Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Tran Dinh Thanh Lam
- Few urban officials across Asia have been successful in decongesting their cities by resettling residents elsewhere.
Yet for one brief moment, the People’s Committee of Tan Binh District of Ho Chi Minh City thought it had finally come up with a winning resettlement plan.
To be sure, the plan the Committee had drawn up had a lot going for it. After all, the resettlement site is in the fertile Central Highlands, where the settlers would be given “virgin land” and provided with credit and means of production to set up farms.
Local officials there had even been hopeful that these farms would create a dynamic economic hub that could only make their region prosperous.
The programme was actually in line with efforts of Ho Chi Minh authorities to reduce the number of poor households here from almost 20 percent to eight percent. These efforts, in turn, were part of the national hunger alleviation and poverty reduction programme.
Unfortunately, the Tan Binh District committee overlooked a crucial detail — large areas within the resettlement site were full of unexploded mines and all sorts of ammunition.
Likewise, for those lucky enough to get land that did not have the deadly devices, a drought soon wreaked havoc on their farms.
Now hundreds of families in the “new economic zone” in the Central Highlands, comprising Gia Lai, Kontum and Daklak provinces, are torn between trying to make something out of arid and mined lands, or returning to the city where they will be considered illegal migrants.
The municipal Department of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs (DoLISA) in fact says that the vast majority of the 1.2 estimated migrants here come from the new economic zones set up by different localities.
These migrants are considered illegals because their certificates of residence for Ho Chi Minh were revoked after they left for the resettlement sites.
Many more are being held back in resettlement sites by the lack of a certificate of land-use rights.
“Only 45 out of the 175 households settled here have received a land-use right certificate, having paid all their debts to the New Economic Zone Development Centre (NEZDC),” explains Le Van Hai, a settler in the Central Highlands. “Without that document, you cannot sell the land.”
Thus, for now, many are resigned to whatever kind of life they can have in the resettlement sites, even if they are in heavily mined areas. Settler Nguyen Thi Hoa says, “When the first convoy of settlers landed here, bombs and shells were lying everywhere.”
Do Dai, 45, who received a plot in Height 710, says he has unearthed eight hand grenades and a ‘claymore’ mine from his land, using a mine detector. But when local authorities learned about his detector, they confiscated it without bothering to explain why.
epeatedly asked authorities to clear the ground and seem not be concerned,” says Do Dai. “So we have to do it ourselves.”
There have been casualties, such as Nguyen Thi Hong Pha, 36, who lost her arm while working on her land. Nguyen Van Nhan lost his leg after stumbling on a grenade, and has had to abandon the .45 hectare allocated to him.
Huyn Van Hao, the new economic zone land management officer, says, “Leaders at the Tan Binh district do know the situation. When someone falls on a mine, we stop the clearance process and allocate him or her another lot.”
But settlers say it is not that simple, since such “reassigned” land is usually claimed by other people. Says Nguyen Thi Hong Pha: “You have to reimburse them if you want to have the plot.”
To many, the land allocation policy itself seems to be flawed. Would-be settlers take part in a draw that allocates them the plots for their future farms. But the allocated land area has only a specific width to go by, leading to settlers claiming as much land as they could.
That same loophole, though, has enabled those who end up with mined plots to cobble together enough to sustain a farm. Nguyen Thi Hoa and her family of five, for example, managed to piece together an area where they were able to plant some 500 coffee plants.
According to the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MARD), the Central Highlands is blessed with rich soil that is ideal for coffee, rubber, tea and fruit trees.
That was why Doan Van Bay was so full of hope that his 200 coffee trees would prosper, and this which would enable him and his wife to buy more land on which to plant more trees.
Doan Van Bay was among the very first people from Tan Binh District to register for the resettlement programme. Having lost his job at a food processing cooperative, he thought it was the perfect solution to his never-ending problem of trying to make ends meet.
But a drought came, and the river at the resettlement site turned into a narrow spring. Many wells dried out. Doan Van Bay’s coffee trees soon got burned under the scorching sun. He applied for another loan and replanted, but with irrigation there still non- existent, his new trees are struggling to live.
A small plantation belonging to Li Thang, whose plot is close to the spring, is among the very few that survived the drought.
Li Thang’s 150 coffee trees, however, have been able to yield only 50 kilos of green beans. These are “just enough,” he says, “to pay for the workers, not speaking of new seeds and fertiliser”.
He adds that he is unsure whether he will try anew this year.