Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

CHILDREN-LATAM: Adoption Laws at Crossroads

Daniel Gatti

MONTEVIDEO, Mar 31 1999 (IPS) - The extreme variations in adoption laws in Latin America, coupled with the lack of resources in most organizations that handle adoptions, has caused frequent cases of “trafficking” in children to the United States and Europe, say sociologists.

In most of Central America, there is a legal vacuum concerning the issue, while in Uruguay, legislation is so restrictive that couples wishing to adopt a child have to wait up to three years. In Argentina, meanwhile, a change in the adoption law has liberalized the current system, allowing adopted persons to inquire about their biological origins.

Social workers from the region, meeting at a symposium here, heard the complaints of would-be parents about the slowness of the Uruguayan state system and how there was a waiting list of 200 couples. This caused prospective parents to resort to other channels, sometimes illegal.

The National Institute of Minors (INAME), the government entity in charge of adoption in Uruguay, places some 50 children in nmew homes every year. Outside Montevideo, however, judges and doctors at public hospitals often decide where to place abandoned children.

Ana Maria Mendez, director of the Institute for Adoption and Adoptive Legitimation (ILAYA), which depends on INAME, said that these authorities “place children without the technical evaluation of the Institute”.

“They only guide themselves by the recommendation cards that the candidates themselves present”, she said.

Mendez said that one of the reasons for the long waits that the candidates must endure is that many parents want only very small children, with ethnic characteristics similar to their own and no physical defects, however minor even if they can be easily corrected.

Some of the speakers at the symposium said that they knew that “in the interior of Uruguay, finding a child is very easy, especially near the border with Brazil.”

Iris Vega, a lawyer for ILAYA, explained that the placing of babies without technical intervention, besides being illegal, is an action that could have very serious consequences for the child.

When the ILAYA places a baby for adoption, she said, there is a follow-up of the parents for one year. Only after that period, is the adoption process completed.

Numerous candidates for adoption of a child complain, nevertheless, about the tight requirements imposed by INAME.

“They practically require us to be model parents, perfect, as if that could exist. In reality, they don’t think about the children, that if they don’t get an adoptive home, they remain in the INAME centers where they live in much worse conditions than with people who will love them”, said one of the prospective candidates in an interview with a local magazine.

Meanwhile, in Argentina, where the situation of adoptive parents and children is similar to that in Uruguay, a new system allows any adopted person who is 18 years old, to find out their place of origin, what their birth was like and who was the birth mother.

An experiment initiated three years ago at the Office of the National Council of Minors and the Family was a precursor to this new civil right.

Maria Ester Benchuya, the office’s coordinator, said that people anywhere between eight and 73-years-old had contacted her organisation wanting to know their history.

“The demand has grown in the past few years, with the campaign to search for the children who were kidnaped by the military during the dictatorship (1979-1983), she said.

“Many adolescents adopted by the military and police showed up spontaneously to find out whether they had been kidnaped or legally adopted”, she added.

An estimated 500 children of people who “disappeared”, both Argentine and foreigners, were adopted illegally in the late 1970s – mostly by childless couples among the military.

Of these children, 62 recovered their real identity and most of returned to their biological families or are in regular contact with them.

The repetitive story lines of soap operas, in which there are characters who discover their real identities in dramatic situations, are also singled out as catalysts for the curiosity of adopted people to know about their past.

“Not everyone who comes to the office of the Council wants to know the name of their real mother”, said Patricia Carricart, a lawyer and head of the Department of Adoptions in Buenos Aires.

“I can recall, for example, the case of one man who had had children with malformations and wanted to know his clinical history in order to detect the hereditary factors for those anomalies”, said Carricart.

Benchuya said that “others come because they have memories of having brothers and sisters who, after being adopted, they never saw again”.

“These reunions are always very emotional, but the link that they forge is rarely a fraternal one. At most, they establish a solid friendship”, she said.

Carricart and Benchuya agreed that the new legal right, which has been extended to all adopted persons in Argentina, is a positive development.

However, they expressed concern over the fact that the law did not specify that the information must be transmitted to the person requesting it by a someone trained to deal with it.

“If the person receives their file at the counter of any court, learning the details of their past could cause them shock”, said Carricart. “Many of the children given up for adoption have been mistreated, abused, burned with cigarettes and even raped.”

Benchuya also said that there was also the right of the mother who gave her child up legally to a “substitute”, to protect herself from having her biological child “come knocking on her door”.

“We have to proceed with clearly defined criteria and extreme caution”, she concluded.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags