Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

RIGHTS-BANGLADESH: Poor Detainees Become ‘Forgotten Prisoners’

Tabibul Islam

DHAKA, Mar 15 2002 (IPS) - Latifa (not her real name) was only five years old when her older brother Anwar, then 20, was arrested on suspicion of being involved in a murder.

For the next two decades, Anwar would remain behind bars even though the police never found enough evidence to formally file charges against him, which is why his case never went to trial.

Born to poor parents, Anwar would still be in the Dhaka Central Jail today had it not been for Latifa, who became acquainted with her brother only when she was already all grown up.

Now 24, Latifa sought the help of a lawyer and succeeded in securing bail for Anwar just this January. He was subsequently released from jail upon orders of a session judge.

Activists say there are thousands of other Anwars who have fallen through the cracks of Bangladesh’s justice system and are still languishing in jails — some on suspicion of the flimsiest of crimes — years after they were first arrested, and without their cases ever being heard in court.

Political activist Ssfura Khatun, who has experienced being arrested, says, ” I have seen a female prisoner who was put behind the bar for stealing a (piece of) bread and lodged in jail for more than three years without trail.”

Legal experts say most of such detainees, whom eminent jurist Dr Kamal Hossain has taken to describing as “forgotten prisoners”, come from families that are too impoverished to hire a lawyer, post bail and do a costly and time-consuming battle in court.

The experts also say that oftentimes, the prisoners and their relatives simply do not know that they have rights that they can assert and can demand authorities to respect.

Indeed, since 1966, the government has been allocating nearly 40,000 U.S. dollars every year to render legal aid free of cost to detainees or prisoners who are unable to hire lawyers to plead their cases.

Each of the country’s 64 district headquarters is in fact supposed to have a legal aid committee that would take care of these cases.

But experts say that indigent detainees rarely know that these committees exist, let alone seek their help. As a result, they say, the head of the legal aid committee is sitting on an accumulated amount of about 2.4 million dollars that is simply lying unused.

Another result is that the country’s 80 prisons, which have a total capacity of 24,000 people, are now overflowing. Experts estimate that there are at least 70,000 people behind bars in Bangladesh at present.

Recent media reports also say that in Dhaka Central Jail alone, there about 1,500 people who have already spent more than three years there without their cases being heard.

Meantime, legal advocate Anwaruzzaman, who uses only one name, estimates that the total number of detainees across the country who have had not had the benefit of a trial could be at least 5,000.

He observes, “These people have been passing their days with a sense of uncertainty as they have no means to engage lawyers to fight their cases.”

Anwaruzzaman says that had there been a timely intervention of lawyers, an overwhelming majority of the prisoners who have now logged three years in jail without trial would have been out after serving two- or three-month terms for their minor offences.

He adds that some others should have been set free within a week of their arrest since they were taken to jail on mere suspicion of a crime, without the police producing any evidence.

Law and Justice Minister Moudud Ahmed told Parliament last week that the legal aid committee at the district level would be “reactivated” to render free legal advice to poor prisoners. He also reported that there are more than half a million cases now pending in courts across Bangladesh.

In the meantime, those behind bars have to put up with subhuman conditions, brought about partly by overcrowding.

One jail official notes that while the number of prisoners has increased over the years due to deterioration of law and order and slow judicial process, the accommodation capacity of the country’s prisons has not been increased.

The Dhaka Central jail, built in the 19th century, was supposed to house a maximum of only 2,632 people. These days, officials say that the jail has anywhere from 8,500 to 9,500 prisoners.

In the Gopalgonj district jail, located about 150 km south of Dhaka, some 600 prisoners are crammed in a facility that is supposed to accommodate only 75 people.

Prisoners thus have to wait for hours in the queue to use the toilet in Bangladeshi jails. Bathing is also a luxury. Here in the Dhaka, many of the thousands of inmates in the central jail go unwashed for months on end because there is only one washing room for all of them.

At many jails, inmates sleep in shifts because of shortage of space. There is also inadequate food and health facilities — if there are any at all — often lack essential medicines as well.

Women and child detainees suffer the most and are also most vulnerable to abuse. Activists say that some jail police apparently take advantage of women detainees, as do a number of the convicts.

Advocate Elena Khan say incidents of the sexual harassment of women prisoners often remain undetected as the victims are reluctant to disclose their experiences because of shame and social stigma and fear of further attack from the perpetrators.

Human rights activists also say that while torture of detainees is prohibited under the law, its practice is rampant. They say that too often, the police subject the people they arrest to various kinds of harassment and torture either to extract a confession or some kind of “monetary benefit”.

According to a preliminary report done by Odhikar, a coalition of human rights groups, inmates are also sometimes denied visiting rights or their family is turned away at the jail gate if they are unable to pay bribes.

Not surprisingly, some inmates seem to think dying is better than enduring what passes for a life in a Bangladeshi jail.

The ‘Daily Star’, an English-language newspaper based here in Dhaka, said in a report last month that “suicide seems to be the only way out for an increasing number of prisoners at the Dhaka Central Jail”, faced as they are with “unfriendly treatment and hostile living conditions”.

It said that there had been a significant number of suicide attempts at that jail in the last several months, some of which had been successful.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags