby, at the ready to collect whatever kind-hearted passers-by drop into Thu’s palm.

There are many like Thu. According to some estimates, six out of 10 children who beg in the city live with parents or relatives. For the adults, such a source of money is fairly assured and requires no investment on their part.

Indeed, the practice is so lucrative that beggars with no children of their own ”hire” babies or small children to accompany them, so as to play upon the pity of would-be alms givers.

Now, city authorities have launched a drive to clean out the streets in preparation for the 22nd South-east Asian Games, which Vietnam is hosting in December 2003. Their objective is to present the city as clean, friendly, green and free of what they term ”social evils”.

High on their agenda is ridding the city of child beggars. Already, one father has been arrested apparently for coercing his children to beg, dozens of street children have been rounded up and sent back to their families, and others with nowhere to go have been placed in juvenile centres.

With over 100,000 foreign arrivals in October and September this year, officials say that Ho Chi Minh City is bringing in the visitors and has rebounded from the effects of the Severe Acquired Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) outbreak earlier this year.

Tourists may welcome the temporary respite from poor children crowding around to beg or hawk souvenirs, but social workers point out that the city needs to adopt comprehensive, long-term measures to control working children, and to protect them from exploitation and sexual abuse.

”It’s unrealistic to eradicate child labour in Ho Chi Minh City,” explained social researcher Do Thi Loan. ”The authorities should prevent children from working in dangerous jobs, and control the level of child labour.”

City authorities are all too aware of the issues involved. They have suggested that child labour can be managed by placing orphans in foster care, returning migrating children to their homes, and offering the remainder a chance to study towards a job as they grow older.

The key factor, they stress, is education, and they would like families to be convinced about the need for giving their children an education.

Nguyen Dai Dong, head of the labour department in the Ministry of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs, has pointed out that close to 45 percent of child labourers in the city are between six and 14 years old, and that one in every three child workers has not completed primary school.

”Poverty is the main reason children work on the streets,” said Phan Thanh Minh, a senior official of the city’s Committee for Population, Family and Children. ”Most of them are not from the city, arriving in the southern economic hub either by themselves, or with their families. All hope to find a chance to earn something to live on.”

A recent survey conducted by Loan among Ho Chi Minh City street children found over half of those surveyed support their families. Nor is this support reliant solely on begging – her survey also found that apart from begging, almost 70 percent of street children sell goods or lottery tickets, while 30 percent take to manual labour or do odd jobs like shine shoes for a living.

One such shoeshine boy is seven-year-old Nguyen Trong. From southern Bac Lieu province, Trong said his mother is a street vendor and that his brother also shines shoes. In a day’s work, Trong might earn only 10,000 dong (about 65 U.S. cents).

From the same province is Bui Van, who was brought to the city by his mother after his father died. ”I sell lottery tickets and chewing gum, and my mother works as a street vendor,” Van said. ”Every day I give her what I earn, which is between 7,000 and 15,000 dong.”

Children who find work in private companies may earn more than those who earn their living from the streets. However, they are exposed to other threats, like hazardous jobs and exploitative employers.

Doanh is 15 and comes from the northern province of Bac Giang, where her parents live. She signed a two-year contract with a private garments company, and is to receive four million dong (255 dollars) at the end of that period.

Like others who find such work, Doanh is very vulnerable. Working children have neither protection nor welfare, and are targets of abuse and exploitation. Often when working for private companies, they are sacked after two years of work, at a time when they are entitled to more pay.

On the other hand street children, said Minh, are exposed to dangers like drugs and paedophile tourists. Data collected by the authorities shows that at least 30 percent of street children are unaware of the dangers of drug abuse or HIV/AIDS, even though close to a fifth have been sexually abused.

The city’s clean-up programme, while well-intentioned, appears to have made little impact on the ground.

Beggars and their children still roam the streets, and the authorities make appeals to people about not encouraging the practice by giving them money, and by setting up a toll-free hotline to call the police whenever a beggar is spotted.

Loan has proposed that the authorities establish a system of penalties for businesses or individuals who exploit child labour, and for poor families to be monitored. ”The problem of child labour needs to be solved as part of the city’s social and economic development programme,” she concluded.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags